Transcriptome Reveals Allele Contribution to Heterosis in Maize

Jian Wu, Dequan Sun, Qian Zhao, Hongjun Yong, Degui Zhang, Zhuanfang Hao, Zhiqiang Zhou, Jienan Han, Xiaocong Zhang, Zhennan Xu, Xinhai Li, Mingshun Li, Jianfeng WengFrontiers in Plant Science 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the molecular basis of heterosis (hybrid vigor) in maize by analyzing gene expression patterns in hybrids and their parental lines across different developmental stages. They found that the unique combination and differential expression of parental alleles in hybrids, particularly during seed development, are key drivers of enhanced traits, offering insights for breeding more robust maize varieties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Heterosis is a crucial phenomenon driving significant yield increases in crops like maize. While its existence is well-established, the underlying molecular mechanisms remain complex and not fully understood. Specifically, how the interplay of parental genes within a hybrid leads to superior performance compared to either parent is a major question. Existing hypotheses include dominance, overdominance, and epistasis, but a comprehensive understanding of how gene expression contributes to these effects, especially across different developmental stages and tissues, is needed to effectively harness heterosis for crop improvement. This paper aims to dissect these gene expression dynamics to shed light on the genetic basis of heterosis in maize.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining experimental crosses with advanced molecular techniques:

  • Incomplete Diallel Cross (NCII): Four elite inbred maize lines were crossed to generate six hybrids. This design allows for the analysis of combining abilities and the effects of parental allele interactions.
  • Comprehensive mRNA Sequencing (RNA-Seq): This high-throughput sequencing technology was used to quantify gene expression levels across different tissues (leaves, ears, and seeds) and developmental stages of the parental lines and their hybrids.
  • Differential Gene Expression (DEG) Analysis: Standard bioinformatics pipelines were used to identify genes that showed significant differences in expression between parental lines and hybrids, or between different tissues and stages.
  • Gene Expression Pattern Classification: DEGs were categorized into various patterns, including:
  • Qualitative variations: Parental Co-Silence Expression (PCE), Parent-Specific Expression (PSE), Hybrid-Specific Expression (HSE), and Single-Parent Expression (SPE).
  • Quantitative variations: Positive Super-Dominance (PSD), Positive Dominance (PD), Partial Positive Dominance (PPD), Mid-Parent (MP), Partial Negative Dominance (PND), Negative Dominance (ND), and Negative Super-Dominance (NSD). These categories describe how gene expression in the hybrid relates to the expression levels of its parents.
  • Functional Enrichment Analysis (GO and KEGG): These analyses were performed on sets of differentially expressed genes (especially ZC-specific genes) to identify the biological pathways and molecular functions they are involved in.

Datasets

The study utilized RNA-Seq data generated from:

  • Four elite maize inbred parental lines: Zheng58 (Z), Chang7-2 (C), Mo17 (M), and Qi319 (Q).
  • Six maize hybrids: Generated from the NCII crosses of these parental lines, including Zhengdan958 (ZC), Zhengdan958 x Mo17 (ZM), Zhengdan958 x Qi319 (ZQ), Chang7-2 x Mo17 (CM), Chang7-2 x Qi319 (CQ), and Mo17 x Qi319 (MQ).
  • Three tissue types: Leaves (L), ears (E), and seeds (S).
  • Three developmental stages: Represented by the five-leaf stage (leaves), spikelet differentiation stage (ears), and 15 days post-pollination (seeds).

The raw sequence data has been submitted to NCBI (BioProject: PRJNA682889).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Allelic Complementarity is Key: The study strongly suggests that heterosis in maize is driven by the complementary expression of parental alleles in the hybrid. This means that genes from one parent might compensate for or enhance the function of genes from the other parent.
  • Qualitative vs. Quantitative Variation: Both types of gene expression variation are important. Qualitative variations (like SPE and PSE) highlight which parental alleles are expressed, while quantitative variations (like NSD and PSD) show the degree of expression bias.
  • Seed Development is Critical: The early reproductive growth stage, particularly seed development, appears to be a critical period where gene expression patterns significantly influence heterosis. Interestingly, in seeds, expression biased towards low-value parental alleles (NSD) showed a surprising association with quantitative superiority.
  • Zhengdan958 (ZC) as a Model: The popular hybrid Zhengdan958 (ZC) exhibited unique gene expression patterns, particularly a higher proportion of Single-Parent Expression (SPE) in its seeds compared to other hybrids. This suggests ZC's strong heterosis might be linked to its specific allelic expression profile.
  • Tissue-Specific Pathways: ZC-specific genes were enriched in pathways crucial for plant growth and yield, such as photosynthesis, plant hormone signal transduction, and biosynthesis, underscoring their role in conferring hybrid vigor.

Key Results

  • Prevalence of Partial Expression: Single-Parent Expression (SPE) and Parent-Specific Expression (PSE) were the most prevalent qualitative variations, accounting for 43.73% and 41.07% of observed variations, respectively.
  • Dominance in Quantitative Variation: Negative Super-Dominance (NSD) and Positive Super-Dominance (PSD) were the most common quantitative variations, at 31.06% and 24.30%, respectively.
  • Seed Expression Bias: In seeds, gene expression patterns were skewed towards low-value parental alleles, which was unexpectedly associated with significant quantitative variation-associated superiority.
  • ZC's Unique SPE: ZC seeds showed a significantly higher proportion of SPE-DEGs (41.36%) compared to the average of other hybrids (28.36%).
  • Enriched Pathways in ZC: ZC-specific genes were enriched in pathways like photosynthesis, plant hormone signal transduction, and biosynthesis, suggesting these are critical for its superior performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity of Heterosis: The authors acknowledge that heterosis is a complex phenomenon, and while gene expression is a key component, other factors like DNA methylation and epigenetic modifications likely also play a role.
  • Predictive Power: While the study provides insights into the mechanisms, predicting heterosis intensity for a given inbred parental line combination remains challenging.
  • Further Validation: The study suggests that further investigation into the specific roles of ZC-specific genes and pathways, particularly those identified in seed development, is warranted. Future work could focus on targeted gene editing or breeding strategies to leverage these findings for developing even more robust and high-yielding maize hybrids.

Summary updated

Abstract

Heterosis, which has greatly increased maize yields, is associated with gene expression patterns during key developmental stages that enhance hybrid phenotypes relative to parental phenotypes. Before heterosis can be more effectively used for crop improvement, hybrid maize developmental gene expression patterns must be better understood. Here, six maize hybrids, including the popular hybrid Zhengdan958 (ZC) from China, were studied. Maize hybrids created in-house were generated using an incomplete diallel cross (NCII)-based strategy from four elite inbred parental lines. Differential gene expression (DEG) profiles corresponding to three developmental stages revealed that hybrid partial expression patterns exhibited complementarity of expression of certain parental genes, with parental allelic expression patterns varying both qualitatively and quantitatively in hybrids. Single-parent expression (SPE) and parent-specific expression (PSE) types of qualitative variation were most prevalent, 43.73 and 41.07% of variation, respectively. Meanwhile, negative super-dominance (NSD) and positive super-dominance (PSD) types of quantitative variation were most prevalent, 31.06 and 24.30% of variation, respectively. During the early reproductive growth stage, the gene expression pattern differed markedly from other developmental stage patterns, with allelic expression patterns during seed development skewed toward low-value parental alleles in hybrid seeds exhibiting significant quantitative variation-associated superiority. Comparisons of qualitative gene expression variation rates between ZC and other hybrids revealed proportions of SPE-DEGs (41.36%) in ZC seed DEGs that significantly exceeded the average proportion of SPE-DEGs found in seeds of other hybrids (28.36%). Importantly, quantitative gene expression variation rate comparisons between ZC and hybrids, except for transgressive expression, revealed that the ZC rate exceeded the average rate for other hybrids, highlighting the importance of partial gene expression in heterosis. Moreover, enriched ZC DEGs exhibiting distinct tissue-specific expression patterns belonged to four biological pathways, including photosynthesis, plant hormone signal transduction, biology metabolism and biosynthesis. These results provide valuable technical insights for creating hybrids exhibiting strong heterosis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2021transcriptome,
  author = {Jian Wu and Dequan Sun and Qian Zhao and Hongjun Yong and Degui Zhang and Zhuanfang Hao and Zhiqiang Zhou and Jienan Han and Xiaocong Zhang and Zhennan Xu and Xinhai Li and Mingshun Li and Jianfeng Weng},
  title = {{Transcriptome Reveals Allele Contribution to Heterosis in Maize}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2021.739072},
}
Figure