TL;DR
This paper tackles the challenge of automatically identifying argumentative structures in scientific texts, a crucial but difficult task. They propose a transfer learning approach, leveraging existing discourse annotations to improve argument mining models, and demonstrate its effectiveness in predicting paper acceptance based on abstract analysis.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The sheer volume of scientific publications and the increasing pressure for faster publication cycles necessitate automated tools to assist in evaluating scientific work. While aspects like novelty and relevance are key, the argumentative structure of a paper—how claims are presented and supported—is vital for effective communication and assessing the work's contribution. Automatically identifying these argumentative components and their relationships (argument mining) is a challenging problem, exacerbated by a lack of annotated data and low inter-annotator agreement, especially in the complex domain of scientific writing. This paper aims to bridge this gap by using existing discourse-level annotations to enhance argument mining capabilities.
Methods
The core of this work lies in a transfer learning approach. The authors leverage existing Rhetorical Structure Theory (RST) annotations from the SciDTB corpus, which already contains discourse-level information. They propose an annotation scheme for argumentative units and relations, and then use this to enrich a subset of SciDTB.
The transfer learning happens by training encoders on discourse parsing tasks (identifying discourse functions and attachments) using the full SciDTB corpus. These trained encoders then generate contextualized representations of text, which are fed as input to argument mining models. This allows the argument mining models to benefit from the knowledge learned during discourse parsing, even with a limited amount of argument-annotated data.
The argument mining tasks themselves are framed as sequence labeling problems, using a Bi-LSTM architecture with dependency-based and ELMo word embeddings.
Datasets
- SciDTB (Discourse Dependency TreeBank for Scientific Abstracts): This corpus, containing 798 abstracts from the ACL Anthology, was initially annotated with elementary discourse units (EDUs) and RST relations.
- Enriched SciDTB Subset: A subset of SciDTB was further annotated with the authors' proposed argumentative structure scheme. This enriched corpus contains 327 sentences, 8012 tokens, 862 discourse units, and 352 argumentative units linked by 292 argumentative relations.
- CDNNRIA and IRASL workshops: Abstracts from these workshops were used for training the acceptance prediction classifier.
- ICLR 2018: Abstracts from this conference were used as the test set for the acceptance prediction experiment.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Discourse as a Bridge to Argument: The paper strongly suggests that understanding the discourse structure of a text can significantly aid in identifying its argumentative components. This is a key insight, as it offers a way to overcome the scarcity of direct argument annotations.
- Transfer Learning Pays Off: By training models on discourse parsing tasks and then transferring that knowledge to argument mining, the authors demonstrate improved performance, especially when argument-annotated data is limited. This highlights the power of leveraging related linguistic structures.
- Argumentative Structure Predicts Acceptance: Perhaps the most intriguing finding is that the automatically identified argumentative structure of a scientific abstract can be a surprisingly good predictor of whether a paper will be accepted or rejected. This suggests that the way authors construct their arguments in abstracts reflects the overall quality and impact of their work.
- Fine-grained Features Matter: The acceptance prediction experiment showed that using detailed argumentative information (unit types, functions, and parent attachments) led to significantly better prediction performance than using only the presence of argumentative units.
Key Results
- Argument Mining Performance: The transfer learning approach using RST encoders improved F1-measures by 0.03, 0.04, and 0.02 for the AFu, ATy, and APa argument mining tasks, respectively, compared to models trained without discourse information.
- Acceptance Prediction: A decision tree classifier trained on argumentative features extracted from abstracts achieved an F1-score of 0.67, outperforming a random binary classifier by 0.17 F1 points. This was significantly better than using only the presence of argumentative units (F1 of 0.59).
- Feature Importance: In the acceptance prediction, the most important features were related to the parent attachment of the first argumentative unit, the functions of the first two units, and the type of the first unit, indicating that the initial argumentative framing is highly predictive.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Annotated Data: The authors acknowledge the inherent challenge of limited annotated data for argument mining, which is why their transfer learning approach is crucial.
- Pilot Study: The acceptance prediction experiment is described as a "pilot application," suggesting that further validation and refinement are needed.
- Extending Annotations: A key future direction is to extend the argumentative annotation layer to the full SciDTB corpus, creating a more comprehensive resource.
- Exploring Other Transfer Learning Methods: The authors plan to investigate other transfer learning approaches, such as multi-task learning and attention-based architectures.
- Broader Datasets: They intend to use larger datasets like PeerRead for acceptance prediction, which also include scores for aspects like substance and clarity, allowing for deeper analysis of how argumentative structure relates to specific quality dimensions.
- Cross-domain Applicability: While this study focuses on scientific abstracts, exploring the transferability of these methods to other domains remains an open question.
Summary updated