Tracing the origins of stratospheric ozone intrusions: direct vs. indirect pathways and their impacts on Central and Eastern China in spring–summer 2019

Kai Meng, Tianliang Zhao, Yongqing Bai, Ming C. Wu, Le Cao, Xuewei Hou, Yuehan Luo, Yongcheng JiangAtmospheric 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces a novel high-resolution method to pinpoint the origins of stratospheric ozone intrusions (SIs) impacting Central and Eastern China. It reveals that indirect intrusions are more significant for monthly ozone pollution, while direct intrusions are more impactful on a daily basis, particularly in May. Understanding these pathways is crucial for improving ozone pollution forecasts and mitigation strategies in the region.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ozone is a critical air pollutant with significant impacts on human health and ecosystems, and unlike other regulated pollutants, its background concentrations are influenced by stratospheric intrusions (SIs). Central and Eastern China (CEC) faces severe ozone pollution, and the precise contribution of SIs to this problem, especially distinguishing between direct and indirect pathways, remains uncertain. Previous research often focused on specific regions or single intrusion types, lacking a systematic, high-resolution analysis of SI origins and their varying impacts across different sub-regions of CEC. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a detailed traceability assessment of SIs, identifying their critical source areas (CSAs), and quantifying their influence on tropospheric and near-surface ozone.

Methods

The authors developed a "traceability assessment method" that combines several key components:

  • Ambient Air Quality Observations: Ground-based surface ozone data from China.
  • Global Ozone (Re)analysis Data: ERA-Interim reanalysis data for meteorological fields and stratospheric ozone tracers (O3S) from EAC4 and CAM-Chem models.
  • Customized Lagrangian Simulations: The FLEXPART model was used to simulate the transport of stratospheric ozone tracers. This involved releasing over 500,000 air particles from the stratosphere and tracking their trajectories for 15 days.
  • Critical Source Area (CSA) Identification: A novel approach was used to identify CSAs, defined as regions where stratospheric air mass crosses the tropopause into the troposphere. This involved analyzing particle trajectories and using potential vorticity (PV) thresholds to distinguish stratospheric air.
  • CSA Impact Index (CSAII): This index was developed to quantify the geographical spread and impact of CSAs on ozone levels in the middle and lower troposphere.

The study also involved validating their simulation methodology by comparing simulated SI ozone with stratospheric ozone tracers from reanalysis datasets and satellite observations, as well as comparing simulated SI events with ground-based measurements.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • ERA-Interim Reanalysis Data: Meteorological fields (geopotential height, potential vorticity, wind) at 0.75° resolution.
  • EAC4-CAMS and CAM-Chem Global Atmospheric Chemistry Models: Stratospheric ozone tracer (O3S) products.
  • Aura Ozone Monitoring Instrument (OMI) Level-2 Ozone Profile Data (OMO3PR): For satellite-based ozone profile information.
  • Trajectory-mapped Ozonesonde Dataset for the Stratosphere and Troposphere (TOST): For background stratospheric ozone concentrations.
  • Operational Surface Ozone Observations: From the Ministry of Ecology and Environment of China.
  • Global Forecast System (GFS) Data: Provided by the U.S. National Weather Service for meteorological fields driving the FLEXPART model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Indirect Intrusions Dominate Monthly Ozone: Indirect stratospheric intrusions, characterized by longer transport pathways (around 10 days), are found to be more efficient in contributing to tropospheric ozone on a monthly scale, with impacts up to twice that of direct intrusions.
  • Direct Intrusions Matter Daily: Direct stratospheric intrusions, occurring within approximately 2 days, have a more pronounced impact on daily ozone levels, particularly in May.
  • Eastern Plains are Ozone Hotspots: The eastern plains of China (e.g., North China and East China) experience the most substantial impact of SIs on near-surface ozone, with contributions as high as 15.8% and 16.7% respectively. This highlights their vulnerability to descending stratospheric air.
  • High-Altitude Regions Receive More Ozone, But Less Near-Surface Impact: Regions like the Loess Plateau and Central China, despite receiving more stratospheric ozone into the troposphere, show minimal contributions to near-surface ozone. This suggests that atmospheric boundary layer dynamics play a crucial role in determining the final surface ozone levels.
  • Distinct Source Areas for Direct vs. Indirect Intrusions: Indirect intrusions originate from distant CSAs (thousands of kilometers away) linked to synoptic-scale Rossby waves or subtropical jets (e.g., Western Siberia, Europe, North Africa). Direct intrusions, however, come from more concentrated, closer sources (e.g., Tibetan Plateau for middle troposphere, Mongolia/Central Russia for lower troposphere).
  • Northeast Cold Vortex (NECV) as a DSI Driver: The study highlights the Northeast Cold Vortex (NECV) as a significant driver for direct stratospheric intrusions, creating a pathway for ozone transport into the lower troposphere and boundary layer.

Key Results

  • Indirect vs. Direct Impact: Indirect intrusions contribute up to twice the tropospheric ozone compared to direct intrusions on monthly scales. Direct intrusions are more significant on daily scales, especially in May.
  • Near-Surface Ozone Contributions: In North China and East China, SIs contribute 15.8% and 16.7% to near-surface ozone, respectively.
  • CSA Locations: Indirect intrusions originate from CSAs located between 40-70° N, spaced about 70° longitude apart. Direct intrusions originate from more concentrated areas, with middle troposphere sources from the Tibetan Plateau and lower troposphere sources from Mongolia and central Russia.
  • Model Validation: The study demonstrated strong correlations (R > 0.7) between simulated SI ozone and stratospheric ozone tracers from reanalysis datasets, and reasonable agreement between simulated and measured SI events, with hit rates generally above 50% (except for SC).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Limitations: The authors acknowledge that the FLEXPART model used does not account for tropospheric chemistry, which could influence ozone concentrations. They also note that Lagrangian approaches, while promising, have inherent uncertainties.
  • Data Resolution: While the study aimed for high-resolution CSAs, the authors suggest that further research using even higher-resolution models and coordinated measurements (surface, remote sensing, aircraft) is needed for a comprehensive understanding of SI variations and their global hotspots.
  • Future Research: The authors are conducting SI ozonesonde experiments in the summer of 2024 to further validate their simulation and computation methods. They emphasize the need for continued research to understand the underlying physical mechanisms influencing SI contributions to ground-level ozone and to improve forecasting and mitigation strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The impact of stratospheric intrusions (SIs) on Central and Eastern China (CEC) with severe ozone pollution presents a range of uncertainties, underscoring the imperative for sustained research endeavors. In this study, we propose a traceability assessment method that can derive high-resolution critical source areas (CSAs) of SIs by utilizing ambient air quality observations, global ozone (re)analysis data, and customized Lagrangian simulations. This approach enables us to facilitate a meticulous and systematic examination of the impact of direct and indirect SIs on tropospheric and near-surface ozone in six important sub-regions within the CEC during the spring and summer of 2019, as well as the unique circulations driving SIs, from a more refined and targeted tracing perspective. The findings reveal that impacts of indirect intrusions are more efficient at monthly scales, with contributions to tropospheric ozone reaching up to twice the magnitude of direct intrusions. The impacts of direct intrusions are more pronounced at daily scales, primarily occurring in May. In terms of contribution to near-surface ozone, the eastern plains frequently witness ozone exceedance events, with the most substantial impact from SIs observed (e.g., contributing 15.8 % and 16.7 % to near-surface ozone in North China and East China, respectively), showcasing a remarkable ability to capture descending lower-stratospheric air. In contrast, the Loess Plateau and Central China, situated in central and western high-altitude regions, receive more intrusive ozone into the troposphere but exhibit minimal contributions to near-surface ozone. The indirect intrusions that generate the above impact come from three to four CSAs located thousands of kilometers away, evenly distributed latitudinally within the westerlies between 40 and 70° N (spaced 70 longitudes apart). These CSAs are intricately linked to the evolution of synoptic-scale Rossby waves or subtropical westerly jets, with western Siberia or Europe and north Africa identified as the most significant CSAs. Conversely, the CSAs for direct intrusions are relatively concentrated, with those influencing the middle troposphere originating from the Tibetan Plateau and those influencing the lower troposphere predominantly located in Mongolia and central Russia, just a few hundred kilometers from the CEC. These sources are associated with typical atmospheric circulations such as the northeast cold vortex and the South Asian High, where the intensity of the intrusion system plays a more crucial role than its frequency of occurrence. This study provides valuable insights for forecasting and mitigating the impact of SIs on ozone pollution in China and contributes to addressing the broader challenges posed by climate change.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{meng2024tracing,
  author = {Kai Meng and Tianliang Zhao and Yongqing Bai and Ming C. Wu and Le Cao and Xuewei Hou and Yuehan Luo and Yongcheng Jiang},
  title = {{Tracing the origins of stratospheric ozone intrusions: direct vs. indirect pathways and their impacts on Central and Eastern China in spring–summer 2019}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-24-12623-2024},
}
Figure