Transdiagnostic alterations in white matter microstructure associated with suicidal thoughts and behaviours in the ENIGMA Suicidal Thoughts and Behaviours consortium

Laura S. van Velzen, Lejla Čolić, Zuriel Ceja, Maria R. Dauvermann, Luca M. Villa, Hannah S. Savage, Yara J. Toenders, Niousha Dehestani, Alyssa H. Zhu, Adrián I. Campos, Lauren E. Salminen, Ingrid Agartz, Nina Alexander, Rosa Ayesa‐Arriola, Elizabeth D. Ballard, Nerisa Banaj, Carlotta Barkhau, Zeynep Başgöze, Jochen Bauer, Francesco Benedetti, Klaus Berger, Bianca Besteher, Katharina Brosch, Manuel Canal‐Rivero, Simon Červenka, Romain Colle, Colm G. Connolly, Emmanuelle Corruble, Philippe Courtet, Baptiste Couvy‐Duchesne, Benedicto Crespo‐Facorro, Kathryn R. Cullen, Udo Dannlowski, Jérémy Deverdun, Ana M. Díaz‐Zuluaga, Lorielle M. F. Dietze, Jennifer W. Evans, Negar Fani, Kira Flinkenflügel, Naomi P. Friedman, Ian H. Gotlib, Nynke A. Groenewold, Dominik Grotegerd, Tomáš Hájek, Alexander S. Hatoum, Marco Hermesdorf, Ian B. Hickie, Yoshiyuki Hirano, Tiffany C. Ho, Yuki Ikemizu, Frank Iorfino, Jonathan Ipser, Y. Isobe, Andrea Parolin Jackowski, Fabrice Jollant, Tilo Kircher, Melissa Klug, Sheri‐Michelle Koopowitz, Anna Kraus, Axel Krug, Emmanuelle Le Bars, Elisabeth J. Leehr, Meng Li, Elizabeth Lippard, Carlos López‐Jaramillo, Ivan S. Maximov, Andrew M. McIntosh, Katie A. McLaughlin, Sean R. McWhinney, Susanne Meinert, Elisa Melloni, Philip B. Mitchell, Benson Mwangi, Igor Nenadić, Stener Nerland, Émilie Olié, Víctor Ortiz‐García de la Foz, Pedro Mário Pan, Fabrício Pereira, Fabrizio Piras, Sara Poletti, Andrew E. Reineberg, Gloria Roberts, Rafael Romero-García, Matthew D. Sacchet, Giovanni Abrahão Salum, Anca‐Larisa Sandu, Carl M. Sellgren, Eiji Shimizu, Harry R. Smolker, Jair C. Soares, Gianfranco Spalletta, J. Douglas Steele, Frederike Stein, Dan J. Stein, Benjamin Straube, Lea Teutenberg, Florian Thomas‐Odenthal, Paula Usemann, Romain ValabrèguemedRxiv 2024 · DOI

This large-scale study from the ENIGMA consortium provides the most robust evidence to date that suicidal behavior is linked to subtle, widespread alterations in the brain's white matter "wiring," independent of a patient's specific psychiatric diagnosis. By pooling data from thousands of participants across 40 international sites, the researchers identified a specific neural signature—primarily lower fractional anisotropy in tracts involved in emotional regulation—that distinguishes individuals who have attempted suicide from those with similar mental health conditions who have not.

TL;DR

A massive "mega-analysis" of brain imaging data reveals that a history of suicide attempts is associated with subtle structural changes in white matter tracts responsible for emotional and cognitive control. These alterations persist regardless of the underlying psychiatric diagnosis, though recent suicidal thoughts alone do not show the same structural pattern.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Suicide is a global health crisis, yet our understanding of its biological roots remains fragmented. For decades, researchers have used Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) to look for "breaks" or "fraying" in the white matter—the brain's communication cables. However, results have been notoriously inconsistent. Small sample sizes and "noise" from different psychiatric disorders (like depression vs. bipolar disorder) made it impossible to tell if certain brain changes were due to the mental illness itself or specifically related to suicidal thoughts and behaviors (STBs).

The authors sought to clear this fog by conducting a transdiagnostic study: looking across many different diagnoses to find the common neural threads specifically tied to suicide attempts and ideation.

Methods

The researchers performed a mega-analysis, which involves pooling raw individual-level data from 40 different research cohorts rather than just comparing their final results.

  • Imaging Technique: They used DTI to measure four key metrics of white matter microstructure:
  • Fractional Anisotropy (FA): A proxy for the overall integrity and "directionality" of water flow along axons.
  • Mean, Axial, and Radial Diffusivity (MD, AD, RD): Measures that provide clues about membrane density and myelination (the insulation on the wires).
  • Standardization: To handle the "batch effects" of using different MRI scanners across 15 countries, they used the ENIGMA-DTI protocol and the ComBat algorithm for data harmonization.
  • Statistical Rigor: They employed multiple linear regression models, adjusting for age, sex, and their non-linear interactions, while applying False Discovery Rate (FDR) corrections to avoid "finding" patterns by pure chance.

Datasets

The study utilized a massive dataset from the ENIGMA Suicidal Thoughts and Behaviours (ENIGMA-STB) consortium:

  • Suicide Attempt (SA) Analysis: 652 individuals with a history of attempt, 1,871 clinical controls (diagnosed but no attempt), and 642 healthy controls.
  • Suicidal Ideation (SI) Analysis: 714 individuals with recent ideation, 1,184 clinical controls, and 1,240 healthy controls.
  • Diversity of Diagnosis: Participants had various conditions, including Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), Bipolar Disorder (BD), Schizophrenia, OCD, and PTSD.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Suicide Signature" is Transdiagnostic: The most important finding is that white matter alterations in suicide attempters were present even when compared to "clinical controls"—people with the same psychiatric diagnoses who had never attempted suicide. This suggests that suicidal behavior has its own neural footprint separate from general mental illness.
  • Circuitry of Control: The affected tracts—the corona radiata, thalamic radiation, fornix, and superior longitudinal fasciculus—are not random. They form the "thalamic-cortical circuitry" essential for emotional regulation, executive function, and behavioral inhibition. Fraying here might make it harder for an individual to "brake" an impulsive suicidal urge during a crisis.
  • Ideation vs. Action: Interestingly, while suicide attempts were linked to structural changes, recent ideation (thoughts) was not significantly different from clinical controls. This suggests that the structural "scars" or vulnerabilities in white matter are more closely tied to the transition from thought to action.
  • The Power of Scale: The effect sizes were small (Cohen’s $d < 0.25$). This explains why previous small studies failed to find consistent results; the signal is real but subtle, requiring thousands of subjects to detect reliably.

Key Results

  • SA vs. Healthy Controls: Widespread lower FA was found in 18 out of 25 white matter tracts.
  • SA vs. Clinical Controls: Significant lower FA was found in the corona radiata, thalamic radiation, fornix/stria terminalis, splenium of the corpus callosum, and superior longitudinal fasciculus.
  • Ideation: No significant microstructural differences were found between those with recent suicidal ideation and clinical controls after correcting for multiple comparisons.
  • Diffusivity: Higher Radial Diffusivity (RD) was observed in several tracts for attempters, potentially pointing toward differences in myelination as a biological driver.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors are careful to note that this study is cross-sectional. We don't know if these white matter changes are a pre-existing risk factor that makes someone vulnerable to suicide, or a consequence of the attempt itself (for example, brain damage caused by hypoxia during a near-fatal attempt).

Furthermore, while the results are statistically significant at a population level, the effect sizes are too small to use these brain scans as a diagnostic tool for individual patients today.

Future Work: The consortium emphasizes the need for longitudinal studies—tracking the same individuals over years—to see if changes in white matter integrity can predict future suicidal behavior, potentially opening the door for targeted neuro-interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Previous studies have suggested that alterations in white matter (WM) microstructure are implicated in suicidal thoughts and behaviours (STBs). However, findings of diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) studies have been inconsistent. In this large-scale mega-analysis conducted by the ENIGMA Suicidal Thoughts and Behaviours (ENIGMA-STB) consortium, we examined WM alterations associated with STBs. Data processing was standardised across sites, and resulting WM microstructure measures (fractional anisotropy, axial diffusivity, mean diffusivity and radial diffusivity) for 25 WM tracts were pooled across 40 cohorts. We compared these measures among individuals with a psychiatric diagnosis and lifetime history of suicide attempt (<i>n</i>=652; mean age=35.4±14.7; female=71.8%), individuals with a psychiatric diagnosis but no STB (i.e., clinical controls; <i>n</i>=1871; mean age=34±14.8; female=59.8%), and individuals with no mental disorder diagnosis and no STB (i.e., healthy controls; <i>n</i>=642; mean age=29.6±13.1; female=62.9%). We also compared these measures among individuals with recent suicidal ideation (<i>n</i>=714; mean age=36.3±15.3; female=66.1%), clinical controls (<i>n</i>=1184; mean age=36.8±15.6; female=63.1%), and healthy controls (<i>n</i>=1240; mean age= 31.6±15.5; female=61.0%). We found subtle but statistically significant effects, such as lower fractional anisotropy associated with a history of suicide attempt, over and above the effect of psychiatric diagnoses. These effects were strongest in the corona radiata, thalamic radiation, fornix/stria terminalis, corpus callosum and superior longitudinal fasciculus. Effect sizes were small (Cohen's <i>d</i> < 0.25). Recent suicidal ideation was not associated with alterations in WM microstructure. This large-scale coordinated mega-analysis revealed subtle regional and global alterations in WM microstructure in individuals with a history of suicide attempt. Longitudinal studies are needed to confirm whether these alterations are a risk factor for suicidal behaviour.
BibTeX
@misc{velzen2024transdiagnostic,
  author = {Laura S. van Velzen and Lejla Čolić and Zuriel Ceja and Maria R. Dauvermann and Luca M. Villa and Hannah S. Savage and Yara J. Toenders and Niousha Dehestani and Alyssa H. Zhu and Adrián I. Campos and Lauren E. Salminen and Ingrid Agartz and Nina Alexander and Rosa Ayesa‐Arriola and Elizabeth D. Ballard and Nerisa Banaj and Carlotta Barkhau and Zeynep Başgöze and Jochen Bauer and Francesco Benedetti and Klaus Berger and Bianca Besteher and Katharina Brosch and Manuel Canal‐Rivero and Simon Červenka and Romain Colle and Colm G. Connolly and Emmanuelle Corruble and Philippe Courtet and Baptiste Couvy‐Duchesne and Benedicto Crespo‐Facorro and Kathryn R. Cullen and Udo Dannlowski and Jérémy Deverdun and Ana M. Díaz‐Zuluaga and Lorielle M. F. Dietze and Jennifer W. Evans and Negar Fani and Kira Flinkenflügel and Naomi P. Friedman and Ian H. Gotlib and Nynke A. Groenewold and Dominik Grotegerd and Tomáš Hájek and Alexander S. Hatoum and Marco Hermesdorf and Ian B. Hickie and Yoshiyuki Hirano and Tiffany C. Ho and Yuki Ikemizu and Frank Iorfino and Jonathan Ipser and Y. Isobe and Andrea Parolin Jackowski and Fabrice Jollant and Tilo Kircher and Melissa Klug and Sheri‐Michelle Koopowitz and Anna Kraus and Axel Krug and Emmanuelle Le Bars and Elisabeth J. Leehr and Meng Li and Elizabeth Lippard and Carlos López‐Jaramillo and Ivan S. Maximov and Andrew M. McIntosh and Katie A. McLaughlin and Sean R. McWhinney and Susanne Meinert and Elisa Melloni and Philip B. Mitchell and Benson Mwangi and Igor Nenadić and Stener Nerland and Émilie Olié and Víctor Ortiz‐García de la Foz and Pedro Mário Pan and Fabrício Pereira and Fabrizio Piras and Sara Poletti and Andrew E. Reineberg and Gloria Roberts and Rafael Romero-García and Matthew D. Sacchet and Giovanni Abrahão Salum and Anca‐Larisa Sandu and Carl M. Sellgren and Eiji Shimizu and Harry R. Smolker and Jair C. Soares and Gianfranco Spalletta and J. Douglas Steele and Frederike Stein and Dan J. Stein and Benjamin Straube and Lea Teutenberg and Florian Thomas‐Odenthal and Paula Usemann and Romain Valabrègue},
  title = {{Transdiagnostic alterations in white matter microstructure associated with suicidal thoughts and behaviours in the ENIGMA Suicidal Thoughts and Behaviours consortium}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.11.07.24316876},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure