Towards the Prosody of Persuasion in Competitive Negotiation. The Relationship Between f0 and Negotiation Success in Same Sex Sales Tasks

Jan Michalsky, Heike Schoormann, Thomas SchultzeInterspeech 2019

TL;DR

This study explores how fundamental frequency (f0) in speech influences negotiation success in same-sex competitive sales scenarios. Researchers found that while broader f0 variation generally boosts persuasiveness, the specific f0 patterns associated with success differ between male and female negotiators, suggesting distinct strategies for dominance and charisma.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Persuasion through speech is a well-studied area, particularly in public speaking where charisma and leadership are often linked to vocal cues like fundamental frequency (f0). However, most research has focused on monologues or cooperative negotiations. This paper tackles a gap by investigating the role of acoustic-prosodic cues, specifically f0, in competitive negotiation, a scenario where win-lose dynamics are at play. The authors aim to understand if the prosodic features that signal persuasion in public speaking translate directly to competitive negotiation, or if different vocal strategies are employed, especially considering the potential for gender-based differences in communication styles.

Methods

The researchers employed a controlled experimental setup. Sixty-two participants (44 female, 18 male) were paired in same-sex dyads (22 female-female, 9 male-male) to negotiate the sale of a fictional company. Participants were assigned roles as either buyer or seller and given a five-minute time limit to reach an agreement. Audio recordings of these negotiations were then analyzed using ProsodyPro software to extract several f0 features: mean, minimum, maximum, excursion size (range), and final f0. Statistical analysis involved linear mixed-effects models to determine the relationship between these f0 features and the interlocutor's concession range (the difference between their initial and final offer). This approach allows for controlling for individual conversational differences and examining the impact of speaker sex.

Datasets

The study utilized audio recordings from 31 same-sex negotiation dyads, comprising 62 participants. This dataset was a subset of a larger study, specifically selected to focus on same-sex interactions and reduce potential confounds from mixed-sex entrainment effects. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Broader f0 range signals persuasiveness: Similar to public speaking, a larger f0 excursion (range) in competitive negotiation correlates with greater concessions from the interlocutor, suggesting expressiveness and confidence are key.
  • Dominance vs. Charisma: The study hints at a trade-off between signaling dominance and charisma in competitive negotiation. While charisma often involves passion and emotional investment (linked to higher f0), dominance (potentially linked to lower f0) might be more effective in this context.
  • Gendered Prosodic Strategies: A significant finding is the divergence in how f0 relates to negotiation success between male and female speakers. This suggests that men and women may employ different vocal strategies to achieve their goals in competitive settings.
  • Lower f0 maxima can be beneficial: Counterintuitively, lower f0 maxima were associated with greater interlocutor concession, suggesting that while a broad range is good, excessively high peaks might be detrimental.
  • Final f0 as an indicator of assertiveness: For male speakers, lower final f0 values (potentially indicating falling contours) correlated with higher concessions, suggesting a link to assertiveness.

Key Results

  • Overall: A larger f0 range and higher f0 minimum were positively correlated with interlocutor concession range. Lower f0 maxima also correlated with greater concession.
  • Gender Interaction (f0 Minimum): Both sexes showed a positive correlation between f0 minimum and concession range, but the effect was shallower for male speakers.
  • Gender Interaction (f0 Mean): Female speakers showed a positive correlation between f0 mean and concession range, while male speakers showed a negative correlation. This suggests female speakers become more persuasive with a higher average pitch, while male speakers might become more persuasive with a lower average pitch, potentially signaling dominance.
  • Male Speakers (Post-hoc): For male speakers specifically, lower f0 maxima and lower final f0 values were significantly correlated with greater interlocutor concession.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sexual Orientation: The study did not account for participants' sexual orientation, which could influence perceptions of attractiveness and negotiation dynamics.
  • Generalizability: The study was conducted with German speakers, and findings may not generalize to languages with different intonation systems.
  • Scope of Analysis: The analysis focused solely on f0. Future work should incorporate other prosodic features (rhythm, voice quality) and potentially multimodal cues (body language, facial expressions) for a more comprehensive understanding.

Future research directions include:

  • Investigating mixed-sex negotiations to explore how gender dynamics interact with prosodic cues.
  • Conducting tonal analysis to better understand the implications of final f0 contours.
  • Extending the analysis to include rhythmic and voice quality features to align with broader research on charismatic speech.
  • Exploring additional prosodic parameters and multimodal cues for a richer understanding of persuasive communication.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{michalsky2019towards,
  author = {Jan Michalsky and Heike Schoormann and Thomas Schultze},
  title = {{Towards the Prosody of Persuasion in Competitive Negotiation. The Relationship Between f0 and Negotiation Success in Same Sex Sales Tasks}},
  booktitle = {Interspeech},
  year = {2019},
}
Figure