Transgenic Cavendish bananas with resistance to Fusarium wilt tropical race 4

J. L. Dale, Anthony P. James, Jean‐Yves Paul, Harjeet Khanna, M. K. Smith, Santy Peraza-Echeverría, Fernando A. García-Bastidas, G.h.j. Kema, Peter M. Waterhouse, Kerrie Mengersen, R. M. HardingNature Communications 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports the successful development of transgenic Cavendish bananas resistant to Fusarium wilt tropical race 4 (TR4), a devastating fungal disease threatening global banana production. By introducing genes like RGA2 from resistant wild bananas, researchers have created banana lines that remain disease-free in field trials, offering a crucial step towards securing this vital food source.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bananas are a staple food for over 400 million people worldwide, with the Cavendish variety dominating global production and export. However, Cavendish bananas are highly susceptible to Fusarium wilt tropical race 4 (TR4), a virulent fungal pathogen that has already decimated other banana cultivars. TR4 poses a significant threat to the global banana industry and food security, as no commercially viable resistant Cavendish variety currently exists. Existing control methods like quarantine and chemical treatments have proven ineffective against TR4's widespread dissemination. This paper addresses the urgent need for TR4-resistant Cavendish bananas by exploring genetic engineering approaches.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged genetic engineering strategy:

  • Gene Introduction: They transformed Cavendish banana cultivar 'Grand Nain' (GN) with two different genes:
  • RGA2: A gene isolated from a TR4-resistant wild diploid banana (Musa acuminata ssp. malaccensis), known to be a resistance gene analog (RGA).
  • Ced9: An anti-apoptosis gene derived from the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, previously shown to confer resistance to an earlier race of Fusarium wilt.
  • Transgene Expression: Both genes were placed under the control of strong plant promoters (maize Ubi-P for Ced9 and Agrobacterium Nos-P for RGA2) to ensure sufficient expression in the banana plants.
  • Field Trials: The transformed lines, along with untransformed controls (including susceptible Cavendish cultivars like GN and Williams, and partially tolerant variants like GCTCV 218), were subjected to a rigorous 3-year field trial in a TR4-endemic commercial banana plantation in Australia.
  • Disease Assessment: Plants were regularly monitored for external symptoms (wilting, yellowing) and internal vascular discoloration, a key diagnostic marker for TR4 infection. Confirmatory fungal isolation and PCR-based assays were also performed.
  • Gene Expression Analysis: Quantitative RT-PCR (qRT-PCR) was used to measure the expression levels of the RGA2 transgene and endogenous RGA2 homologs in the roots of the transgenic and control plants.
  • Southern Blot Analysis: This technique was used to determine the number of transgene copies integrated into the banana genome.
  • Homolog Identification: The researchers identified and sequenced endogenous RGA2 homologs present in the wild-type Cavendish genome.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as datasets in the traditional machine learning sense. The study relies on:

  • Transgenic Banana Lines: Multiple lines of Cavendish bananas transformed with either the RGA2 or Ced9 gene.
  • Control Banana Lines: Wild-type Cavendish cultivars (Grand Nain, Williams), partially tolerant Cavendish variants (GCTCV 218, DPM25), and a TR4-resistant wild banana accession (M. acuminata ssp. malaccensis).
  • TR4 Pathogen: Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cubense tropical race 4 (TR4) naturally present in the field trial site.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RGA2 as a Potent Resistance Gene: The RGA2 gene, when introduced into Cavendish bananas, confers a high level of resistance to TR4, with some lines showing complete immunity in field trials. This highlights the potential of leveraging resistance genes from wild relatives.
  • Ced9 Offers Partial Resistance: While not as effective as RGA2, the Ced9 gene also provided a degree of resistance, suggesting that anti-apoptotic mechanisms can contribute to disease tolerance.
  • Expression Level is Crucial: For RGA2, there's a strong correlation between transgene expression levels and the degree of TR4 protection. Higher expression leads to better resistance.
  • Endogenous RGA2 Homologs Exist but are Under-Expressed: Wild-type Cavendish bananas possess RGA2-like genes, but their expression levels are significantly lower (about tenfold less) than in the resistant transgenic lines. This opens up possibilities for non-transgenic resistance strategies.
  • Gene Editing Potential: The discovery of endogenous RGA2 homologs suggests that gene editing technologies could be used to enhance their expression, potentially leading to non-transgenic TR4-resistant Cavendish bananas.
  • Field Trials are Essential: The study underscores the critical importance of long-term field trials to validate the efficacy and robustness of genetic modifications under real-world agricultural conditions.

Key Results

  • RGA2 Lines Show Robust Resistance: Four out of five RGA2 lines and four out of five Ced9 lines showed significantly reduced symptom development compared to the susceptible control (GN) over the 3-year trial.
  • Immunity Observed: Two lines, RGA2-3 and Ced9-21, appeared to be completely immune to TR4, showing no internal or external symptoms throughout the trial.
  • Control Plants Devastated: By the end of the trial, 67-100% of all control plants were either dead or infected with TR4.
  • Expression-Resistance Correlation: A statistically significant inverse correlation was found between RGA2 expression levels and the proportion of TR4 infections in RGA2 transgenic lines and the GN control.
  • No Detrimental Impact on Bunch Size: The transgenic modifications did not negatively affect the bunch size of the banana plants.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Ced9 Resistance Mechanism Unclear: The precise mechanism by which Ced9 confers resistance in transgenic bananas remains to be elucidated.
  • RGA2 Homolog Functionality: While endogenous RGA2 homologs are present in Cavendish, their effectiveness in conferring resistance is unknown. The authors plan to transform GN with these homologs to assess their resistance.
  • Non-Transgenic Resistance via Gene Editing: The study suggests that gene editing could be used to enhance the expression of endogenous RGA2 genes, offering a path to non-transgenic resistance. This is a key area for future research.
  • Commercial Release Progression: The researchers are planning further, more extensive field trials with RGA2 lines and new Cavendish lines to identify candidates for commercial release.
  • Trial Termination: The field trial was cut short from the intended 5 years to 3 years due to a forced quarantine termination order related to another disease, which might limit the long-term assessment of resistance durability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Banana (Musa spp.) is a staple food for more than 400 million people. Over 40% of world production and virtually all the export trade is based on Cavendish banana. However, Cavendish banana is under threat from a virulent fungus, Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cubense tropical race 4 (TR4) for which no acceptable resistant replacement has been identified. Here we report the identification of transgenic Cavendish with resistance to TR4. In our 3-year field trial, two lines of transgenic Cavendish, one transformed with RGA2, a gene isolated from a TR4-resistant diploid banana, and the other with a nematode-derived gene, Ced9, remain disease free. Transgene expression in the RGA2 lines is strongly correlated with resistance. Endogenous RGA2 homologs are also present in Cavendish but are expressed tenfold lower than that in our most resistant transgenic line. The expression of these homologs can potentially be elevated through gene editing, to provide non-transgenic resistance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dale2017transgenic,
  author = {J. L. Dale and Anthony P. James and Jean‐Yves Paul and Harjeet Khanna and M. K. Smith and Santy Peraza-Echeverría and Fernando A. García-Bastidas and G.H.J. Kema and Peter M. Waterhouse and Kerrie Mengersen and R. M. Harding},
  title = {{Transgenic Cavendish bananas with resistance to Fusarium wilt tropical race 4}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-017-01670-6},
}
Figure