Tracking Dabbing Using Search Query Surveillance: A Case Study in the United States

Zhu Zhang, Xiaolong Zheng, Daniel Zeng, Scott J. LeischowJournal of Medical Internet Research 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages Google search data to track the growing public interest in "dabbing," a method of marijuana ingestion. It reveals a strong correlation between dabbing searches and those for electronic nicotine delivery systems (ENDS), suggesting a potential link in user behavior or technology. The research highlights that dabbing interest is highest in US states with legalized recreational and medical marijuana, offering a novel surveillance method for public health.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dabbing, an increasingly popular method of consuming marijuana concentrates, has historically lacked robust surveillance data. Traditional methods are insufficient to capture the nuances of this emerging trend. This paper addresses the challenge of understanding the scope, breadth, and geographical distribution of public interest in dabbing, especially in relation to the evolving legal landscape of marijuana in the United States. It also investigates the potential association between dabbing and the use of electronic nicotine delivery systems (ENDS), a related area with its own public health implications.

Methods

The researchers employed Google Trends data to analyze search query patterns. They collected data for terms related to dabbing (e.g., "dab rig," "dab," "hash oil") and ENDS (e.g., "vaping," "e-cigarette") from January 2004 to December 2015. To assess temporal trends, they used relative search volume (RSV) and compared search patterns across different categories and time periods. For spatial analysis, they examined raw search data for dabbing in 2015 across US states. Statistical methods, including Pearson correlation coefficients (PCC), were used to quantify the association between dabbing and ENDS search terms. One-way ANOVA was employed to compare dabbing search volumes across states with varying marijuana legalization policies.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is Google Trends data for search queries related to dabbing and ENDS in the United States from January 2004 to December 2015. The study also utilized Google AdWords data to estimate raw search volume for "dabbing" in 2015. The raw search data for dabbing across all 50 US states and the District of Columbia for 2015 was also collected and analyzed. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing Google Trends data was leveraged for a novel application.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dabbing's Rise: Public interest in dabbing has significantly increased over time, surpassing traditional cannabis smoking and edibles in search volume by mid-2013.
  • ENDS Connection: There's a remarkably strong temporal correlation between searches for dabbing and ENDS (vaping/e-cigarettes). This suggests a potential overlap in user behavior, technology adoption, or information-seeking patterns.
  • Legalization's Influence: Dabbing interest is demonstrably higher in US states that have legalized both medical and recreational marijuana, indicating a link between legal access and public curiosity.
  • Geographic Hotspots: Dabbing searches are more concentrated in western US states, potentially influenced by earlier adoption of medical marijuana laws and subsequent recreational legalization.
  • Surveillance Potential: Google search data offers a valuable, novel, and timely method for public health surveillance of emerging substance use trends, complementing traditional but often lagging data sources.

Key Results

  • Estimated dabbing searches in the US reached 1,526,280 in 2015, with a predicted 22% increase for 2016.
  • Dabbing searches surpassed cannabis smoking and edibles searches by 28% and 58% respectively in 2015.
  • The Pearson correlation coefficient (PCC) between "dab" and "vaping" searches was .992 (P<.001), and between "hash oil" and "e-cigarette" searches was .931 (P<.001).
  • States with recreational and medical marijuana legalization showed significantly higher average dabbing searches compared to states with only medical legalization (P=.02) or no legalization (P=.01).
  • The top 12 states with the highest search volume included states like Colorado, Washington, and Oregon, which have legalized recreational marijuana.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Adjusted Relative Search Volume: Google Trends provides relative, not absolute, search volumes, and extremely low search volumes are normalized to zero, potentially obscuring niche trends.
  • Demographic Data: Google Trends data lacks demographic information, making it difficult to profile the users behind the searches.
  • Search Engine Dominance: While Google has a large market share, its data doesn't represent all internet searches.
  • Geographic and Language Bias: The study is limited to the United States and English search terms, restricting generalizability.
  • Search Term Specificity: Minor biases could arise from keyword selection, though efforts were made to use comprehensive terms.
  • Correlation vs. Causation: The study demonstrates high correlations between dabbing and ENDS searches but cannot definitively establish causation. Future research is needed to explore the reasons behind these associations.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Spatiotemporal Analysis: Further research is needed to characterize associations between dabbing and other factors, potentially using more advanced spatio-temporal models.
  • Integration with Other Data: Combining web search data with other sources like web-based surveys and community-recruited samples could provide a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Understanding ENDS-Dabbing Link: Investigating the reasons for the strong correlation between dabbing and ENDS searches is crucial, potentially exploring shared technologies or user demographics.
  • Real-World Use Patterns: Future research should aim to link search trends with actual product use patterns and adverse event reporting to assess the public health value of this surveillance method.

Summary updated

Abstract

Public interest in dabbing is increasing in the United States. There are close associations between dabbing and ENDS searches. The findings suggest greater popularity of dabs in the states that legalized medical and recreational marijuana use. This study proposes a novel and timely way of cannabis surveillance, and these findings can help enhance the understanding of the popularity of dabbing and provide insights for future research and informed policy making on dabbing.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2016tracking,
  author = {Zhu Zhang and Xiaolong Zheng and Daniel Zeng and Scott J. Leischow},
  title = {{Tracking Dabbing Using Search Query Surveillance: A Case Study in the United States}},
  journal = {Journal of Medical Internet Research},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.2196/jmir.5802},
}
Figure