Towards Sustainable Human–Land Symbiosis: An Empirical Study of Chinese Traditional Villages

Jianmin Wang, Xiaoying Wen, Shikang Zhou, Zhihong Zhang, Dongye ZhaoLand 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the soundscapes of traditional villages, particularly natural sounds and local human voices, play a crucial role in fostering a sense of land attachment among residents. This attachment, in turn, significantly enhances their environmental satisfaction, offering a novel pathway for sustainable rural development by optimizing auditory environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rural China faces a growing disconnect between urban and rural areas, leading to escalating human-land conflicts and the erosion of traditional villages. These villages, repositories of cultural heritage and historical landscapes, are struggling with issues like rural revitalization, cultural preservation, and ecological balance. The paper addresses the gap in understanding how intangible aspects of the rural environment, specifically soundscapes, influence residents' connection to their land and their overall satisfaction, which are critical for sustainable development and preventing the phenomenon of "empty villages."

Methods

The study employs a mixed-methods approach, integrating three key techniques:

  • Field Research and Surveys: Researchers conducted systematic field surveys in five traditional villages, collecting data through questionnaires administered to 524 residents. These questionnaires gathered information on background demographics, soundscape perception (preference, occurrence, loudness of 18 sound sources), land attachment (land dependence and rootedness), and environmental satisfaction.
  • Association Rule Mining (ARM): ARM was used to identify strong associations and patterns among the perceived sound sources. This data-driven technique helps uncover frequently co-occurring sound combinations and their relationships with other variables. The study used the Apriori algorithm and evaluated rules based on support, confidence, and lift.
  • Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): SEM, based on the Stimulus-Organism-Response (S-O-R) framework, was employed to test the hypothesized causal relationships between soundscape perception, land attachment (as mediators), and environmental satisfaction (as the outcome). This statistical technique allows for the simultaneous examination of multiple relationships and indirect effects.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a survey of 524 residents across five representative traditional villages in Jinyuan District, Taiyuan City, Shanxi Province, China. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation; instead, the research generated its own primary data through field surveys and questionnaires.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Soundscapes as Emotional Mediators: The research strongly suggests that soundscapes are not merely background noise but act as powerful emotional mediators, shaping how residents feel about their connection to the land.
  • The Power of Familiar Sounds: Culturally significant sounds like local dialects and tour guide narratives, alongside natural sounds (birdsong, rustling leaves), are key drivers of positive emotional responses and strengthen the human-land bond.
  • Indirect Influence on Satisfaction: Sound perception doesn't directly impact environmental satisfaction. Instead, its influence is channeled through the development of land dependence and land rootedness.
  • Land Dependence vs. Land Rootedness: While both contribute to satisfaction, land dependence (economic and emotional reliance) appears to have a stronger mediating effect than land rootedness (sense of belonging). Interestingly, land dependence was found to have a negative effect on land rootedness, suggesting a complex emotional dynamic where economic reliance might coexist with a willingness to leave.
  • Optimizing for Sustainability: The findings offer a practical framework for rural planning, emphasizing that by consciously designing and preserving positive sound environments, communities can foster stronger land attachment and, consequently, enhance overall environmental satisfaction and promote sustainable development.

Key Results

  • ARM Findings: The top 10 strong ARM relationships revealed that combinations of tour guide sound, dialect sound, wind-blown leaf sound, and birdsong were strongly associated with tourist sounds (support = 50%, confidence = 78%, lift = 1.33). This highlights the importance of these specific sounds in the village soundscape.
  • SEM Path Coefficients:
    • Sound perception significantly and positively influenced land dependence (β = 0.952, p < 0.001) and land rootedness (β = 1.812, p < 0.001).
  • Land dependence positively influenced environmental satisfaction (β = 0.491, p < 0.001).
  • Land rootedness positively influenced environmental satisfaction (β = 0.200, p = 0.023).
  • A chain mediation effect was observed: sound perception influenced environmental satisfaction through land dependence and land rootedness (H9: β = -0.192, p = 0.027).
  • The direct effect of sound perception on environmental satisfaction (H3) was not supported (β = -0.031, p = 0.874).
  • Land dependence had a significant negative effect on land rootedness (H6: β = -1.012, p < 0.001).

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The study relied on self-reported questionnaire data without qualitative triangulation. * Acoustic measurements focused on sound pressure levels, not psychoacoustic characteristics or multisensory interactions. * The SEM model assumed unidirectional pathways and did not test for reciprocal or moderating effects. * The analysis primarily focused on the presence/absence of sounds and general appreciation, not the nuanced ways sounds contribute to sonic identity or cultural markers.

Future Work: * Expand the geographic scope and diversity of villages studied. * Incorporate qualitative data, audiovisual interaction, VR, and physiological monitoring for a richer understanding. * Conduct longitudinal studies to track the evolution of emotional bonds over time. * Integrate objective acoustic measurements (decibel levels, frequency spectra) with subjective perceptions for more precise assessments. * Apply soundscape design principles in village renewal programs, incorporating local dialects, traditional performances, and natural sounds. * Avoid intensive mechanical or intrusive sounds in rural planning.

Summary updated

Abstract

In response to the growing urban–rural dichotomy and escalating human–land conflicts in rural China, this study investigates the role of soundscapes as emotional mediators to enhance environmental satisfaction and foster sustainable human–land symbiosis. To address this need, we carried out a series of systematic field surveys at five representative traditional villages in a major provincial capital city in China, and we implemented a comprehensive questionnaire and surveyed 524 residents about their perceptions of sound, land affection, and environment. We employed a mixed-methods approach combining questionnaire surveys, association rule mining (ARM), and structural equation modeling (SEM) to explore the ‘sound–land–environment’ interaction chain. ARM analysis identified strong associations among tour guide narratives, local dialects, natural sounds (e.g., rustling leaves, birdsong), and tourist-generated sounds (support = 50%, confidence = 78%, lift = 1.33). SEM results revealed that soundscapes significantly and positively influence land dependence (β = 0.952, p &lt; 0.001) and land rootedness (β = 1.812, p &lt; 0.001), which in turn jointly affect environmental satisfaction (β = –0.192, p = 0.027) through a chain mediation pathway. These findings suggest that optimizing rural soundscapes can strengthen emotional bonds between people and land, thereby enhancing environmental satisfaction and promoting performance of sustainable human–land symbiosis. The study contributes theoretically by elucidating the emotional mechanisms linking soundscapes to human–land relationships and offers insights for incorporating soundscape considerations into village planning and developing policies to cultivate land attachment, supporting the sustainable development of traditional villages.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2025towards,
  author = {Jianmin Wang and Xiaoying Wen and Shikang Zhou and Zhihong Zhang and Dongye Zhao},
  title = {{Towards Sustainable Human–Land Symbiosis: An Empirical Study of Chinese Traditional Villages}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/land14081676},
}
Figure