Transgressive Potential Prediction and Optimal Cross Design of Seed Protein Content in the Northeast China Soybean Population Based on Full Exploration of the QTL-Allele System

Weidan Feng, Lianshun Fu, Mengmeng Fu, Ziqian Sang, Yanping Wang, Lei Wang, Haixiang Ren, Du Weiguang, Xiaoshuai Hao, Lei Sun, Jiaoping Zhang, Wubin Wang, Guangnan Xing, Jianbo He, Junyi GaiFrontiers in Plant Science 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages a novel RTM-GWAS approach to comprehensively map quantitative trait loci (QTLs) and their alleles associated with seed protein content (SPC) in Northeast China soybean germplasm. By analyzing these QTL-allele systems, researchers predict the potential for transgressive breeding and identify optimal crosses to significantly enhance SPC, suggesting a powerful new strategy for soybean improvement.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Soybean is a crucial source of protein, and increasing seed protein content (SPC) is a key goal for food and animal feed industries. While Northeast China is a major soybean production region, its commercial soybeans have a lower SPC compared to other Chinese populations. Previous genetic studies on SPC often relied on single-locus models or limited parental lines, potentially missing the full picture of genetic variation, especially when multiple alleles exist within a population. This paper aims to address this gap by thoroughly exploring the SPC QTL-allele system within a representative Northeast China soybean germplasm population (NECSGP) to uncover its full breeding potential.

Methods

The researchers employed a Restricted Two-Stage Multi-Locus Genome-Wide Association Study (RTM-GWAS). This method is an advancement over traditional single-locus GWAS because it:

  • Uses Linkage Disequilibrium Blocks (SNPLDBs) as markers: This allows for the detection of multiple alleles within a QTL, which is crucial for natural populations where genetic diversity is high.
  • Employs a two-stage approach: The first stage uses a single-locus model for efficient preselection of markers, and the second stage uses a multi-locus model to identify QTL-alleles with higher trait heritability.
  • Reduces false positives/negatives: By using a normal p-value without excessive Bonferroni correction and a stepwise regression with a heritability upper limit, the method aims for more precise QTL identification.

Following the RTM-GWAS, the researchers constructed a QTL-allele matrix for the NECSGP. This matrix was then used to simulate all possible crosses in silico to predict the transgressive potential of SPC. This involves predicting the SPC of homozygous progenies and identifying crosses that could yield offspring with SPC exceeding the maximum observed in the population. Candidate genes associated with the identified SPC QTLs were also annotated.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 361 soybean accessions from the Northeast China Soybean Germplasm Population (NECSGP). These accessions were collected from various subregions and historical reserves within Northeast China and represented six different maturity groups (MG III, II, I, 0, 00, and 000). Field experiments were conducted in Tieling, Northeast China, under controlled environmental conditions to measure SPC. Genotyping data was obtained from previous sequencing efforts, resulting in 15,501 SNPLDB markers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The NECSGP has untapped SPC potential: Despite a seemingly narrow range of SPC variation compared to landraces, the study reveals significant potential for improvement through genetic recombination.
  • RTM-GWAS is powerful for complex traits: The RTM-GWAS method, by considering SNPLDBs and multi-locus interactions, proved effective in dissecting the genetic architecture of SPC, identifying more QTLs and alleles than previous studies.
  • Evolutionary shifts in maturity groups show subtle SPC changes: The transition from older to earlier maturity groups in Northeast China has led to a slight increase in SPC, driven by a small number of new positive alleles and potential recombination events, rather than major allele exclusions.
  • Optimal cross prediction is a game-changer: The ability to simulate all possible crosses and predict progeny SPC based on a whole-genome QTL-allele matrix offers a precise and efficient method for designing superior crosses, potentially shortening breeding cycles.

Key Results

  • SPC Variation: The NECSGP showed a mean SPC of 40.77%, ranging from 36.60% to 46.07%. This was lower than the Chinese soybean landrace population (43.10%).
  • QTL Identification: RTM-GWAS identified 73 SPC QTLs with 273 alleles, explaining 71.70% of the phenotypic variation. Of these, 28 QTLs were novel.
  • Evolutionary Changes: In the transition from older to newer maturity groups, 97.79% of alleles were inherited, with only 2.21% being new.
  • Breeding Potential: The predicted mean SPC for all possible crosses was 43.29% (a +2.52% increase over the population mean), with a maximum predicted SPC of 50.00% (a +9.23% increase). The maximum transgressive potential was 3.93%.
  • Candidate Genes: 120 candidate genes were annotated and functionally classified into 13 GO biological process categories, highlighting SPC as a complex trait controlled by a gene network.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Phenotypic Variation: The authors acknowledge that the phenotypic variation in SPC within the NECSGP was not as wide as in the Chinese soybean landrace population.
  • Environmental Influence: While genotype-by-environment interaction (GEI) was significant, the QEI information was not used in further analysis due to the random nature of environmental factors in this study.
  • Sequencing Depth: The exploration of SPC QTL-allele systems could be further improved with increased sequencing depth, potentially merging single-SNP LD blocks into more complex haplotypes.
  • Multi-trait Breeding: The study focused solely on SPC. Future work should involve establishing QTL-allele matrices for other important traits like yield and oil content to design crosses that optimize multiple traits simultaneously.
  • External Germplasm: To achieve breakthroughs in SPC improvement, introducing superior alleles from other germplasm populations into the NECSGP is suggested as a potential strategy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Northeast China is a major soybean production region in China. A representative sample of the Northeast China soybean germplasm population (NECSGP) composed of 361 accessions was evaluated for their seed protein content (SPC) in Tieling, Northeast China. This SPC varied greatly, with a mean SPC of 40.77%, ranging from 36.60 to 46.07%, but it was lower than that of the Chinese soybean landrace population (43.10%, ranging from 37.51 to 50.46%). The SPC increased slightly from 40.32-40.97% in the old maturity groups (MG, MGIII + II + I) to 40.93-41.58% in the new MGs (MG0 + 00 + 000). The restricted two-stage multi-locus genome-wide association study (RTM-GWAS) with 15,501 SNP linkage-disequilibrium block (SNPLDB) markers identified 73 SPC quantitative trait loci (QTLs) with 273 alleles, explaining 71.70% of the phenotypic variation, wherein 28 QTLs were new ones. The evolutionary changes of QTL-allele structures from old MGs to new MGs were analyzed, and 97.79% of the alleles in new MGs were inherited from the old MGs and 2.21% were new. The small amount of new positive allele emergence and possible recombination between alleles might explain the slight SPC increase in the new MGs. The prediction of recombination potentials in the SPC of all the possible crosses indicated that the mean of SPC overall crosses was 43.29% (+2.52%) and the maximum was 50.00% (+9.23%) in the SPC, and the maximum transgressive potential was 3.93%, suggesting that SPC breeding potentials do exist in the NECSGP. A total of 120 candidate genes were annotated and functionally classified into 13 categories, indicating that SPC is a complex trait conferred by a gene network.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2022transgressive,
  author = {Weidan Feng and Lianshun Fu and Mengmeng Fu and Ziqian Sang and Yanping Wang and Lei Wang and Haixiang Ren and Du Weiguang and Xiaoshuai Hao and Lei Sun and Jiaoping Zhang and Wubin Wang and Guangnan Xing and Jianbo He and Junyi Gai},
  title = {{Transgressive Potential Prediction and Optimal Cross Design of Seed Protein Content in the Northeast China Soybean Population Based on Full Exploration of the QTL-Allele System}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2022.896549},
}

Loading related content...

Figure