Transition for adolescents with a rare disease: results of a nationwide German project

Corinna Grasemann, Jakob Höppner, Peter Burgard, Michael M. Schündeln, Nora Matar, Gabriele Müller, Heiko Krude, Reinhard Berner, Min Ae Lee‐Kirsch, Fabian Hauck, Kerstin Wainwright, S. Baumgarten, Janet Atinga, Jens Bauer, Eva Manka, Julia Körholz, Cordula Kiewert, A. Heinen, Tanita Kretschmer, Tobias Kurth, Janna Mittnacht, Christoph Schramm, Christoph Klein, Holm Graeßner, Olaf Hiort, Ania C. Muntau, Annette Grüters, Georg F. Hoffmann, Daniela ChoukairOrphanet 2023 · DOI

Abstract: The described transition pathway succeeds to improve health literacy in adolescents with RDs and can be implemented by paediatric care teams in any RD specialty. Patient empowerment was mainly achieved by individualized training and counselling.

Introduction: The "Medical Cliff" in Rare Disease Care

For adolescents living with chronic conditions, the transition from pediatric to adult medical care is often described as a "medical cliff." As patients "age out" of pediatric systems, up to 40% experience a significant gap in care. This discontinuity frequently leads to poor therapy adherence, symptom flare-ups, and in some cases, irreversible organ damage.

The challenge is particularly acute for those with Rare Diseases (RDs). With 5,000–8,000 distinct conditions, two major hurdles emerge: a "specialist vacuum" where adult physicians lack expertise in pediatric-onset ultra-rare diseases, and a "literacy gap" where patients, previously managed by parents, lack the skills to navigate the autonomous adult healthcare system.

The TRANSLATE NAMSE Transition Pathway

To address these systemic failures, the "TRANSLATE NAMSE" project implemented a standardized transition pathway across 10 German university hospitals. Managed by dedicated care coordinators, the process moved through four distinct phases designed to transform the patient from a passive recipient of care into an empowered manager of their own health.

The structured four-phase transition pathway from pediatric to adult care.

The pathway begins with a formal assessment of the patient's readiness (Questionnaire I), followed by individualized training sessions. These sessions (averaging 2.1 per patient) focus on disease-specific knowledge and system-navigation skills. The process culminates in a "joint transfer" consultation, where the pediatric specialist, the patient, and the new adult specialist meet to ensure a seamless handover of care.

Addressing the Knowledge Deficit

A core finding of the initiative was the near-universal knowledge deficit among adolescents, regardless of how long they had lived with their condition. Initial assessments revealed that over 90% of participants required further information regarding their specific disease and medical system navigation.

Baseline assessment of information requirements among study participants.

As shown in the assessment data, requirements for information were high across almost all categories, including disease-specific details (84.6%), therapy-related issues (84.3%), and navigating the medical system (90.7%). Interestingly, psychological counseling was the only area where a vast majority of patients (92.7%) felt they did not require additional support, suggesting that the primary barrier to successful transition is educational and logistical rather than emotional.

Results and Resource Implications

The project demonstrated high feasibility and success. Out of 292 recruited patients (mean age ~18), 286 (97.9%) completed the pathway, and 267 were successfully transferred to adult specialists. Post-intervention assessments showed significantly improved health literacy, though roughly 78% of patients still expressed a desire for some ongoing guidance in navigating the healthcare system.

While successful, the process is resource-intensive. The average transition took nearly a year, with joint consultations often lasting 90 minutes. The researchers calculated the average cost at €599 per patient. While this exceeds current insurance reimbursement rates in Germany, the authors argue it is a modest investment compared to the long-term costs of medical complications resulting from failed transitions.

Limitations and Future Outlook

Despite the positive outcomes, the study faced several limitations. As a prospective implementation study, it lacked a control group for direct comparison. Furthermore, the three-year scope prevents long-term tracking of whether these patients remain in adult care or experience better health outcomes over a decade.

The sustainability of such programs remains a concern. Current funding models do not adequately cover the high personnel costs of coordinators and extended consultations. For the "TRANSLATE NAMSE" model to become standard practice, systemic changes in healthcare reimbursement are necessary to support the intensive coordination required for rare disease transitions.

Reference: Grasemann, C., et al. (2023). Transition for adolescents with a rare disease: results of a nationwide German project. Orphanet Journal of Rare Diseases, 18:93. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13023-023-02698-2

Summary updated

Abstract

The described transition pathway succeeds to improve health literacy in adolescents with RDs and can be implemented by paediatric care teams in any RD specialty. Patient empowerment was mainly achieved by individualized training and counselling.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{grasemann2023transition,
  author = {Corinna Grasemann and Jakob Höppner and Peter Burgard and Michael M. Schündeln and Nora Matar and Gabriele Müller and Heiko Krude and Reinhard Berner and Min Ae Lee‐Kirsch and Fabian Hauck and Kerstin Wainwright and S. Baumgarten and Janet Atinga and Jens Bauer and Eva Manka and Julia Körholz and Cordula Kiewert and A. Heinen and Tanita Kretschmer and Tobias Kurth and Janna Mittnacht and Christoph Schramm and Christoph Klein and Holm Graeßner and Olaf Hiort and Ania C. Muntau and Annette Grüters and Georg F. Hoffmann and Daniela Choukair},
  title = {{Transition for adolescents with a rare disease: results of a nationwide German project}},
  booktitle = {Orphanet},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1186/s13023-023-02698-2},
}
Figure