Transforming the Canada France Hawaii Telescope (CFHT) into the Maunakea Spectroscopic Explorer (MSE): a conceptual observatory building and facilities design

Steven E. Bauman, Kei Szeto, Alexis Hill, Rick Murowinski, Ivan Look, Greg Green, Casey Elizares, Derrick Salmon, Eric Grigel, Eric Manuel, Federico Ruan, José Terán, Mike Gedig, Gaizka Murga, Ronny Müller, Thomas Lorentz, David Lo, Alan W. McConnachie, Armando Bilbao, Rafael García-Tapia Urrutia, Greg Barrick, Nathan Loewen, Tom Benedict, Nicolas FlageyarXiv 2018 · arXiv

Abstract

The Canada France Hawaii Telescope Corporation (CFHT) plans to repurpose its observatory on the summit of Maunakea to operate a new wide-field spectroscopic survey telescope, the Maunakea Spectroscopic Explorer (MSE). MSE will upgrade the observatory with a larger 11.25m aperture telescope, capitalizing on the site's exceptional seeing conditions. This project involves a sustainable approach by reusing the existing building and telescope pier. However, significant upgrades are required to accommodate the increased mass and aperture, including reinforcing the support pier and replacing the dome with a 12.5m diameter "Calotte" style enclosure. This paper describes the design approach for redeveloping the CFHT facility, focusing on structural, seismic, and thermal engineering to support transformative science while maintaining the original building footprint.

Introduction

The global astronomical community has long identified the need for a dedicated 10m-class, wide-field spectroscopic survey telescope. Building new facilities on Maunakea involves significant environmental, cultural, and financial complexities. The MSE project proposes a sustainable alternative: "astronomical recycling" of the existing 40-year-old CFHT infrastructure. The primary engineering challenge lies in fitting a telescope with three times the aperture and significantly higher mass into a structure designed in the 1970s.

Structural Engineering and Geotechnical Capacity

A critical hurdle for the MSE project was determining if the existing volcanic cinder soil could support a much heavier telescope. While 1973 geotechnical data provided a baseline, new soil core borings conducted in 2018 confirmed that the underlying cinders can support the upgraded loads, provided contact pressure is limited to 4,500–6,600 psf.

To accommodate the new Alt-Azimuth mount, the top of the existing telescope pier requires significant modification. The design involves removing the top 2-3 feet of the pier and replacing it with a 24-inch concrete "haunch" to provide the necessary support. Additionally, carbon fiber wraps are utilized to increase the shear stress capacity of the inner concrete pier, particularly around existing door openings.

Structural modifications to the telescope pier, including the new concrete haunch and pier wall reinforcements.

Seismic Retrofitting and Enclosure Design

Bringing a 1970s structure up to modern International Building Code (IBC) seismic standards required innovative solutions. The design introduces Buckling Restrained Braces (BRBs) into the outer steel framework. Unlike traditional bracing, BRBs have equal capacity in tension and compression and dissipate seismic energy through friction. Further reinforcements include welding 3/8-inch steel plates to existing columns and adding new concrete stem walls with epoxy-anchored threaded bars to resist wind uplift during extreme weather.

3D model of the building's steel framework highlighting new and retrofitted seismic components like the azimuth ring girder and radial bracing.

The new enclosure is a Calotte-style dome, which remains within 10% of the original dome's size but allows for the 12.5m slit width required by the larger telescope. This design ensures the facility remains almost indistinguishable from the original CFHT observatory from the outside.

Thermal Management for Image Quality

To preserve the site's excellent seeing, the MSE design treats heat as a pollutant. A "defense-in-depth" thermal strategy moves heat-generating equipment (chillers, pumps) to the basement and ground floor. The 4th-floor crawlspace acts as an active air plenum to flush out residual heat before it reaches the telescope environment. Low-emissivity paint, reflective insulation, and underground exhaust tunnels are used to ensure the telescope environment remains as close to ambient temperature as possible.

Conclusion and Future Work

The conceptual design demonstrates that repurposing the CFHT facility for the MSE is technically feasible. By combining modern structural reinforcements with advanced thermal management, the project can deliver an 11.25m aperture telescope within an existing footprint. Future design phases will focus on finalizing vibration isolation, specific instrumentation layouts for the spectrographs, and optimizing facility maintenance systems to continue CFHT's legacy of efficient remote operations.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Canada France Hawaii Telescope Corporation (CFHT) plans to repurpose its observatory on the summit of Maunakea and operate a new wide field spectroscopic survey telescope, the Maunakea Spectroscopic Explorer (MSE). MSE will upgrade the observatory with a larger 11.25m aperture telescope and equip it with dedicated instrumentation to capitalize on the site, which has some of the best seeing in the northern hemisphere, and offer its user’s community the ability to do transformative science. The knowledge and experience of the current CFHT staff will contribute greatly to the engineering of this new facility. MSE will reuse the same building and telescope pier as CFHT. However, it will be necessary to upgrade the support pier to accommodate a bigger telescope and replace the current dome since a wider slit opening of 12.5 meters in diameter is needed. Once the project is completed the new facility will be almost indistinguishable on the outside from the current CFHT observatory. MSE will build upon CFHT’s pioneering work in remote operations, with no staff at the observatory during the night, and use modern technologies to reduce daytime maintenance work. This paper describes the design approach for redeveloping the CFHT facility for MSE including the infrastructure and equipment considerations required to support and facilitate nighttime observations. The building will be designed so existing equipment and infrastructure can be reused wherever possible while meeting new requirement demands. Past experience and lessons learned will be used to create a modern, optimized, and logical layout of the facility. The purpose of this paper is to provide information to readers involved in the MSE project or organizations involved with the redevelopment of an existing observatory facility for a new mission.
BibTeX
@misc{bauman2018transforming,
  author = {Steven E. Bauman and Kei Szeto and Alexis Hill and Rick Murowinski and Ivan Look and Greg Green and Casey Elizares and Derrick Salmon and Eric Grigel and Eric Manuel and Federico Ruan and José Terán and Mike Gedig and Gaizka Murga and Ronny Müller and Thomas Lorentz and David Lo and Alan W. McConnachie and Armando Bilbao and Rafael García-Tapia Urrutia and Greg Barrick and Nathan Loewen and Tom Benedict and Nicolas Flagey},
  title = {{Transforming the Canada France Hawaii Telescope (CFHT) into the Maunakea Spectroscopic Explorer (MSE): a conceptual observatory building and facilities design}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1807.08044},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.08044},
}
Figure