Transient Tertiary Structure Formation within the Ribosome Exit Port

Edward P. O’Brien, Shang‐Te Danny Hsu, John Christodoulou, Michele Vendruscolo, Christopher M. DobsonJournal of the American Chemical Society 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper challenges the long-held assumption that protein folding only begins after the nascent polypeptide chain fully exits the ribosome. Using molecular simulations, the authors demonstrate that significant tertiary structure formation, including native and non-native folds, can occur transiently within the ribosome's "exit port" – the final 20 Å of its tunnel. This finding has profound implications for understanding the intricate process of co-translational folding and its interplay with cellular machinery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Protein synthesis is a complex process where ribosomes translate genetic information into polypeptide chains. A key question in this field is when and where protein folding begins. The ribosome possesses a narrow exit tunnel (approximately 80 Å long and 10-20 Å in diameter) through which the nascent chain (NC) emerges. Traditionally, the narrowness of this tunnel has led to the assumption that it's too restrictive for any significant tertiary structure formation, implying that folding must wait until the entire chain is outside the ribosome. However, recent experimental evidence, particularly from cross-linking studies, has hinted that some level of tertiary structure might form within the tunnel. This paper aims to resolve this discrepancy by investigating the possibility and nature of co-translational folding within the ribosome exit tunnel, specifically focusing on the last 20 Å, often referred to as the "exit port."

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of molecular simulation techniques to tackle this problem:

  • Coarse-Grained (CG) Molecular Simulations: To efficiently explore a large conformational space and examine many different folded tertiary structural elements (FTEs), a CG model of the E. coli ribosome and nascent chain was used. This model simplifies amino acids to two interaction sites and nucleotide bases to up to four, allowing for faster simulations and better statistical sampling compared to all-atom models.
  • Restrained Simulations: A key protocol involved restraining specific FTEs to remain folded while the rest of the nascent chain was kept unfolded. This "reverse synthesis" approach allowed the researchers to determine the minimum number of residues (minimum APTC) and the minimum distance from the peptidyl transferase center (PTC) (minimum dPTC) required for an FTE to fit sterically within the ribosome exit tunnel without clashing.
  • Unrestrained Replica Exchange Simulations: To assess the thermodynamic stability and transient nature of these folded structures, unrestrained simulations were performed. These simulations allowed the nascent chain to fold and unfold at equilibrium, providing insights into the free energies of stability for various FTEs within the tunnel.
  • Comparison with All-Atom Simulations: The validity and accuracy of the CG model were rigorously tested by comparing its results with more computationally expensive all-atom simulations for a subset of the problem.
  • Experimental Data Comparison: The simulation results were also compared with existing experimental data, particularly from cross-linking studies, to validate their findings and provide a framework for interpreting experimental observations.

Datasets

The study utilized structural data from nine different proteins (GFP, SH3, filamen, immunoglobulin domain 27, ubiquitin, protein G, Kv1.2, 26-85 repressor, and notch ankyrin 1-7) to define their folded tertiary structural elements (FTEs). These structures were obtained from the Protein Data Bank (PDB). No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the study aimed to interpret existing experimental data within the context of their simulation findings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Exit Port" is a Folding Hotspot: The most striking insight is that the last 20 Å of the ribosome exit tunnel, the "exit port," is not merely a passive conduit but a region where significant tertiary structure formation can occur.
  • Steric Fit is Key, Not Just Tunnel Dimensions: The irregular geometry of both the ribosome tunnel and the folded tertiary structural elements (FTEs) is crucial. Simple geometric arguments (like fitting a sphere in a cylinder) are insufficient; detailed atomic-level interactions dictate what can fit.
  • Transient Nature of Folding: While FTEs can fit and form within the exit port, they are generally not thermodynamically stable there. This means they form transiently, existing at their midpoints of stability at the boundary between the inside and outside of the tunnel.
  • Both Native and Non-Native Structures Can Form: The simulations suggest that not only can native tertiary structures form, but also non-native folds can be accommodated within the exit port, highlighting the dynamic and potentially error-prone nature of early co-translational folding.
  • Implications for Chaperone Interactions: The presence of partially folded NCs with exposed hydrophobic patches in the exit port could serve as recognition sites for chaperones, influencing protein folding and targeting.

Key Results

  • Tertiary Contacts Form Early: Long-range tertiary contacts, essential for initiating protein folding, can form in a nascent chain when it reaches the last 20 Å of the exit tunnel.
  • Significant Proportion of FTEs Fit: On average, about 35% of the folded tertiary structural elements (FTEs) from the nine proteins studied could sterically fit within the exit tunnel. For protein G, 12 out of 23 FTEs could fit.
  • Early Formation of Secondary Structure Elements: The first occurrence of a folded tertiary structure involving two β-strands was found at an APTC of 19 Å (63.5 Å from the PTC), and two helices could assemble tertiary structure starting at 21 Å (61.2 Å from the PTC).
  • Midpoints of Stability at the Exit: The midpoints of stability for folded FTEs were found to be at the interface of the exit port and the external environment, suggesting transient folding. For example, for protein G, this midpoint was at 28 Å, and for 26-85 repressor, it was at 26 Å.
  • Non-Native Structures Also Fit: For a protein known to adopt two different native folds, approximately half of one protein's non-native tertiary structure could fit in the exit tunnel.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Limitations: While coarse-grained models offer efficiency, they inherently simplify the system. The authors acknowledge that larger fluctuations in the ribosome might allow for even greater tertiary folding than observed.
  • Thermodynamic Stability: The study highlights that folded structures within the tunnel are transient and not thermodynamically stable. Understanding the precise kinetics of formation and decay is a crucial next step.
  • Experimental Validation: The authors propose that their findings provide a framework for interpreting experimental data and suggest specific experimental tests, such as cross-linking experiments with larger residue separations, to further validate their predictions.
  • Broader Applicability: While the study focused on globular proteins, future work could explore the implications for other types of proteins and macromolecular systems. The authors suggest that their simulation approach could be valuable for studying other co-translational processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

The exit tunnel of the ribosome is commonly considered to be sufficiently narrow that co-translational folding can begin only when specific segments of nascent chains are fully extruded from the tunnel. Here we show, on the basis of molecular simulations and comparison with experiment, that the long-range contacts essential for initiating protein folding can form within a nascent chain when it reaches the last 20 Å of the exit tunnel. We further show that, in this "exit port", a significant proportion of native and non-native tertiary structure can form without steric overlap with the ribosome itself, and provide a library of structural elements that our simulations predict can form in the exit tunnel and is amenable to experimental testing. Our results show that these elements of folded tertiary structure form only transiently and are at their midpoints of stability at the boundary region between the inside and the outside of the tunnel. These findings provide a framework for interpreting a range of recent experimental studies of ribosome nascent chain complexes and for understanding key aspects of the nature of co-translational folding.
BibTeX
@article{obrien2010transient,
  author = {Edward P. O’Brien and Shang‐Te Danny Hsu and John Christodoulou and Michele Vendruscolo and Christopher M. Dobson},
  title = {{Transient Tertiary Structure Formation within the Ribosome Exit Port}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1021/ja106530y},
}
Figure