Trajectories of Outpatient Service Utilisation of Hypertensive Patients in Tertiary Hospitals in China

Zijing Pan, Wanchun Xu, Zhong Li, Chengzhong Xu, Fangfang Lu, Pei Zhang, Liang Zhang, Ting YeInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses Latent Class Growth Analysis (LCGA) to identify distinct patterns of outpatient healthcare utilization among hypertensive patients in Chinese tertiary hospitals. The findings reveal four key trajectories—stable-low, low-fluctuating, high-fluctuating, and stable-high—each with unique demographic and medical expenditure profiles, highlighting the need for tailored management strategies to improve patient outcomes and reduce healthcare costs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hypertension is a major global health challenge with a growing prevalence, particularly in developing countries like China. While tertiary hospitals are crucial for managing complex cases, a significant number of hypertensive patients utilize their outpatient services. However, the utilization patterns of these patients are not well-characterized, leading to potential inefficiencies in resource allocation and suboptimal patient management. This paper addresses the gap in understanding the longitudinal trajectories of outpatient service utilization among hypertensive patients in tertiary hospitals and identifies the factors that influence these patterns. This knowledge is vital for developing targeted interventions and improving the overall management of hypertension, aiming to reduce both the economic burden on patients and the strain on healthcare resources.

Methods

The study employed Latent Class Growth Analysis (LCGA), a statistical technique used to identify unobserved subgroups (latent classes) within a population that exhibit similar developmental trajectories over time. For this research, LCGA was used to group patients based on their monthly outpatient service utilization patterns over a 12-month period. To determine the optimal number of trajectory groups, model fit statistics such as the Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) and Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) were utilized.

Following the identification of these trajectory groups, one-way ANOVA and chi-square tests were used to compare demographic characteristics and medical utilization variables across the identified groups. Finally, multinomial logistic regression was employed to identify the determinants of these outpatient service utilization trajectories, examining how factors like age, gender, residence, education, and prior medical service utilization influence which trajectory a patient falls into.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 9822 patients diagnosed with hypertension who received hypertension-related medical care in Yichang, China, between January 1 and December 31, 2016. The data was extracted from the Yichang Health Management Centre's interconnected hospital information system, population information database, and public health information system. All patient data was de-identified.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Heterogeneity in Utilization: Hypertensive patients are not a monolithic group when it comes to healthcare seeking behavior. There's significant variation in how they utilize outpatient services over time, suggesting a one-size-fits-all approach to management is unlikely to be effective.
  • Tertiary Hospitals as Primary Care for Some: A substantial portion of patients (nearly 30%) fall into a "stable-high" utilization trajectory, suggesting that for some, tertiary hospitals are effectively serving as their primary source of ongoing care, potentially due to perceived higher quality or convenience.
  • Fluctuating Use Indicates Acute Needs: The "fluctuating" trajectory groups (low and high) likely represent patients who primarily seek tertiary care during acute exacerbations or when their condition becomes more severe, rather than for routine follow-up.
  • Socioeconomic Factors Matter: Place of residence (urban vs. rural) and education level are significant predictors of a patient's utilization trajectory, pointing to potential disparities in access, awareness, or health-seeking behaviors.
  • Cost vs. Utilization: While higher utilization generally correlates with higher costs, the study found that inpatient cost did not significantly differ across trajectories, suggesting that outpatient utilization patterns might be more indicative of overall healthcare expenditure management.

Key Results

  • Four Trajectory Groups Identified: The LCGA identified four distinct trajectories of outpatient service utilization:
  • Stable-low (34.7%): Characterized by consistently low outpatient visits, with a slight increase over time.
  • Low-fluctuating (13.4%): Showed an initial sharp decrease in visits, followed by minimal utilization.
  • High-fluctuating (22.5%): Exhibited high utilization in the first half of the year, followed by a sharp decline.
  • Stable-high (29.4%): Maintained the highest level of outpatient service utilization throughout the year, with a slight decrease over time.
  • Demographic Differences: Significant differences were observed in age, gender, marital status, and place of residence across the four groups (p < 0.001). For instance, the "stable-high" group (Trajectory 4) had a higher proportion of older patients (≥65 years) and males compared to other groups.
  • Medical Utilization Differences: Significant differences were also found in outpatient visit times, outpatient costs, and overall medical costs (p < 0.001). The "stable-high" group had the highest outpatient visit times and costs.
  • Predictors of Trajectories: Determinants for outpatient service utilization patterns included place of residence, education level, outpatient visit times, inpatient service utilization, and outpatient cost. For example, patients with primary school education had a higher probability of being in the "stable-high" trajectory.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Health Status and Complications Not Included: The study did not incorporate patients' specific health status, disease severity, or complications, which could significantly influence their healthcare utilization patterns.
  • Medical Insurance Information Missing: Data on medical insurance was not collected, and insurance status can play a crucial role in patients' decisions regarding healthcare service utilization.
  • Medication Expenditures Not Captured: The study did not include medication expenditures, which constitute a significant portion of total medical costs for hypertensive patients, potentially biasing the analysis of medical expenditures. Self-medication was also not accounted for.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Incorporating Comorbidities and Health Status: Future studies should consider patients' complications and comorbid conditions to provide a more accurate description of the relationship between utilization trajectories and health outcomes.
  • Analyzing Socioeconomic Factors: Further investigation into socioeconomic characteristics such as income and medical insurance is recommended to develop more tailored intervention measures.
  • Exploring Primary vs. Tertiary Care: Further research could explore the reasons behind the preference for tertiary hospitals and investigate strategies to effectively channel patients to primary healthcare institutions for routine management.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study aims to identify the characteristics and trajectories of outpatient service utilisation for hypertensive patients in tertiary hospitals. This study also attempts to investigate the determinants of the trajectories of outpatient service utilisation. A total of 9822 patients with hypertension and hypertension-related medical utilisation were recruited in Yichang, China from January 1 to December 31 in 2016. The latent trajectories of outpatient service utilisation were identified through latent class growth analysis. Differences in the demographic characteristics and medical utilisation among patients in different trajectories were tested by one-way ANOVA and chi-square analysis. The predictors of the trajectory groups of outpatient service utilisation were identified through multinomial logistic regression. Four trajectory groups were determined as stable-low (34.7%), low-fluctuating (13.4%), high-fluctuating (22.5%), and stable-high (29.4%). Significant differences were observed in all demographic characteristics (<i>p</i> < 0.001) and medical service utilisation variables (<i>p</i> < 0.001) among the four trajectories except for inpatient cost (<i>p</i> = 0.072). Determinants for outpatient service utilisation patterns include the place of residence, education level, outpatient visit times, inpatient service utilisation, and outpatient cost. Overall, hypertensive patients visiting outpatient units in the tertiary hospital were middle-aged, elderly, and well-educated, and they received poor follow-up services. The four identified latent trajectories have different characteristics and medical utilisation patterns. Trajectory group-based measurements are necessary for hypertension management and economic burden reduction.
BibTeX
@article{pan2020trajectories,
  author = {Zijing Pan and Wanchun Xu and Zhong Li and Chengzhong Xu and Fangfang Lu and Pei Zhang and Liang Zhang and Ting Ye},
  title = {{Trajectories of Outpatient Service Utilisation of Hypertensive Patients in Tertiary Hospitals in China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph17030852},
}
Figure