Abstract
Despite the fact that tremendous efforts have been made on the study of quasicrystals since their discovery in 1984, nucleation of quasicrystals—the emergence of a quasicrystal from a crystalline phase—still presents an unsolved problem. The difficulties lie in that quasicrystals and crystals are incommensurate structures in general, so there are no obvious epitaxial relations between them. We solved this problem by applying an efficient numerical method to Landau theory of phase transitions and obtained the accurate critical nuclei and transition pathways connecting crystalline and quasicrystalline phases. The proposed computational methodology not only reveals the mechanism of nucleation of quasicrystals, but also paves the way to investigate a wide range of physical problems undergoing the first-order phase transitions.
Introduction: The Challenge of Incommensurability
Since their discovery in 1984, quasicrystals (QCs) have challenged our understanding of solid-state physics. Unlike standard crystals, which possess repeating translational symmetry, quasicrystals exhibit long-range order with "forbidden" symmetries (e.g., 5-fold, 10-fold, or 12-fold). This lack of a common unit cell creates a significant computational hurdle known as incommensurability. Because the atomic patterns of a crystal and a quasicrystal do not geometrically align, modeling the transition from one to the other—specifically the nucleation process—has remained an elusive goal. Understanding the "critical nucleus," the unstable configuration that marks the tipping point of a phase transition, is essential for predicting how these materials form and transform.
Methodology: Mapping the Energy Landscape
To overcome these challenges, researchers utilized the Lifshitz–Petrich (LP) model, a Landau-type free-energy functional capable of describing systems with multiple characteristic length scales. This model allows for the emergence of various symmetries, including 2-, 6-, and 12-fold patterns.
The key innovation lies in the use of High-Index Saddle Dynamics (HiSD). While standard optimization techniques find local energy minima (stable phases), HiSD systematically identifies "saddle points" on the free-energy surface. These saddle points represent the transition states or critical nuclei. To handle the infinite nature of quasiperiodicity, the authors employed the crystalline approximant method, using large periodic structures that mimic the local environment of a quasicrystal.
Key Insights: The "Intermediate Bridge" and Ostwald’s Step Rule
A central discovery of this work is the identification of the Lamellar Quasicrystal (LQ) as a critical intermediate state. As shown in Figure 2, the LQ phase is periodic in one dimension and quasiperiodic in another, effectively serving as a structural bridge between the fully periodic 6-fold crystal (C6) and the 12-fold quasicrystal (QC).
The research identified two primary transition pathways:
- One-stage transition: A direct jump between phases characterized by a circular critical nucleus.
- Two-stage transition: A more energetically favorable route where the system first nucleates an ellipsoidal LQ phase before reaching the final state.
This finding provides a theoretical foundation for Ostwald’s Step Rule, which suggests that systems often transition through metastable intermediate states rather than jumping directly to the most stable phase. The ellipsoidal shape of the nuclei in the two-stage process reflects the broken symmetry of these intermediate states, contrasting with the spherical assumptions of classical nucleation theory.
Results: Quantifying the Transition
The numerical results confirm that the two-stage pathway is physically more probable due to lower energy barriers. For the transition from a 12-fold QC to a 6-fold crystal, the two-stage barrier ($\Delta f = 4.5 \times 10^{-6}$) is significantly lower than the one-stage barrier ($\Delta f = 5.3 \times 10^{-6}$).
The study also successfully mapped the transition from a disordered liquid to a 12-fold QC, identifying a circular critical nucleus that grows isotropically. By demonstrating how periodicity is broken sequentially in the two-stage process, the authors provide a mechanistic view of how incommensurate structures reconcile their geometric differences.
Conclusion and Future Directions
While this work marks a significant step forward, it relies on a mean-field approximation that excludes thermal fluctuations, which may play a role in real-world soft matter or metallic alloys. Additionally, the current study is limited to 2D systems; extending this methodology to 3D—where even more complex phases like the gyroid or icosahedral structures exist—remains a target for future research. Nevertheless, the proposed computational framework offers a powerful new tool for investigating first-order phase transitions across a wide range of physical systems.
Summary updated