Trade-Offs between Economic and Environmental Optimization of the Forest Biomass Generation Supply Chain in Inner Mongolia, China

Min Zhang, Guangyu Wang, Yi Gao, Zhenqi Wang, Feng MiSustainability 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a multi-objective linear programming model to optimize the forest biomass supply chain in Inner Mongolia, China, aiming to balance economic costs and CO2 emissions. The study reveals that optimizing the supply chain can significantly reduce both costs and emissions, with transportation and chipping being critical nodes for improvement.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global push for renewable energy sources, particularly biomass, aims to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions and address energy shortages. In China, forest biomass, especially residues like sandy shrub stubble, holds significant potential. However, the economic viability and environmental benefits of utilizing these residues are often questioned due to high costs and CO2 emissions throughout the supply chain. This paper tackles this challenge by investigating the trade-offs between economic and environmental factors in the forest biomass power generation supply chain, specifically focusing on the Mao Wu Su biomass thermoelectric company in Inner Mongolia. The goal is to find an optimal balance that maximizes benefits for both the company and the environment.

Methods

The core methodology employed is a multi-objective linear programming (MLP) model. This approach allows for the simultaneous optimization of multiple, potentially conflicting, objectives – in this case, minimizing supply cost and minimizing CO2 emissions. The model considers various nodes within the supply chain, including planting, harvesting, skidding, storage, chipping, and transportation, for three key raw materials: sandy shrub stubble residue, wood-chipping residue, and waste-wood products.

To further understand the robustness of the optimal solution, a sensitivity analysis was conducted. This analysis specifically examined the impact of variations in key parameters, namely the farmer's average transportation distance and the unit chipping cost, on the overall supply cost and CO2 emissions.

Datasets

The data for this study was gathered from two primary sources:

  • Statistical data: This included information from the China Statistical Yearbook 2016, China Energy Statistical Yearbook 2014, and the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region Forestry Department website.
  • Field investigation: This involved interviews and questionnaires conducted with forest biomass power generation enterprises, middlemen, and farmers in the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather utilizes existing statistical data and primary data collected through direct investigation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Transportation and chipping are major bottlenecks: The study highlights that transportation and chipping nodes significantly impact both the total cost and CO2 emissions of the supply chain. Optimizing these stages offers the greatest potential for improvement.
  • Sandy shrub residue is key, but needs optimization: While sandy shrub stubble residue is the primary raw material, its collection, chipping, and transportation present challenges due to its dispersed nature and low density. The study suggests strategies to improve its utilization.
  • Trade-offs are manageable: The MLP model demonstrates that it's possible to achieve reductions in both cost and CO2 emissions simultaneously, suggesting that economic and environmental goals are not mutually exclusive in this context.
  • Farmer engagement is crucial: The sensitivity analysis underscores the importance of farmer-level decisions, particularly transportation distance and the adoption of efficient chipping methods, in influencing the overall supply chain performance.

Key Results

The optimization of the supply chain for the Mao Wu Su biomass thermoelectric company yielded several significant results:

  • Cost Reduction: The total supply cost was reduced by **US$98.4 thousand** compared to the current situation, reaching $7451 thousand.
  • CO2 Emission Reduction: Total CO2 emissions decreased by 60.6 thousand kg, reaching 5683.8 thousand kg.
  • Material Flow Optimization:
    • Waste-wood products were reduced by 3750 thousand kg.
  • Sandy shrub stubble residue was increased by 3750 thousand kg.
  • Wood-chipping residue supply remained unchanged.
  • Transportation Strategy: 64% of chipped sandy shrub residue was optimized to be transported directly from the forestland to the power plant, while 36% of non-chipped residue was routed via a chipping plant.
  • Sensitivity Analysis Findings:
    • An optimal farmer's transportation distance of 84.13 km was identified.
  • An optimal unit chipping cost of $0.01022 thousand was determined.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Limited Sensitivity Analysis: The sensitivity analysis focused primarily on transportation distance and unit chipping cost. Future work could explore the impact of other parameters, such as demand variations, product prices, and raw material availability, on the optimal solution.
  • Assumptions: The model relies on certain assumptions, such as a definite demand for raw materials and steady labor salaries. Relaxing these assumptions could lead to more nuanced results.
  • Additional Factors: Future research could incorporate the addition of labor employment figures and the number of chipping plants (middlemen) into the study. Analyzing the impact of subsidies and their role in supporting the forest biomass power generation industry is also suggested.
  • Broader Scope: The study's findings are specific to the Mao Wu Su company. Expanding the analysis to other companies with similar supply chains would enhance the generalizability of the results.

Summary updated

Abstract

The utilization of forest residue to produce forest biomass energy can mitigate CO2 emissions and generate additional revenue for related eco-enterprises and farmers. In China, however, the benefit of this utilization is still in question because of high costs and CO2 emissions in the entire supply chain. In this paper, a multi-objective linear programming model (MLP) is employed to analyze the trade-offs between the economic and environmental benefits of all nodes within the forest biomass power generation supply chain. The MLP model is tested in the Mao Wu Su biomass Thermoelectric Company. The optimization results show that (1) the total cost and CO2 emissions are decreased by US$98.4 thousand and 60.6 thousand kg, respectively; 3750 thousand kg of waste-wood products is reduced and 3750 thousand kg of sandy shrub stubble residue is increased; (2) 64% of chipped sandy shrub residue is transported directly from the forestland to the power plant, 36% of non-chipped sandy shrub residue is transported from the forestland to the power plant via the chipping plant; (3) transportation and chipping play a significant role in the supply chain; and (4) the results of a sensitivity analysis show that the farmer’s average transportation distance should be 84.13 km and unit chipping cost should be $0.01022 thousand for the optimization supply cost and CO2 emissions. Finally, we suggest the following: (1) develop long-term cooperation with farmers; (2) buy chain-saws for regularly used farmers; (3) build several chipping plants in areas that are rich in sandy shrub.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2017trade,
  author = {Min Zhang and Guangyu Wang and Yi Gao and Zhenqi Wang and Feng Mi},
  title = {{Trade-Offs between Economic and Environmental Optimization of the Forest Biomass Generation Supply Chain in Inner Mongolia, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/su9112030},
}
Figure