Transactive Energy System Deployment Over Insecure Communication Links

Yang Lu, Jianming Lian, Minghui Zhu, Ke MaIEEE Trans Autom. Sci. Eng 2024 · OpenReview

Abstract

As power grids transition toward decentralized architectures, Transactive Energy Systems (TES) have emerged as a critical mechanism for balancing supply and demand through market-based interactions. However, the reliance on insecure communication links introduces significant privacy and security vulnerabilities. This paper presents a unified cryptographic framework designed to protect individual bidding information and detect malicious data injection attacks. By integrating an enhanced Paillier encryption scheme with a novel "block design" and a stamp-concatenation digital signature mechanism, the proposed system achieves high computational efficiency and robust cyber-resiliency.

Introduction

Transactive Energy Systems (TES) facilitate the optimal allocation of energy resources by engaging suppliers and consumers in market operations. In a typical TES, participants submit bidding curves—representing their willingness to buy or sell energy at specific prices—to a central coordinator. While promising, this approach faces two primary challenges when deployed over public or insecure networks: the leakage of sensitive consumer habits or business secrets (privacy) and the potential for data tampering or reordering by malicious actors (security).

Problem Statement

Existing research in TES often prioritizes coordination mechanisms over cyber-resiliency. Standard encryption methods frequently introduce prohibitive computational overhead, making them unsuitable for real-time market clearing. Furthermore, traditional digital signatures may verify the sender's identity but fail to detect sophisticated temporal attacks, such as message reordering or replay attacks, which can destabilize the grid or lead to financial fraud.

Proposed Methodology

The authors propose a unified framework leveraging the additively homomorphic properties of Paillier cryptography. This allows a coordinator to perform necessary mathematical operations on encrypted data without ever accessing the underlying plaintext.

1. Privacy Preservation via Block Design

To address the computational bottleneck of point-wise encryption, the framework introduces a "block design." Instead of encrypting each point on a bidding curve individually, multiple data points are concatenated into a single large integer. This allows the entire curve to be encrypted and aggregated in a single operation, significantly reducing processing time. A semi-honest Third-Party Aggregator (TP) is utilized to sum these encrypted bids, ensuring the coordinator only receives the aggregate total.

2. Security via Stamp-Concatenation

To counter data injection and reordering attacks, the framework employs an enhanced digital signature scheme. Each message is appended with a unique index "stamp" before being signed. This mechanism ensures that the receiver can verify not only the integrity of the data but also its correct sequence and timeliness, preventing attackers from successfully replaying or swapping valid messages.

Experimental Validation

The framework was tested using a simulated distribution feeder with 1,000 residential air conditioning (AC) units. The simulation incorporated:

  • Load Dynamics: A second-order equivalent thermal parameter (ETP) model for AC units.
  • Environmental Data: Typical Meteorological Year (TMY2) data for Columbus, Ohio.
  • Market Data: Real-world wholesale electricity prices from the PJM market.

Key Results

The simulation results demonstrated that the proposed cryptographic enhancements do not compromise market accuracy; clearing prices remained identical to those calculated using plaintext data.

The "block design" provided a massive efficiency boost. For a bidding curve with 101 sampled points using a 4000-bit key, the processing time per agent was reduced from 128 seconds to 1.4 seconds—a 101-fold improvement. Additionally, the stamp-concatenation mechanism successfully detected four distinct attack types, including data replacement and reordering, which standard signature schemes failed to identify.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research provides a practical path for the secure deployment of TES in modern power systems. While motivated by TES, the proposed framework is broadly applicable to enhancing privacy and security in any general hierarchical control system. Future work will address "Byzantine attacks" where legitimate participants may intentionally submit distorted data. Further investigation into preventing collusion between the coordinator and the third-party aggregator will also be essential for ensuring long-term system integrity.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, the privacy and security issues associated with the transactive energy system (TES) deployment over insecure communication links are addressed. In particular, it is ensured that 1) individual agents’ bidding information is kept private throughout hierarchical market-based interactions; and 2) any extraneous data injection attack can be quickly and easily detected. An implementation framework is proposed to enable the cryptography-based enhancement of privacy and security for the deployment of any general hierarchical systems including TESs. Under the proposed framework, a unified cryptography-based approach is developed to achieve both privacy and security simultaneously. Specifically, privacy preservation is realized by an enhanced Paillier encryption scheme, where a block design is proposed to significantly improve computational efficiency. Attack detection is further achieved by an enhanced Paillier digital signature scheme, where a stamp-concatenation mechanism is proposed to enable detection of data replace and reorder attacks. Simulation results verify the effectiveness of the proposed cyber-resilient design for transactive energy systems. Note to Practitioners—This paper is motivated by addressing the issues of cyber resiliency for practically deploying transactive energy system (TES) but it is also applicable to the problem of enhancing the privacy and security for any general hierarchical control systems. TES is an emerging control approach that engages energy suppliers and customers through market operations and uses the price to optimally allocate energy resources. While it has been shown to be promising for power system applications, the underlying market-based interactions raise significant concerns of privacy (data leakage) and security (data tampering). However, existing TES works only focus on the coordination mechanism instead of privacy and security issues. This paper proposes a new cryptography-based TES design for practical deployment. Specifically, to protect privacy, individual supply and demand amounts to be exchanged are all encrypted in a particular way such that the original amounts cannot be inferred from the encrypted amounts, while the desired computation for setting the market clearing price can be carried out over the encrypted amounts, thus generating an encrypted result which, when decrypted, matches that of the same computation over the original amounts. To achieve security, for each exchanged data, its sender generates a particular digital signature which is exchanged together with the data. This enables the receiver to automatically detect the integrity by checking whether a mathematical relationship holds for the pair of data and signature. In our future research, we will investigate more challenging scenarios where some suppliers and customers themselves could be corrupted and purposely submit distorted amounts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2024transactive,
  author = {Yang Lu and Jianming Lian and Minghui Zhu and Ke Ma},
  title = {{Transactive Energy System Deployment Over Insecure Communication Links}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Trans Autom. Sci. Eng},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=uvd5vpOKMC},
}
Figure