Transfer Learning with Large-Scale Quantile Regression

Jun Jin, Jun Yan, Robert H. Aseltine, Kun ChenTechnometrics 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "Trans-Lasso QR," a novel transfer learning method for high-dimensional quantile regression. It effectively leverages information from similar datasets to improve predictions on a target dataset, even when data distributions, model coefficients, and error distributions differ. This is crucial for big data applications where target data is scarce but related external data is abundant.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many real-world scenarios, we want to build predictive models for a specific "target" population, but the available data for this population is limited. However, there might be abundant data from other "source" populations that share similarities with the target. The challenge is to effectively transfer knowledge from these sources to improve the target model's performance without introducing "negative transfer" (where using source data actually degrades performance). This is particularly complex in quantile regression, where we're interested in predicting specific quantiles of an outcome (e.g., the 90th percentile of risk), and the relationships can vary across these quantiles. Existing transfer learning methods often struggle with the heterogeneity present in real-world data, such as different error distributions or varying relationships between features and outcomes across sources.

Methods

The authors propose a four-step transfer learning procedure for high-dimensional quantile regression:

  1. Single-Source Modeling: For each source dataset (and the target dataset), they first fit an $l_1$-penalized quantile regression model. This step is done independently for each source.
  2. Response Surrogation: To simplify the quantile regression problem, they construct "surrogate responses." This involves using an estimated error density function to transform the original response variable, making it amenable to linear regression techniques.
  3. Fusion Learning: This is the core transfer learning step where information from the target and the identified "informative" sources is combined. They fit an $l_1$-penalized regression model using the surrogate responses from all relevant sources (target and informative sources).
  4. Debiasing: Finally, they use only the target data to debias the fused estimator, aiming to refine the prediction specifically for the target population.

A key innovation is the development of an informative-source detection procedure. This procedure uses sample splitting and evaluates the performance of single-source transfer learning estimators on a held-out test set. Sources that lead to better performance than the target-only model are identified as "informative." This allows the method to selectively use beneficial sources and avoid negative transfer.

Datasets

The paper uses two main types of datasets:

  • Simulated Datasets: Extensive simulations are conducted to evaluate the proposed method under various conditions, including different levels of informativeness ($d$), numbers of informative sources ($|A|$), signal-to-noise ratios ($\eta$), and error distributions (normal and Cauchy). These simulations explore both homogeneous and heterogeneous designs for feature distributions.
  • Real-World Dataset: The methods are applied to flight QAR (Quick Access Recorder) data to predict the risk of hard landing. This dataset includes flight attributes for three types of airplanes: Boeing 737 (B737), Airbus A320 (A320), and Airbus A380 (A380). The A380 data is used as the target, with B737 and A320 data serving as sources.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Selective Transfer is Crucial: The paper strongly emphasizes that not all external data is helpful. Identifying "informative" sources is critical to avoid negative transfer and achieve positive transfer. Their data-driven informative source detection mechanism is a key contribution.
  • Quantile Regression's Complexity: The method specifically addresses the challenges of quantile regression, particularly the need to handle varying relationships across quantiles and the use of a non-differentiable loss function, which complicates standard transfer learning approaches.
  • Response Surrogation as a Bridge: The response surrogation technique is a clever way to bridge the gap between quantile regression and linear regression, making the fusion step more computationally tractable.
  • Robustness to Heterogeneity: The Trans-Lasso QR method is designed to be robust to various forms of heterogeneity (feature distributions, model coefficients, error distributions), making it applicable to a wider range of real-world problems.
  • Airplane Hard Landing Insights: The application to flight data reveals that aircraft from the same manufacturer (Airbus A320 and A380) are more similar and thus more informative sources for predicting hard landing risk for the A380, highlighting the importance of domain knowledge in understanding data similarity.

Key Results

  • Superior Performance: The proposed Trans-Lasso QR method consistently outperforms the "target-only" Lasso QR and "naive" transfer learning approaches (which use all sources indiscriminately) in terms of both mean squared error (MSE) and quantile loss (QL) across various simulation settings.
  • Oracle-Level Performance: The Trans-Lasso QR method, which performs informative set detection, achieves performance very close to the "oracle" Trans-Lasso QR (which assumes the informative set is known a priori). This validates the effectiveness of their source detection procedure.
  • Computational Efficiency: The paper highlights that their method offers superior computational efficiency compared to pooled transfer learning approaches, especially in large-scale settings, due to its parallelizable single-source modeling step.
  • Real-World Impact: In the airplane hard landing analysis, Trans-Lasso QR significantly reduces quantile loss for the A380 target, especially given its smaller sample size compared to other aircraft. This demonstrates the practical benefits of their approach.
  • Feature Importance: The analysis of flight data reveals that controllable "human factors" like speed, acceleration, and attitude are most relevant to hard landing risk, suggesting that pilot training could be a key area for risk mitigation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost for Very Large Datasets: While more efficient than pooled methods, the computational cost can still be significant for extremely large datasets, especially in the fusion learning step.
  • Assumption of Similar Features: The method assumes that source and target datasets share the same set of features.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest several avenues for future research:
  • Extending the framework to binary quantile regression using latent variable models, particularly for rare events.
  • Investigating scenarios with multiple targets and developing multivariate transfer learning models.
  • Developing "transfer learning without transfer" approaches that avoid pooling raw data, which could be beneficial for data privacy and integration challenges.
  • Exploring the use of composite quantile regression frameworks.
  • Investigating connections with hierarchical Bayesian modeling.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{jin2024transfer,
  author = {Jun Jin and Jun Yan and Robert H. Aseltine and Kun Chen},
  title = {{Transfer Learning with Large-Scale Quantile Regression}},
  journal = {Technometrics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1080/00401706.2024.2315952},
}
Figure