Transcriptional activity and strain-specific history of mouse pseudogenes

Cristina Sisu, Paul Muir, Adam Frankish, Ian T. Fiddes, Mark Diekhans, David Thybert, Duncan T. Odom, Paul Flicek, Thomas Keane, Tim Hubbard, Jennifer Harrow, Mark GersteinNature Communications 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Pseudogenes are ideal markers of genome remodelling. In turn, the mouse is an ideal platform for studying them, particularly with the recent availability of strain-sequencing and transcriptional data. Here, combining both manual curation and automatic pipelines, we present a genome-wide annotation of the pseudogenes in the mouse reference genome and 18 inbred mouse strains (available via the mouse.pseudogene.org resource). We also annotate 165 unitary pseudogenes in mouse, and 303 in human. The overall pseudogene repertoire in mouse is similar to that in human in terms of size, biotype distribution, and family composition. Notable differences arise in the pseudogene age distribution, with multiple retro-transpositional bursts in mouse evolutionary history and only one in human. Furthermore, in each strain about a fifth of all pseudogenes are unique, reflecting strain-specific evolution. Finally, we find that ~15% of the mouse pseudogenes are transcribed, and that highly transcribed parent genes tend to give rise to many processed pseudogenes.

Introduction: Beyond "Junk DNA"

For decades, pseudogenes—sequences that resemble functional genes but have lost their protein-coding ability due to mutations—were dismissed as "junk DNA." However, modern genomics reveals they are actually high-resolution markers of genome remodeling. While the human pseudogene repertoire has been extensively mapped, the mouse, the most critical model organism in biomedicine, lacked a detailed, strain-specific annotation until now.

Because different mouse strains exhibit vastly different phenotypes, understanding the "genomic fossils" left behind in their respective lineages helps researchers trace the specific evolutionary pressures that shaped them. This study moves beyond a single reference genome to understand the "pan-genome" of mouse pseudogenes across 18 inbred lineages.

Methodology: A Hybrid Annotation Strategy

To ensure high-quality data, the researchers employed a hybrid approach to annotation. Manual curation via the GENCODE framework established a high-confidence "gold standard" in the mouse reference genome. This was complemented by automated pipelines: PseudoPipe for identifying processed and duplicated pseudogenes, and RetroFinder for retrotransposed elements.

To map these findings across 18 different strains, the team utilized HAL tools and BEDTools to "lift over" reference annotations onto strain-specific assemblies. Annotations were categorized into three confidence levels: Level 1 (manually and automatically confirmed), Level 2 (manual only), and Level 3 (automated only). Finally, transcriptional activity was assessed by integrating RNA-seq data from ENCODE and the Mouse Genome Project.

Evolutionary Context and Strain Diversity

The study analyzed 18 inbred strains, ranging from classical laboratory strains like BALB/c and DBA/2 to wild-derived strains such as M. spretus and M. castaneus. This diversity allows for a deep look into the evolutionary timeline of the mouse lineage compared to primates.

Evolutionary divergence of mouse strains compared to the human/primate lineage.

One of the most striking findings is the difference in evolutionary "bursts." Unlike humans, who experienced one major burst of retrotransposition approximately 40 million years ago, mice have undergone multiple successive bursts. This suggests a significantly more dynamic and "restless" genome.

Key Results: The Mouse Pseudogene Landscape

The final annotation identified 20,397 pseudogenes in the mouse reference genome. The distribution across strains reveals significant genomic turnover; while 97.7% of loci are preserved across classical lab strains, preservation drops to only 10% when comparing the reference mouse to the more distant Mus pahari.

Pseudogene counts and classifications (Level 1-3 and biotypes) across 18 inbred mouse strains.

Strain-Specific Evolution and Transcription

Roughly 20% of pseudogenes in any given strain are unique to that lineage, reflecting rapid evolution over a relatively short timeframe. Furthermore, approximately 15% of mouse pseudogenes are transcribed. This transcriptional activity suggests these elements may not be silent relics but could serve secondary regulatory roles, such as acting as microRNA "decoys" or producing long non-coding RNAs (lncRNAs).

The study also observed a "rich get richer" effect: a strong correlation exists between the expression level of a "parent" gene and the number of processed pseudogenes it generates. Housekeeping genes, such as GAPDH and ribosomal proteins, consequently have the largest "fossil records" within the genome.

Conclusion

This comprehensive resource, available at mouse.pseudogene.org, provides a new lens through which to view mouse models. By identifying 165 unitary pseudogenes—genes functional in humans but "dead" in mice—researchers can better understand species-specific biology. Future work will focus on the functional significance of the transcribed pseudogene fraction, determining if they are mere "transcriptional noise" or repurposed regulatory elements.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pseudogenes are ideal markers of genome remodelling. In turn, the mouse is an ideal platform for studying them, particularly with the recent availability of strain-sequencing and transcriptional data. Here, combining both manual curation and automatic pipelines, we present a genome-wide annotation of the pseudogenes in the mouse reference genome and 18 inbred mouse strains (available via the mouse.pseudogene.org resource). We also annotate 165 unitary pseudogenes in mouse, and 303, in human. The overall pseudogene repertoire in mouse is similar to that in human in terms of size, biotype distribution, and family composition (e.g. with GAPDH and ribosomal proteins being the largest families). Notable differences arise in the pseudogene age distribution, with multiple retro-transpositional bursts in mouse evolutionary history and only one in human. Furthermore, in each strain about a fifth of all pseudogenes are unique, reflecting strain-specific evolution. Finally, we find that ~15% of the mouse pseudogenes are transcribed, and that highly transcribed parent genes tend to give rise to many processed pseudogenes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sisu2020transcriptional,
  author = {Cristina Sisu and Paul Muir and Adam Frankish and Ian T. Fiddes and Mark Diekhans and David Thybert and Duncan T. Odom and Paul Flicek and Thomas Keane and Tim Hubbard and Jennifer Harrow and Mark Gerstein},
  title = {{Transcriptional activity and strain-specific history of mouse pseudogenes}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-020-17157-w},
}
Figure