Trait‐based mechanistic approach highlights global patterns and losses of herbivore biomass functional diversity

Fabio Berzaghi, Dan Zhu, John Alroy, Philippe CiaisFunctional 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel mechanistic model (REMAP) that integrates mammalian herbivores into Earth System Science by classifying them into 37 functional groups based on key traits. The study reveals significant global losses in herbivore biomass due to human activity, with small herbivores now dominating the remaining biomass, and identifies actual evapotranspiration as the primary driver of herbivore distribution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mammalian herbivores play a crucial role in Earth's biogeochemical cycles and ecosystem functioning. However, current Earth System Science models often lack detailed representations of mammalian populations, hindering our understanding of their ecological impact and the consequences of their decline. Existing models struggle to capture the diversity of herbivore species and their complex interactions with vegetation. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a mechanistic global model that accounts for the functional diversity of herbivores, allowing for a more accurate assessment of their biomass, distribution, and the drivers behind changes in their populations.

Methods

The core of this research is the development of the REMAP (REproduce MAmmal Populations) model. This model utilizes a trait-based approach to classify mammalian herbivores into 37 distinct functional types (HFTs). This classification is based on four key traits: diet composition (leaf, fruit, seed), adult body mass (categorized into micro, small, and large), digestive system (hindgut or foregut), and folivory type (grazer, browser, mixed-feeder) for leaf-eaters.

The HFT classification was coupled with the ORCHIDEE global vegetation model to simulate herbivore populations. REMAP models the carrying capacity of each HFT based on physiological processes like metabolism, growth, mortality, and competition for food, which is determined by the vegetation model's output of plant biomass. The model was used to estimate both pre-industrial (potential) and present-day herbivore biomass, accounting for habitat and range losses caused by anthropogenic activities.

Datasets

The study utilized several existing datasets for mammal trait data:

  • Phylacine: Provided species ranges and taxonomic information.
  • Mammal Diet 2, Elton Traits, and PanTHERIA: Contributed life-history traits such as body mass and diet preferences.

For empirical mammal population density and biomass, data were compiled from:

  • Hatton et al. (2015) and Santini, Isaac, & Ficetola (2018): Two primary sources for density estimates.
  • Literature search: Supplemented with 433 additional records.

Environmental data for regression analysis included:

  • Abatzoglou et al. (2018) and Fick & Hijmans (2017): Freely available datasets for plant evapotranspiration, precipitation, and temperature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Functional Diversity Matters: Simply counting species isn't enough. Grouping herbivores by their eco-physiological traits (diet, body mass, digestion) reveals distinct functional roles and allows for a more nuanced understanding of their impact on ecosystems.
  • Small Herbivores are Dominant (Now): While large herbivores historically held more biomass, human-induced losses have shifted the balance. Small herbivores now constitute a larger proportion of the global herbivore biomass, highlighting their critical, often overlooked, role.
  • Water and Energy are Key: Actual evapotranspiration is the strongest predictor of where herbivores live and how much biomass they can sustain, challenging the traditional view that intermediate precipitation (like in savannas) is always optimal for large herbivores.
  • Human Impact is Profound: The study quantifies significant biomass losses, particularly for large herbivores, underscoring the widespread impact of habitat destruction and range contraction.
  • Pre-industrial Hotspots Overlap with Human Habitation: Areas that once supported high herbivore biomass are now heavily populated, posing challenges for conservation and rewilding efforts.

Key Results

  • Potential Pre-industrial Biomass: Natural ecosystems could have supported approximately 330 Mt (wet weight) of wild herbivore biomass. This comprised 193 Mt from large herbivores and 138 Mt from small herbivores.
  • Present-Day Biomass and Losses: Current herbivore biomass is estimated at 82 Mt for large herbivores (a 57% reduction) and 98 Mt for small herbivores (a 29% reduction). This means small herbivores now dominate global herbivore biomass.
  • Environmental Drivers: Actual evapotranspiration explained 64% of the variation in total herbivore biomass, 59% for large herbivores, and 49% for small herbivores.
  • Biomass Distribution: Modelled and observed data suggest a strong dependency on energy and water, with higher biomass in hot and wet areas, contradicting the idea that savannas are the primary peak biomass ecosystems.
  • Human-Dominated Areas: Pre-industrial biomass hotspots outside of Africa and the Tropics were found in areas now heavily impacted by human activities.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Spatial Resolution: The model's 2° resolution might be too coarse for highly heterogeneous landscapes or localized conservation efforts.
  • Model Coupling: REMAP and ORCHIDEE are not fully coupled, meaning feedback loops between animal consumption and plant responses are not entirely integrated.
  • Exclusion of Certain Factors: The model does not explicitly include non-consumptive predator effects, animal movement between grid cells, or the impact of hunting and poaching (though some effects might be indirectly captured by range loss).
  • Invasive Species and Livestock: These significant components of current herbivore biomass were not included in this study.

Future work could involve:

  • Developing finer-scale versions of the model for localized conservation.
  • Achieving full coupling between vegetation and herbivore models to capture complex feedbacks.
  • Integrating invasive species and livestock into the model.
  • Applying the HFT framework to extinct megafauna to understand their ecological roles and extinction drivers.
  • Using the model to predict the impact of climate change on herbivore populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Mammalian herbivores play a pivotal role in Earth System processes by affecting biogeochemical cycles and ecosystem functioning, potentially leading to significant repercussions on atmosphere–biosphere feedbacks. Global dynamic models of mammalian populations can improve our understanding of their ecological role at large scales and the consequences of their extinctions. However, such models are still lacking and mammals are poorly integrated in Earth System Science. We developed a mechanistic global model of terrestrial herbivore populations simulated with 37 functional groups defined through the analysis of eco‐physiological traits across all extant herbivores (2599 species). We coupled this model with a global vegetation model to predict herbivores' maximum potential biomass in pre‐industrial and at present‐day and to study the environmental drivers explaining the distribution of herbivore biomass. Present‐day biomass was estimated by accounting for anthropogenic activity causing habitat and range losses. We show that natural ecosystems could have sustained a potential wild herbivore wet biomass of 330 Mt (95% CI: 245–417), comprised of 193 Mt (95% CI: 177–208) by large species (body mass >1–10 kg, depending on functional group) and 138 Mt (95% CI: 68–209) by small species. We estimate that the remaining present‐day large herbivores biomass is 82 Mt (95% CI: 32–133), reduced by 57% due to anthropogenic activity; consequently, small herbivores currently dominate global herbivore biomass with 98 Mt (95% CI: 91–106, −29%). Losses vary greatly across climatic zones and functional groups, suggesting that size is not the only discriminant feature of biomass decline. Actual evapotranspiration is the most important driver of total, large and small herbivore biomass and explains 64%, 59% and 49% of its variation, respectively. Distribution of modelled and observed large herbivores' biomass suggested a high dependency on energy and water with more biomass in hot and wet areas. These results challenge the notion that large herbivore biomass peaks primarily in ecosystems with intermediate precipitation levels such as savannas. Outside Africa and the Tropics, pre‐industrial biomass hotspots occur in areas today dominated by humans; this could undermine the recovery of larger species biomass in certain areas. Our herbivore biomass estimates provide a quantitative benchmark for setting conservation and rewilding goals at large spatial scales. The herbivore model and functional classification create new opportunities to integrate mammals into Earth System Science and models. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{berzaghi2024traitbased,
  author = {Fabio Berzaghi and Dan Zhu and John Alroy and Philippe Ciais},
  title = {{Trait‐based mechanistic approach highlights global patterns and losses of herbivore biomass functional diversity}},
  booktitle = {Functional},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1111/1365-2435.14512},
}
Figure