Towards synergistic combination of biochar/ultrasonic persulfate enhancing removal of natural humic acids from water

Hongbo Liu, Mengting Ye, Zhenxing Ren, Éric Lichtfouse, Zhongbing ChenJournal of Environmental Chemical Engineering 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel approach to removing humic acids (HAs) from water by synergistically combining biochar, ultrasonic irradiation, and persulfate. This integrated system achieved a remarkable 92.5% removal rate, significantly outperforming individual methods and offering a promising solution for water purification.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Natural organic matter (NOM), particularly humic acids (HAs), is a ubiquitous contaminant in natural water sources, posing challenges for water treatment due to its complex structure and recalcitrance. While advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) like persulfate activation and adsorption using biochar are effective individually, their combined potential for HA removal, especially with the enhancement of ultrasonic treatment, has not been fully explored. This research aims to bridge this gap by investigating a synergistic approach to efficiently remove HAs from water, addressing the need for more effective and potentially energy-efficient water purification technologies.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach to investigate the removal of humic acids:

  • Combined Treatment System: The core of the research involved a system integrating biochar (derived from corn stalks), ultrasonic irradiation (53 kHz, 60 W), and persulfate (PS).
  • Characterization Techniques:
    • Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) and Differential Thermogravimetric Analysis (DTG): Used to assess the thermal stability and composition of the biochar precursor.
  • Raman Spectroscopy: Employed to analyze the structural properties of the biochar, specifically the degree of disorder and graphitization.
  • Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR): Utilized to identify functional groups on the biochar surface before and after the reaction.
  • X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS): Applied to analyze the elemental composition and chemical states of the biochar surface, particularly changes in carbon and oxygen functionalities.
  • Gel Permeation Chromatography (GPC): Used to determine the change in molecular weight of humic acids before and after treatment.
  • UV-Vis Spectroscopy: Employed to monitor the adsorption of humic acids and to calculate the spectral coefficient (SR) as an indicator of molecular weight changes.
  • Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) Spectroscopy: Utilized with DMPO as a spin-trapping agent to identify and quantify the active radical species generated during the process.
  • Fluorescence Spectroscopy (3D-EEM and FRI): Applied to analyze the composition and removal of different fluorescent organic matter components in the water.
  • Kinetic and Synergy Analysis:
    • Pseudo-first-order kinetic model: Used to analyze the reaction rates of HA removal under different conditions.
  • Synergy index: Calculated to quantify the synergistic or antagonistic effects between different treatment components.
  • Radical Quenching Experiments: Tert-butyl alcohol (TBA) and methanol (MeOH) were used to selectively quench hydroxyl (•OH) and sulfate (SO4•) radicals, respectively, to determine their contribution to HA removal.
  • Real Water Application: The developed system was tested on raw water from the Yangtze River to assess its practical applicability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized synthesized humic acid solutions and real water samples from the Yangtze River.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Powerhouse: The combination of biochar, ultrasonic irradiation, and persulfate creates a powerful synergistic effect for humic acid removal, significantly outperforming any single component or pairwise combination. This suggests that the whole is truly greater than the sum of its parts in this system.
  • Dominance of Hydroxyl Radicals: While both sulfate and hydroxyl radicals are generated, the quenching experiments strongly indicate that hydroxyl radicals (•OH) are the primary active species responsible for the efficient degradation of humic acids in this combined system.
  • Biochar's Multifaceted Role: Biochar acts not only as an adsorbent, concentrating humic acids and persulfate at its surface, but also as a catalyst, providing active sites for persulfate activation. Ultrasonic treatment further enhances these roles by cleaning the biochar surface and improving mass transfer.
  • Ultrasonic Enhancement: Ultrasonic irradiation plays a crucial role beyond just activating persulfate. It appears to enhance the synergistic interaction between biochar and persulfate, potentially by improving mass transfer, cleaning biochar surfaces, and creating a more favorable environment for radical generation.
  • Molecular Weight Reduction: The treatment effectively breaks down larger humic acid molecules into smaller fragments, as evidenced by GPC and UV-vis spectral analysis, indicating a more complete degradation rather than just adsorption.

Key Results

  • High Removal Efficiency: The combined biochar/ultrasonic/persulfate system achieved a remarkable 92.5% removal rate of humic acids.
  • Comparison of Systems:
    • Combined biochar/ultrasonic/persulfate: 92.5%
    • Combined biochar/persulfate: 84.0%
    • Sole biochar: 52.0%
    • Combined biochar/ultrasonic: 50.0%
    • Combined persulfate/ultrasonic: 10.0%
    • Sole ultrasonic: 4.0%
    • Sole persulfate: 1.0%
  • Rapid Reaction Kinetics: The system demonstrated a fast reaction rate, with a pseudo-first-order rate constant (kobs) of 3.4 × 10⁻² min⁻¹ for the combined system.
  • Synergy Index: A synergy index of 2.76 confirmed the significant synergistic effect of the combined treatment.
  • pH Adaptability: The system showed good performance across a range of pH values (5.0-9.0), with removal efficiencies generally above 88%.
  • Real Water Efficacy: The treatment effectively removed organic matter from raw Yangtze River water, achieving a 77.7% TOC removal rate.
  • Biochar Reusability: While the biochar's removal capacity decreased over three cycles, the combined system showed better recycling capacity compared to biochar/persulfate alone.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Biochar Reusability: Although the biochar showed some reusability, its removal efficiency decreased significantly after the second and third cycles. Further research is needed to improve the long-term reusability of the biochar.
  • Energy Efficiency: While the system is effective, the energy input, primarily from ultrasonic irradiation, needs to be considered for large-scale applications. The paper mentions calculating energy efficiency (EEO) and suggests that the combined system has the lowest EEO among those studied, but further optimization for energy reduction would be beneficial.
  • Mechanism Elucidation: While the dominant role of hydroxyl radicals was identified, a more detailed understanding of the non-radical pathways and the precise interactions between biochar, ultrasonic waves, and persulfate could lead to further optimization.
  • Application to Diverse NOM: The study focused on humic acids as a model pollutant. Future work could explore the effectiveness of this system on a wider range of NOM components and other organic contaminants in real water matrices.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{liu2022towards,
  author = {Hongbo Liu and Mengting Ye and Zhenxing Ren and Éric Lichtfouse and Zhongbing Chen},
  title = {{Towards synergistic combination of biochar/ultrasonic persulfate enhancing removal of natural humic acids from water}},
  journal = {Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jece.2022.107809},
}
Figure