Tracing HIV-1 transmission: envelope traits of HIV-1 transmitter and recipient pairs

The Swiss Hiv Cohort Study (shcs), Corinna Oberle, Béda Joos, Peter Rusert, Nottania K. Campbell, David Beauparlant, Herbert Kuster, Jacqueline Weber, Corinne D Schenkel, Alexandra Scherrer, Carsten Magnus, Roger D. Kouyos, Philip Rieder, Barbara Niederöst, Dominique L. Braun, Jovan Pavlovic, Jürg Böni, Sabine Yerly, Thomas Klimkait, Vincent Aubert, Alexandra Trkola, Karin J. Metzner, Huldrych F. GünthardRetrovirology 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated whether specific traits of the HIV-1 envelope (Env) drive transmission, leading to a single "transmitted/founder" (T/F) virus. By comparing viruses from nine transmission pairs, they found that T/F viruses generally did not possess distinct phenotypic advantages over their transmitter counterparts, suggesting that HIV-1 transmission, at least in subtype B, is largely a stochastic process.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When HIV-1 infects a new host, typically only one viral variant, the transmitted/founder (T/F) virus, establishes the infection, despite the high diversity of the virus in the infected individual. This raises a fundamental question: is this selection process driven by specific viral characteristics that allow certain variants to better navigate the transmission bottleneck, or is it simply a matter of chance? Previous research hinted that the HIV-1 envelope (Env) protein, crucial for viral entry, might play a role. However, a clear consensus was lacking, partly due to studies comparing T/F viruses to unrelated chronic infection viruses rather than directly to the transmitter's virus at the time of transmission. This paper aims to resolve this by directly comparing the phenotypic properties of transmitter and recipient viruses from well-defined transmission pairs.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Phylogenetic Analysis: They used polymerase (pol) and envelope (env) gene sequences from patients in two Swiss HIV cohorts (ZPHI and SHCS) to identify linked transmission pairs. This involved analyzing genetic distances to confirm relatedness.
  • Single Genome Amplification (SGA) and Sequencing: This technique allowed them to isolate and sequence individual viral genomes from plasma samples, crucial for identifying the T/F virus and characterizing its genetic makeup.
  • Env-Pseudovirus Assays: Env proteins from transmitter and recipient viruses were used to create pseudoviruses. These were then used to assess various phenotypic properties:
  • Entry Kinetics: How quickly the virus enters target cells.
  • Neutralization Sensitivity: Resistance to antibodies in transmitter plasma and a panel of neutralizing antibodies.
  • Entry Inhibitor Sensitivity: Resistance to various drugs that block viral entry.
  • Cell-Cell Transmission and Free Virus Infection: The virus's ability to infect cells through direct contact versus free virions.
  • Replicative Capacity: How well the virus replicates in primary cells (PBMCs and MDMs).
  • Interferon-α (IFNα) Sensitivity: Resistance to the antiviral effects of IFNα.

Datasets

The study utilized samples from two established HIV cohorts:

  • Zurich Primary HIV Infection (ZPHI) study: A prospective, observational, single-center cohort of patients with confirmed acute or recent primary HIV-1 infection.
  • Swiss HIV Cohort Study (SHCS): A nationwide, clinic-based cohort including all HIV-1 infected adults in Switzerland.

They analyzed pol sequences from over 23,705 patients and env sequences from nine confirmed transmission pairs (six men who have sex with men (MSM) and three male-to-female (MTF)).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Stochasticity" Hypothesis Gains Ground: The most striking finding is the lack of consistent phenotypic advantages in T/F viruses compared to their transmitter counterparts. This strongly supports the idea that HIV-1 transmission is often a game of chance, rather than a highly selective process driven by specific viral traits.
  • Env's Role is More Subtle Than Expected: While Env is critical for entry, this study suggests that specific modifications in Env (like loop length or glycosylation) are not the primary drivers of transmission success in subtype B.
  • Transmitter Plasma is Largely Ineffective: Transmitter plasma, even from close to the time of transmission, generally failed to neutralize the transmitted viruses, highlighting the rapid immune escape that occurs during transmission.
  • IFNα Sensitivity is an Exception: Interestingly, recipient viruses showed a higher sensitivity to IFNα, contradicting previous findings that suggested resistance to this antiviral might be a transmission advantage. This suggests IFNα resistance is unlikely to be a major factor in T/F establishment.

Key Results

  • Single T/F Virus: In all nine transmission pairs studied, recipients harbored a single T/F virus, confirmed by extensive sequencing.
  • No Env Modification Advantage: Recipient viruses showed no consistent differences in Env variable loop length or glycosylation compared to transmitter viruses.
  • Similar Entry and Replication: Transmitter and recipient viruses exhibited comparable entry kinetics, cell-cell transmission, free virus infection, and replicative capacity in primary cells.
  • No Consistent Neutralization Resistance: Recipient viruses were not consistently more resistant to neutralizing antibodies or entry inhibitors than transmitter viruses.
  • Increased IFNα Sensitivity in Recipients: Recipient viruses were, on average, more sensitive to IFNα than transmitter viruses, a finding that challenges previous hypotheses.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cohort Size: The study included nine transmission pairs, which, while well-characterized, is a relatively small number. The authors acknowledge that larger cohorts are needed to detect subtle selective forces.
  • Subtype B Focus: The findings are specific to HIV-1 subtype B. Future research should explore other subtypes and transmission modes to see if these patterns hold.
  • Focus on Env: While Env is crucial, other viral factors (e.g., reverse transcriptase, integrase) and host factors could also play a role in transmission, which were not the primary focus here.
  • Future Directions: The authors emphasize the need for larger, multi-center studies that cover diverse transmission settings to definitively unravel the complex interplay of viral properties, host factors, and transmission dynamics. They also suggest exploring the functional consequences of specific Env motifs, such as those involved in α4β7 integrin binding, which were not fully assessed in this study.

Summary updated

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Mucosal HIV-1 transmission predominantly results in a single transmitted/founder (T/F) virus establishing infection in the new host despite the generally high genetic diversity of the transmitter virus population. To what extent HIV-1 transmission is a stochastic process or driven by selective forces that allow T/F viruses best to overcome bottlenecks in transmission has not been conclusively resolved. Building on prior investigations that suggest HIV-1 envelope (Env) features to contribute in the selection process during transmission, we compared phenotypic virus characteristics of nine HIV-1 subtype B transmission pairs, six men who have sex with men and three male-to-female transmission pairs. RESULTS: All recipients were identified early in acute infection and harbored based on extensive sequencing analysis a single T/F virus allowing a controlled analysis of virus properties in matched transmission pairs. Recipient and transmitter viruses from the closest time point to transmission showed no signs of selection for specific Env modifications such as variable loop length and glycosylation. Recipient viruses were resistant to circulating plasma antibodies of the transmitter and also showed no altered sensitivity to a large panel of entry inhibitors and neutralizing antibodies. The recipient virus did not consistently differ from the transmitter virus in terms of entry kinetics, cell-cell transmission and replicative capacity in primary cells. Our paired analysis revealed a higher sensitivity of several recipient virus isolates to interferon-α (IFNα) which suggests that resistance to IFNα cannot be a general driving force in T/F establishment. CONCLUSIONS: With the exception of increased IFNα sensitivity, none of the phenotypic virus properties we investigated clearly distinguished T/F viruses from their matched transmitter viruses supporting the notion that at least in subtype B infection HIV-1 transmission is to a considerable extent stochastic.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shcs2016tracing,
  author = {The Swiss HIV Cohort Study (SHCS) and Corinna Oberle and Béda Joos and Peter Rusert and Nottania K. Campbell and David Beauparlant and Herbert Kuster and Jacqueline Weber and Corinne D Schenkel and Alexandra Scherrer and Carsten Magnus and Roger D. Kouyos and Philip Rieder and Barbara Niederöst and Dominique L. Braun and Jovan Pavlovic and Jürg Böni and Sabine Yerly and Thomas Klimkait and Vincent Aubert and Alexandra Trkola and Karin J. Metzner and Huldrych F. Günthard},
  title = {{Tracing HIV-1 transmission: envelope traits of HIV-1 transmitter and recipient pairs}},
  booktitle = {Retrovirology},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1186/s12977-016-0299-0},
}
Figure