Trait-based mechanistic approach highlights global patterns and losses of herbivore biomass functional diversity

Fabio Berzaghi, Dan Zhu, John Alroy, Philippe CiaisbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel global mechanistic model (REMAP) that simulates herbivore populations based on their functional traits, providing unprecedented insights into their ecological roles and biomass distribution. The study reveals significant declines in large herbivore biomass due to human activity, leading to small herbivores now dominating global biomass, and highlights evapotranspiration as a key driver of herbivore distribution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the ecological impact of mammalian herbivores on Earth's systems is crucial, but global dynamic models of these populations have been lacking. This gap limits our ability to assess their role in processes like carbon cycling and nutrient turnover, and to predict the consequences of their decline or extinction. Specifically, previous research has often focused on species richness or abundance, neglecting the critical aspect of functional biomass – the biomass of animals categorized by their ecological roles. This study aims to fill this gap by developing a comprehensive global model that accounts for the functional diversity of herbivores.

Methods

The core of this research is the development of a new Herbivore Functional Type (HFT) classification system. This system groups the 2599 extant terrestrial mammalian herbivores into 37 distinct functional groups based on four key eco-physiological traits:

  • Diet type: Percentage of leaves, fruit, and seeds consumed.
  • Adult body mass: Categorized into micro, small, and large.
  • Digestive system: Hindgut or foregut fermenters.
  • Folivory type: Grazer, browser, or mixed-feeder (for leaf-eaters).

This HFT classification was then integrated into a mechanistic model called REMAP (REproduce MAmmal Populations). REMAP simulates the carrying capacity of these HFTs by considering reproduction, metabolism, growth, mortality, and competition for food. It's coupled with the ORCHIDEE global vegetation model to provide daily plant biomass availability. The model was used to simulate two scenarios:

  1. Pre-industrial potential maximum biomass: Under natural conditions with no habitat loss or hunting.
  2. Present-day biomass: Accounting for current range and habitat loss.

The model's outputs were validated against empirical data.

Datasets

The study utilized several existing datasets for trait data and empirical biomass estimates:

  • Trait Data: Phylacine, Mammal Diet 2, Elton Traits, and PanTHERIA were used to gather life-history traits for terrestrial mammalian herbivores.
  • Empirical Mammal Population Density & Biomass: Data were compiled from Hatton et al. (2015) and Santini, Isaac, & Ficetola (2018), supplemented with literature records. This dataset included information for 440 species.
  • Climate Data: TerraClimate and WorldClim 2.1 provided yearly averages of plant evapotranspiration, precipitation, temperature, and precipitation seasonality.
  • Habitat Data: A global map of terrestrial habitats from Jung et al. (2020) was used to estimate habitat loss.
  • Species Distribution Maps: Phylacine database and IUCN maps were used to define "present natural" and "current" distribution ranges.

The study did not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather synthesized and analyzed existing data within a novel modeling framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Small Herbivores Now Dominate: Human activity has drastically reduced large herbivore biomass, leading to small herbivores now comprising the majority of global herbivore biomass. This shifts our understanding of ecosystem dynamics, as smaller animals play a more significant role than previously appreciated.
  • Evapotranspiration is King: Actual evapotranspiration emerged as the most significant driver of herbivore biomass distribution, explaining a substantial portion of the variation for total, large, and small herbivores. This highlights the critical link between water availability and herbivore populations.
  • Large Herbivore Hotspots Challenged: The study challenges the long-held notion that large herbivore biomass peaks solely in savannas. Instead, it finds that large herbivores are more abundant in hot and wet areas, suggesting a broader range of suitable habitats.
  • Human-Dominated Areas as Potential Hotspots: Outside of Africa and the Tropics, areas with high human density are identified as potential hotspots for large herbivore biomass. This presents a complex challenge for conservation and rewilding efforts, as these areas are already heavily utilized by humans.
  • Functional Diversity Matters: The research emphasizes that size is not the sole determinant of biomass decline; losses vary significantly across different functional groups, underscoring the importance of considering diverse ecological roles.

Key Results

  • Potential Biomass: Natural ecosystems could have supported approximately 330 Mt of wild herbivore wet biomass (192 Mt large, 138 Mt small).
  • Current Biomass: Anthropogenic activity has reduced large herbivore biomass by 57% to an estimated 82 Mt. Small herbivores now account for 98 Mt, a 29% decrease.
  • Biomass Loss: Overall, there's a potential loss of about 110 Mt of large herbivore biomass and 40 Mt of small herbivore biomass due to range reduction and habitat loss.
  • Climate Drivers: Evapotranspiration explained 64% of total herbivore biomass variation, with precipitation and temperature also being significant drivers for large herbivores.
  • Spatial Patterns: Biomass distribution varies significantly across climate zones, with notable differences between polar, temperate, and tropical regions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Spatial Resolution: The authors acknowledge that the broad spatial resolution of the model (2°) and some input limitations might lead to underestimation in highly heterogeneous landscapes like deserts or transition zones. Finer-scale inputs are suggested for improved accuracy in such areas.
  • Model Coupling: While REMAP is updated daily with plant biomass from ORCHIDEE, it's not fully coupled. Future work could involve a fully-coupled simulation to capture more complex feedbacks between animals and plants, such as how herbivore consumption affects water use, carbon allocation, and nutrient cycling.
  • Predator Effects: Predators are not explicitly modeled, though their impact on herbivore mortality is indirectly captured through carrying capacity parameters. Non-consumptive predator effects (e.g., landscape of fear) are not included.
  • Invasive Species and Livestock: The current model does not include invasive species or livestock, which represent a significant portion of global herbivore biomass. Future integration of these groups is envisioned.
  • Data Gaps: Despite efforts to compile data, gaps remain, particularly for small and micro mammals, and in certain geographic regions.

The authors suggest that their HFT framework and REMAP model provide a strong foundation for future research, including investigating the impacts of climate change on herbivore populations, integrating with other Earth System models to assess biosphere-atmosphere feedbacks, and informing conservation and rewilding strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Mammalian herbivores strongly shape Earth system processes. A lack of global dynamic models of mammal populations limits our understanding of their ecological role at large scales and the consequences of their extinctions. We developed a mechanistic global model of terrestrial herbivore populations simulated with 37 functional groups defined by analyzing eco-physiological traits of all extant herbivores (n = 2599). We coupled this model with a global vegetation model to predict herbivores’ biomass maximum potential (pre-industrial) and at present. Natural ecosystems could have sustained a wild herbivore wet biomass of 330 Mt, comprised of 192 Mt by large (body mass > 5 kg) and 138 Mt by small species. Anthropogenic activity reduced large herbivores biomass by 57%, estimated now at 82 Mt; consequently, small herbivores now dominate global herbivore biomass with 98 Mt (-29%). Losses vary greatly across climatic zones and functional groups, suggesting that size is not the only discriminant feature of biomass decline. Actual evapotranspiration is the most important driver of total, large, and small herbivore biomass and explains 64%, 59%, and 49% of its variation, respectively. Energy and water dependency is high for large herbivores, whose biomass is greater in hot and wet areas, challenging the notion that large herbivore biomass peaks in savannas only. Outside Africa and the Tropics, potential-biomass hotspots occur in areas today dominated by humans; this could undermine the recovery of larger species in certain areas. These herbivore biomass estimates provide a quantitative benchmark for setting conservation and rewilding goals at large spatial scales. The herbivore model and functional classification create new opportunities to integrate mammals into Earth System science and models.
BibTeX
@misc{berzaghi2021trait,
  author = {Fabio Berzaghi and Dan Zhu and John Alroy and Philippe Ciais},
  title = {{Trait-based mechanistic approach highlights global patterns and losses of herbivore biomass functional diversity}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.10.19.464976},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure