Towards understanding edge localised mode mitigation by resonant magnetic perturbations in MAST

I.t. Chapman, A. Kirk, Christopher Ham, J. Harrison, Y. Q. Liu, S. Saarelma, R. Scannell, A. Thornton, M. Bécoulet, F. Orain, W.a. Cooper, S. Pamela, Mast TeamPhysics 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Type-I Edge Localised Modes (ELMs) have been mitigated in MAST through the application of n=3,4, and 6 resonant magnetic perturbations. For each toroidal mode number of the non-axisymmetric applied fields, the frequency of the ELMs has been increased significantly, and the peak heat flux on the divertor plates reduced commensurately. This increase in ELM frequency occurs despite a significant drop in the edge pressure gradient, which would be expected to stabilise the peeling-ballooning modes thought to be responsible for type-I ELMs. Various mechanisms which could cause a destabilisation of the peeling-ballooning modes are presented, including pedestal widening, plasma rotation braking, three dimensional corrugation of the plasma boundary, and the existence of radially extended lobe structures near to the X-point. This leads to a model aimed at resolving the apparent dichotomy of ELM control, which is to say ELM suppression occurring due to the pedestal pressure reduction below the peeling-ballooning stability boundary, whilst the reduction in pressure can also lead to ELM mitigation, which is ostensibly a destabilisation of peeling-ballooning modes. In the case of ELM mitigation, the pedestal broadening, 3d corrugation, or lobes near the X-point degrade ballooning stability so much that the pedestal recovers rapidly to cross the new stability boundary at lower pressure more frequently, whilst in the case of suppression, the plasma parameters are such that the particle transport reduces the edge pressure below the stability boundary, which is only mildly affected by negligible rotation braking, small edge corrugation or short, broad lobe structures.

Introduction

In the quest for sustainable fusion energy, managing the intense heat loads on reactor walls is a critical challenge. In tokamaks like MAST (Mega Amp Spherical Tokamak), the high-pressure "pedestal" at the plasma edge frequently collapses in explosive events known as Edge Localised Modes (ELMs). While these bursts help remove impurities, large "Type-I" ELMs in future devices like ITER could cause significant material damage. Resonant Magnetic Perturbations (RMPs) have emerged as a primary tool for ELM control, capable of either suppressing these events entirely or mitigating them by increasing their frequency and reducing their individual impact.

Experimental Observations in MAST

Recent experiments at the Culham Centre for Fusion Energy have demonstrated successful ELM mitigation using $n=3, 4,$ and $6$ RMP fields. As shown in Figure 1, the application of an $n=6$ field (shot 27205) results in a dramatic increase in ELM frequency compared to the unmitigated case (shot 27204). This mitigation is accompanied by a "density pump-out"—a characteristic reduction in line-averaged electron density—and a commensurate reduction in peak heat flux at the divertor.

Experimental time traces from MAST comparing an unmitigated discharge (27204, black) with an n=6 RMP-mitigated discharge (27205, red). Note the increased ELM frequency in (d) and density pump-out in (b).

The Stability Paradox

The central puzzle of ELM mitigation is that RMPs reduce the pedestal pressure gradient, which standard 2D peeling-ballooning theory suggests should make the plasma more stable. However, the observed increase in ELM frequency implies the plasma is reaching a stability limit more often.

Analysis of the pedestal structure (Figure 2) reveals that mitigated ELMs (red triangles) occur at lower pedestal pressures and significantly reduced pressure gradients compared to unmitigated ELMs (black circles). Furthermore, the pedestal width is often observed to increase during mitigation.

Pedestal characteristics for mitigated (red triangles) and unmitigated (black circles) discharges. Mitigation is associated with lower pedestal pressure (a), wider pedestals (b), and reduced pressure gradients (d).

Mechanisms of Destabilisation

To explain why the plasma becomes less stable despite lower drive, several 3D effects must be considered:

  1. Rotation Braking: RMPs exert a torque that slows plasma rotation. Reduced rotation shear weakens the stabilization of edge modes.
  2. 3D Corrugation: The RMP fields warp the plasma boundary. In specific toroidal locations, this "corrugation" can locally increase the growth rate of ballooning modes by a factor of two.
  3. X-point Lobes: Magnetic perturbations create radially extended "lobe" structures near the X-point. These lobes dwell in regions of unfavourable magnetic curvature, significantly degrading the ballooning stability limit.

A Unified Model for ELM Control

The authors propose a model where RMPs simultaneously reduce the pedestal drive and lower the stability boundary. Mitigation occurs when the boundary is lowered so much that the recovering pedestal intersects it prematurely, leading to frequent, small ELMs. Suppression is achieved when RMP-induced transport is strong enough to keep the pedestal pressure below the stability boundary entirely, even if that boundary is only slightly affected by 3D deformations or rotation braking.

Conclusion

Understanding the 3D nature of the plasma edge is essential for predicting RMP performance. By accounting for pedestal widening, rotation braking, and boundary deformation, this research provides a framework for optimizing ELM control strategies in next-generation fusion reactors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Type-I Edge Localised Modes (ELMs) have been mitigated in MAST through the application of n=3,4, and 6 resonant magnetic perturbations. For each toroidal mode number of the non-axisymmetric applied fields, the frequency of the ELMs has been increased significantly, and the peak heat flux on the divertor plates reduced commensurately. This increase in ELM frequency occurs despite a significant drop in the edge pressure gradient, which would be expected to stabilise the peeling-ballooning modes thought to be responsible for type-I ELMs. Various mechanisms which could cause a destabilisation of the peeling-ballooning modes are presented, including pedestal widening, plasma rotation braking, three dimensional corrugation of the plasma boundary, and the existence of radially extended lobe structures near to the X-point. This leads to a model aimed at resolving the apparent dichotomy of ELM control, which is to say ELM suppression occurring due to the pedestal pressure reduction below the peeling-ballooning stability boundary, whilst the reduction in pressure can also lead to ELM mitigation, which is ostensibly a destabilisation of peeling-ballooning modes. In the case of ELM mitigation, the pedestal broadening, 3d corrugation, or lobes near the X-point degrade ballooning stability so much that the pedestal recovers rapidly to cross the new stability boundary at lower pressure more frequently, whilst in the case of suppression, the plasma parameters are such that the particle transport reduces the edge pressure below the stability boundary, which is only mildly affected by negligible rotation braking, small edge corrugation or short, broad lobe structures.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chapman2013towards,
  author = {I.T. Chapman and A. Kirk and Christopher Ham and J. Harrison and Y. Q. Liu and S. Saarelma and R. Scannell and A. Thornton and M. Bécoulet and F. Orain and W.A. Cooper and S. Pamela and Mast Team},
  title = {{Towards understanding edge localised mode mitigation by resonant magnetic perturbations in MAST}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1063/1.4801743},
}
Figure