Transient Pupil Response Is Modulated by Contrast-Based Saliency

Chin‐An Wang, Susan E. Boehnke, Laurent Itti, Douglas P. MunozJournal of Neuroscience 2014 · DOI

Abstract

The sudden appearance of a novel stimulus in the environment initiates a series of orienting responses that include coordinated shifts of gaze and attention, and also transient changes in pupil size. Although numerous studies have identified a significant effect of stimulus saliency on shifts of gaze and attention, saliency effects on pupil size are less understood. To examine salience-evoked pupil responses, we presented visual, auditory, or audiovisual stimuli while monkeys fixated a central visual spot. Transient pupil dilation was elicited after visual stimulus presentation regardless of target luminance relative to background, and auditory stimuli also evoked similar pupil responses. Importantly, the evoked pupil response was modulated by contrast-based saliency, with faster and larger pupil responses following the presentation of more salient stimuli. The initial transient component of pupil dilation was qualitatively similar to that evoked by weak microstimulation of the midbrain superior colliculus. The pupil responses elicited by audiovisual stimuli were well predicted by a linear summation of each modality response. Together, the results suggest that the transient pupil response, as one component of orienting, is modulated by contrast-based saliency, and the superior colliculus is likely involved in its coordination.

Introduction

While the Pupillary Light Reflex (PLR)—the constriction of pupils in bright light and dilation in the dark—is well-documented, the pupil's role in the broader "orienting response" is less understood. When a salient stimulus captures our attention, our brain coordinates a series of physical adjustments to optimize perception. This study investigates whether transient pupil dilation is a fundamental component of this response, modulated by bottom-up saliency rather than just ambient light levels.

Methods

Researchers conducted experiments with rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) to decouple luminance changes from saliency. Monkeys fixated on a central point while stimuli of varying contrast (positive/brighter or negative/darker than the background) were presented. This design tested if the pupil would react to the "importance" of the stimulus regardless of its light intensity.

Experimental paradigm and pupil response measurement metrics.

The study also explored multisensory integration by presenting auditory tones and combined audiovisual stimuli. Furthermore, to identify the neural circuitry involved, the researchers applied microstimulation to the intermediate layers of the superior colliculus (SCi), a midbrain region critical for gaze control and spatial attention.

Key Results and Insights

The most significant finding is that the pupil exhibits a transient dilation in response to a salient stimulus, even when that stimulus is brighter than the background—a condition that would normally trigger constriction via the PLR. This suggests that the orienting system can temporarily override the light-level system to prioritize sensory intake.

Pupil diameter traces showing transient dilation for both positive (Pos) and negative (Neg) contrast stimuli across different monkeys and background conditions.

Key observations from the data include:

  • Saliency Modulation: Higher contrast (more salient) stimuli resulted in faster and larger pupil dilations. For instance, high-contrast visual stimuli triggered responses at ~222 ms with a peak of ~0.057 mm, compared to ~259 ms and ~0.041 mm for low-contrast stimuli.
  • Multisensory Nature: The pupil reacted to auditory stimuli with dynamics similar to visual ones, confirming it as a global marker of orientation across modalities.
  • Linear Summation: Responses to simultaneous sight and sound were accurately predicted by the linear sum of individual modality responses, suggesting the brain sums "importance" signals linearly.
  • SCi Involvement: Microstimulation of the SCi replicated the "triphasic" pupil response (dilation-constriction-dilation) seen with natural stimuli, positioning the SC as a central coordinator for pupillary orienting.

Discussion and Future Directions

These results indicate that the transient pupil response is a core element of the brain's orienting mechanism, modulated by contrast-based saliency. The superior colliculus appears to be the primary engine driving these changes, integrating multisensory inputs to adjust the eye's state for optimal perception.

Future research could explore how "top-down" factors—such as task relevance or internal goals—interact with these "bottom-up" saliency effects. Additionally, addressing limitations such as the head-fixed condition of the subjects and the need for precise psychophysical matching across modalities will be crucial for a more complete model of the pupillary orienting response.

Summary updated

Abstract

The sudden appearance of a novel stimulus in the environment initiates a series of orienting responses that include coordinated shifts of gaze and attention, and also transient changes in pupil size. Although numerous studies have identified a significant effect of stimulus saliency on shifts of gaze and attention, saliency effects on pupil size are less understood. To examine salience-evoked pupil responses, we presented visual, auditory, or audiovisual stimuli while monkeys fixated a central visual spot. Transient pupil dilation was elicited after visual stimulus presentation regardless of target luminance relative to background, and auditory stimuli also evoked similar pupil responses. Importantly, the evoked pupil response was modulated by contrast-based saliency, with faster and larger pupil responses following the presentation of more salient stimuli. The initial transient component of pupil dilation was qualitatively similar to that evoked by weak microstimulation of the midbrain superior colliculus. The pupil responses elicited by audiovisual stimuli were well predicted by a linear summation of each modality response. Together, the results suggest that the transient pupil response, as one component of orienting, is modulated by contrast-based saliency, and the superior colliculus is likely involved in its coordination.
BibTeX
@article{wang2014transient,
  author = {Chin‐An Wang and Susan E. Boehnke and Laurent Itti and Douglas P. Munoz},
  title = {{Transient Pupil Response Is Modulated by Contrast-Based Saliency}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.3550-13.2014},
}
Figure