Train Window of Container: Visual and Auditory Representation of Train Movement

Kunihiro Nishimura, Yasuhiro Suzuki, Munehiko Sato, Oribe Hayashi, Liwei Yang, Kentaro Kimura, Shinya Nishizaka, Yusuke Onojima, Yuki Ban, Yuma Muroya, Shigeo Yoshida, Michitaka HiroseAdvances in Computer Entertainment 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "Train Window of Container," an immersive art installation that uses a shipping container to simulate the experience of riding a train. By employing synchronized visual displays and auditory cues, the project successfully extracts the "essence of a train ride" and provides an engaging, cost-effective alternative to traditional train simulators.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors aim to capture the sensory experience of being on a train, specifically the feeling of movement and the changing landscapes viewed from the windows. Traditional train simulators can be expensive and complex. This paper explores a more accessible approach by leveraging a common object – a shipping container – and transforming it into an immersive experience. The core challenge is to evoke the sensation of train travel using only visual and auditory stimuli, without actual physical movement.

Methods

The "Train Window of Container" system is built within a standard shipping container. The key methodological innovations include:

  • Visual Immersion: Ten displays are strategically placed on the container walls to act as "train windows." These displays show pre-recorded videos of landscapes taken from actual train journeys. A crucial technique is the use of time-delayed playback across these displays, creating a seamless, flowing panorama that simulates the sensation of movement.
  • Auditory Immersion: Ten speakers are installed to provide synchronized train sounds, further enhancing the feeling of being on a moving train.
  • Environmental Design: The interior of the container is kept dark to minimize distractions and maximize the impact of the visual and auditory stimuli.
  • Perspective Design: To counteract the inherent shortness of a container compared to a real train car, a subtle perspective design is implemented. The entrance is made wider and taller than the rear, creating an illusion of greater depth and length.
  • Content Creation: Videos were captured from real train windows, as well as from other modes of transport like ferries and escalators, to offer diverse visual experiences.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The "datasets" used were custom-recorded video footage from various real-world journeys (trains, ferries, etc.) and synchronized audio.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Essence of a Train Ride": The project successfully demonstrates that the core feeling of a train ride can be evoked through carefully curated visual and auditory stimuli, even without physical motion.
  • Time-Delayed Displays for Motion: The simple yet effective method of playing videos with a time delay across multiple displays is key to creating a convincing sense of forward motion.
  • Darkness Enhances Immersion: A dark interior significantly amplifies the impact of the visual and auditory elements, making the simulated environment more believable.
  • Perspective Design's Subtle Impact: The perspective design, while not overtly noticeable, contributed to the feeling of increased length, suggesting that subtle architectural cues can influence spatial perception.
  • Cost-Effective Simulation: The use of a shipping container and readily available display technology offers a practical and budget-friendly alternative to high-end simulators.

Key Results

The exhibition of "Train Window of Container" at Tokyo Designers Week 2010 attracted approximately 13,000 audiences over five days. Questionnaire results indicated:

  • High Agreement on "Train Feeling": A significant majority of respondents (Q1) felt as if they were on a train.
  • Mixed Results on Movement: While the visual and auditory cues were effective, the physical sensation of movement (Q2, Q6) was harder to convey, with results being "a little hard" or "not so obvious."
  • Successful Perspective Illusion: Most audiences did not consciously notice the perspective design (Q8), but many reported the container felt longer than expected (Q3).
  • Enjoyable Landscapes: Audiences thoroughly enjoyed the landscapes viewed from the "windows" (Q4) and found them to be presented in a continuous series (Q5).
  • No Motion Sickness: Notably, despite the visual stimulation, audiences did not report feeling sick (Q7).
  • Positive Qualitative Feedback: Audiences described the experience as "interesting," "enjoyed," and providing "extraordinary experiences," with some noting the sound effectively conveyed vibration.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Physical Movement: The primary limitation acknowledged is the inability to fully replicate the physical sensation of movement, which was reflected in the questionnaire responses.
  • Subtlety of Perspective: While the perspective design was effective in not being noticed, its impact on perceived length was "small" according to questionnaire results.

Future Work:

  • Further Survey of "Essence": The authors plan to conduct further research into the "essence" of train rides and other experiences, potentially leading to more nuanced simulations.
  • Application in Museums: The team sees potential in applying this simple, effective method to museums that may lack the budget for complex simulators, offering an accessible way to create experience-based exhibits.
  • Deformation of Simulators: The concept of "deformation of simulator" suggests exploring variations and extensions of this approach.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{nishimura2012train,
  author = {Kunihiro Nishimura and Yasuhiro Suzuki and Munehiko Sato and Oribe Hayashi and Liwei Yang and Kentaro Kimura and Shinya Nishizaka and Yusuke Onojima and Yuki Ban and Yuma Muroya and Shigeo Yoshida and Michitaka Hirose},
  title = {{Train Window of Container: Visual and Auditory Representation of Train Movement}},
  booktitle = {Advances in Computer Entertainment},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-34292-9\_22},
}
Figure