Trajectory Tracking Control of High-Speed Vehicles on Wet and Slippery Roads

Xiaohua Song, Kui Chen, Yujia Zheng, Xiaoyan ZhangSensors 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel hybrid control strategy that fuses Model Predictive Control (MPC) with Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) control to enhance the trajectory tracking accuracy and stability of high-speed vehicles on challenging wet and slippery roads. The proposed MPC-PID controller significantly improves tracking performance, comfort, economy, and safety, offering a practical solution for autonomous driving in adverse conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Autonomous driving systems rely heavily on accurate trajectory tracking to ensure safe and reliable operation. While Model Predictive Control (MPC) is a powerful tool for this, its performance can degrade significantly under challenging conditions like high-speed driving on wet and slippery roads. These conditions drastically reduce tire-road adhesion, making vehicles prone to hydroplaning, skidding, and loss of control. Existing research often focuses on simpler driving scenarios, leaving a gap in robust control strategies for these high-risk situations. The challenge lies in balancing the need for precise predictive control with the real-time responsiveness required to handle the dynamic complexities and nonlinearities introduced by low-adhesion surfaces.

Methods

The core of this research is a hybrid MPC-PID control strategy.

  • MPC (Model Predictive Control): This forms the backbone of the system, utilizing a vehicle dynamics model to predict future behavior and optimize control actions over a defined horizon. The authors employ a nonlinear vehicle dynamics model, linearized into a "linear error model" for computational efficiency. A multi-objective co-optimization objective function is used, balancing tracking accuracy, stability, comfort, and economy, with the inclusion of a relaxation factor to ensure feasible solutions.
  • PID (Proportional-Integral-Derivative) Control: This traditional control method is integrated to complement MPC. PID control is known for its fast response and simplicity. In this hybrid approach, the PID controller acts as a feedback mechanism, compensating for the MPC's potential delays in responding to rapid changes in vehicle state, especially crucial on slippery surfaces. It refines the control output from the MPC to enhance real-time performance and robustness.
  • Vehicle Dynamics Model: A 3-DOF bicycle model is used, incorporating assumptions like a flat road, rigid suspension, and neglecting load transfer. This model is linearized for MPC.
  • Multi-Objective Evaluation Index: The authors define comprehensive metrics for tracking accuracy, comfort, economy, and safety to holistically evaluate the controller's performance.

Datasets

The authors do not explicitly mention using pre-existing datasets for training. Instead, they rely on simulations using Carsim/MATLAB Simulink to evaluate their proposed controller under various conditions. This simulation environment allows for controlled testing of different road adhesion coefficients, driving speeds, and controller parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of MPC and PID: The most significant insight is the effectiveness of combining MPC's predictive power with PID's rapid response. This hybrid approach overcomes the limitations of each individual method, particularly in dynamic and low-adhesion scenarios.
  • Low-Adhesion is a Major Hurdle: The research strongly highlights how drastically road adhesion affects vehicle dynamics and control performance. Even with advanced controllers, maintaining stability and accuracy on wet and slippery roads is a substantial challenge.
  • Trade-offs in Controller Parameters: The study demonstrates that parameters like prediction and control horizons in MPC significantly impact both tracking accuracy and computational load. Finding the right balance is crucial for real-time applications.
  • Comprehensive Evaluation is Key: Relying solely on tracking accuracy is insufficient. The inclusion of comfort, economy, and safety metrics provides a more complete picture of the controller's overall effectiveness in real-world driving.

Key Results

The joint MPC-PID controller demonstrated significant improvements across various metrics:

  • Tracking Accuracy: Improved by at least 22.2% on wet and slippery roads.
  • Comfort: Improved by at least 9.4%.
  • Economy: Improved by at least 19.8%.
  • Safety: Improved by at least 5.3%.

The simulations showed that the hybrid controller effectively mitigated issues like "shimmy" phenomena observed with pure MPC on slippery surfaces, especially at higher speeds. The controller also maintained performance across different road adhesion coefficients (μ = 0.4, 0.65, 0.85) and longitudinal speeds (30 km/h to 120 km/h), though performance generally degraded at higher speeds.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The vehicle dynamics model used is a simplified 3-DOF bicycle model. While linearized for MPC, it might not capture all nuances of real-world vehicle dynamics, especially under extreme conditions.
  • Simulation-Based: The results are based on simulations. While Carsim/MATLAB Simulink are robust tools, real-world testing is necessary to fully validate the controller's performance and robustness.
  • Parameter Tuning: The paper discusses the influence of parameters, but optimal tuning for all scenarios might require further investigation.

The authors suggest that this work provides a strong foundation for high-speed trajectory tracking on challenging roads and offers practical significance for the deployment of autonomous vehicles in complex environments. Future work could involve real-world validation and exploring more advanced vehicle dynamics models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Autonomous vehicle trajectory tracking control is one of the hot topics in the autonomous driving field. One of the most widely used control methods is MPC (Model Predictive Control). As the control system generally becomes more nonlinear and complex, more nonlinear system factors are added to the MPC method. However, tracking accuracy and the amount of calculation needed are both dependent on a lot of contradictions for NMPC (Nonlinear Model Predictive Control). This research proposes a control algorithm for MPC-fused PID (Proportional-Integral-Derivative) control that ensures tracking accuracy under different high-speed driving conditions on wet and slippery road surfaces. The objective of the algorithm is twofold: first, to enhance trajectory tracking accuracy, and second, to ensure real-time control and optimize the vehicle's comfort, economy, and safety indexes. The results of the joint simulation in Carsim/MATLAB Simulink show that trajectory tracking accuracy is improved by at least 22.2% under high-speed driving conditions of a vehicle on a wet and slippery road. At the same time, the comfort, economy, and safety of the vehicle are improved by at least 9.4%, 19.8%, and 5.3%, respectively.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2025trajectory,
  author = {Xiaohua Song and Kui Chen and Yujia Zheng and Xiaoyan Zhang},
  title = {{Trajectory Tracking Control of High-Speed Vehicles on Wet and Slippery Roads}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/s25175450},
}
Figure