Traceable Thickness Measurement of nm Oxide Films by Mutual Calibration

Kyung-Joong Kim, Ansoon Kim, Ji‐Hwan Kwon, Chang Soo Kim, Won Ja MinJournal of Surface Analysis 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Mutual calibration has been known to be a traceable method to determine the absolute thickness of nm oxide films. Recently, the thicknesses of a series of ultra-thin $HfO_2$ films were compared in a CCQM pilot study P-190 by 11 NMIs using various thickness measurement methods. The reference thicknesses of the films were precisely determined by mutual calibration by the average thickness of x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and x-ray reflectometry (XRR) data. The film thicknesses were also measured by medium energy ion scattering spectroscopy (MEIS). The film thicknesses measured by MEIS were linearly proportional to the reference thicknesses and the thickness difference was about 2%.

Introduction

In the semiconductor industry, as devices continue to shrink, oxide layers such as $SiO_2$ or $HfO_2$ are reaching thicknesses of only a few atoms. Measuring these ultra-thin films (under 5 nm) accurately is a significant metrological challenge. Most standard measurement tools suffer from either "offsets" or calibration errors at this scale.

Standard techniques like Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) or X-ray Reflectometry (XRR) are excellent at measuring relative lengths based on physical constants, but they often have a "zero-point" problem—reporting a non-zero thickness even when no film is present. Conversely, methods like X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) and Medium Energy Ion Scattering Spectroscopy (MEIS) are "offset-traceable," meaning they correctly show zero signal for zero thickness, but they require a reference to translate their signal into an absolute physical length (nanometers).

Methods: The Mutual Calibration Strategy

To address the need for traceable measurements, researchers utilize a strategy called Mutual Calibration. This involves plotting data from two different types of instruments against each other to cancel out systematic errors. By plotting the thickness from a length-unit traceable method (like TEM) against an offset-traceable method (like XPS), a linear fit $T_{TEM} = m T_{XPS} + c$ can be established. This allows for the determination of absolute thickness by correcting the TEM offset ($c$) and scaling the XPS signal by the slope ($m$).

Mutual calibration process showing the relationship between length-unit traceable methods (TEM) and offset-traceable methods (XPS).

Experimental Results and MEIS Analysis

The study utilized a series of ultra-thin $HfO_2$ films ranging from 0.76 nm to 3.36 nm in thickness, grown via Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) on $Si(100)$ substrates. These films were part of the CCQM pilot study (P-190), which involved 11 different National Metrology Institutes (NMIs) to ensure the reference thicknesses were certified and highly accurate.

Medium Energy Ion Scattering Spectroscopy (MEIS) was a primary focus of the characterization. MEIS works by bombarding a surface with ions and measuring the energy of the scattered ions; the energy loss corresponds to the depth the ion traveled, allowing for a direct calculation of the "amount of substance" (atoms per $cm^2$).

MEIS energy spectra for HfO2 films of varying thicknesses (0.76 nm to 3.36 nm), illustrating the increase in Hf peak intensity with film thickness.

Key Findings

The MEIS measurements demonstrated a high degree of precision and a near-perfect linear relationship with the certified reference thicknesses. Key results included:

  • High Accuracy: The thickness values measured by MEIS were within 2% of the certified reference values.
  • Linearity: The calibration featured a slope of 0.981 and a negligible offset of only 0.017 nm.
  • Traceability: The study successfully demonstrated that MEIS can act as a traceable method for determining the absolute thickness of nanometer-scale oxide films without relying on a single, potentially biased instrument.

Conclusion and Future Work

The mutual calibration approach proves that combining different physical measurement principles can eliminate the inherent biases of individual tools. While MEIS shows significant promise as a standalone traceable method, its accuracy currently depends on the precise calibration of "stopping power" (the rate of energy loss for ions in a material). Future research will focus on refining these simulation parameters and standardizing density characteristics across different high-k dielectric materials to further improve metrological certainty.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mutual calibration has been known to be a traceable method to determine the absolute thickness of nm oxide films Recently, the thicknesses of a serious of ultra-thin HfO2 films were compared in a CCQM pilot study P-190 by 11 NMIs using various thickness measurement methods. The reference thicknesses of the films were precisely determined by mutual calibration by the average thickness of x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and x-ray reflectometry (XRR) data. The film thicknesses were also measured by medium energy ion scattering spectroscopy (MEIS). The film thicknesses measured by MEIS were linearly proportional to the reference thicknesses and the thickness difference was about 2%.
BibTeX
@article{kim2019traceable,
  author = {Kyung-Joong Kim and Ansoon Kim and Ji‐Hwan Kwon and Chang Soo Kim and Won Ja Min},
  title = {{Traceable Thickness Measurement of nm Oxide Films by Mutual Calibration}},
  journal = {Journal of Surface Analysis},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1384/jsa.26.152},
}
Figure