Towards Stochastic Optimization-Based Electric Vehicle Penetration in a Novel Archipelago Microgrid

Qingyu Yang, Dou An, Wei Yu, Zhengan Tan, Xinyu YangSensors 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "archipelago microgrid" concept for enhanced energy efficiency and reduced emissions by integrating electric vehicles (EVs) into a network of islanded microgrids. They propose a stochastic optimization model to determine the optimal number of EVs, considering uncertainties in renewable energy sources and load demand, and present two scheduling schemes (UCS and LCS) to manage EV charging and discharging effectively.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of integrating electric vehicles (EVs) into islanded microgrids (IMGs) to reduce CO2 emissions and operational costs. IMGs, while offering benefits like isolation from grid disturbances, face significant hurdles due to the intermittent nature of renewable energy sources (RESs) like wind and solar, and unpredictable load demands. Effectively managing EV charging and discharging within these IMGs is crucial to leverage their potential as distributed energy storage and to avoid exacerbating grid instability or increasing costs. Existing approaches often overlook the complexities of multiple interconnected IMGs and the inherent uncertainties in RES generation and demand.

Methods

The core of the paper is the development of a Stochastic Optimal Penetration (SOP) model. This is a two-stage stochastic programming approach designed to minimize both emission and operation costs. Key methodological contributions include:

  • Archipelago Microgrid Concept: A novel system architecture comprising multiple interconnected IMGs that can exchange power, allowing for better utilization of surplus energy and reduced reliance on local generation.
  • Two-Stage Stochastic Programming: This framework explicitly accounts for uncertainties in RES generation (wind, solar) and load demand. The first stage involves making decisions (e.g., EV penetration levels) before uncertainties are realized, while the second stage involves making corrective decisions once the uncertainties are known.
  • Monte Carlo-Based Scenario Generation: To represent the uncertainties, the authors use the Monte Carlo method to generate a large number of scenarios for RES output and load demand. These scenarios are then reduced using a fast-forward scenario reduction mechanism for computational efficiency.
  • Scheduling Schemes: Two distinct schemes are proposed for managing EV charging/discharging:
  • Unlimited Coordinated Scheme (UCS): Assumes surplus energy can be freely transported between MGs to charge as many EVs as possible.
  • Limited Coordinated Scheme (LCS): Introduces realistic constraints like peak load limitations and tariff compensation, making it a more practical approach.
  • Optimization Solver: The paper mentions using an integer and binary Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) algorithm to solve the SOP and Deterministic Optimal Penetration (DOP) problems.

Datasets

The paper utilizes a modified IEEE 9-bus test system for simulation and evaluation. This system is configured with three microgrids (MGs) to represent the "archipelago microgrid" concept. The parameters for generation units, RESs, and load demands are derived from existing literature and industry standards, with specific details provided in tables and figures within the paper. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interconnected IMGs are Key: The "archipelago microgrid" concept, allowing power exchange between MGs, is crucial for maximizing RES utilization and accommodating more EVs, thereby improving energy efficiency.
  • Stochasticity Matters: Ignoring uncertainties in RES and demand leads to significantly higher operational costs and emissions compared to stochastic optimization. The SOP model provides a more realistic and cost-effective solution.
  • LCS is More Practical: While UCS allows for maximum EV penetration, the LCS, with its peak load and tariff considerations, offers a more realistic and ultimately more cost-effective approach for EV integration in real-world scenarios.
  • EVs as Flexible Resources: EVs are not just loads but flexible assets that can be strategically managed to balance supply and demand, reduce emissions, and improve grid stability.
  • Balancing Environmental and Economic Goals: The weighting factor 'w' in the objective function allows for a tunable balance between environmental (emission reduction) and economic (cost reduction) objectives, enabling tailored system operation.

Key Results

  • Emission and Cost Reduction: The proposed SOP model, particularly with the LCS scheme, demonstrated significant reductions in both CO2 emissions and operational costs compared to a Deterministic Optimal Penetration (DOP) model. Specifically, LCS achieved approximately 15.2% emission reduction and 11.2% cost savings compared to a non-coordinated average scheme.
  • EV Penetration: The SOP model, especially with LCS, allows for a more realistic and optimized number of EVs to be deployed, balancing the benefits of EV charging with system constraints.
  • Scenario Reduction Effectiveness: The use of a fast-forward scenario reduction mechanism effectively reduced the number of scenarios from 1000 to 10, balancing computational complexity with accuracy.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: The study showed that the weighting factor significantly impacts the trade-off between emission and operation costs, while the compensation factor and RES fluctuations influence the number of EVs and overall system performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified EV Model: The paper assumes EVs charge and discharge once a day and have a fixed battery capacity. Future work could explore more complex EV behavior, including varying battery capacities and more dynamic charging/discharging patterns.
  • Communication Network Assumptions: The paper assumes reliable communication within the archipelago microgrid. The impact of communication delays or failures on the system's performance is not explicitly addressed.
  • Market Mechanisms: While tariff compensation is considered, a more detailed market mechanism for energy trading between MGs and with consumers could be explored.
  • Scalability: The study was conducted on a modified 9-bus system. Future research could investigate the scalability of the proposed approach to larger and more complex microgrid networks.
  • Integration of Other DERs: The focus is on EVs. Future work could incorporate other distributed energy resources (DERs) like battery storage systems and distributed generators more comprehensively.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to the advantage of avoiding upstream disturbance and voltage fluctuation from a power transmission system, Islanded Micro-Grids (IMG) have attracted much attention. In this paper, we first propose a novel self-sufficient Cyber-Physical System (CPS) supported by Internet of Things (IoT) techniques, namely "archipelago micro-grid (MG)", which integrates the power grid and sensor networks to make the grid operation effective and is comprised of multiple MGs while disconnected with the utility grid. The Electric Vehicles (EVs) are used to replace a portion of Conventional Vehicles (CVs) to reduce CO 2 emission and operation cost. Nonetheless, the intermittent nature and uncertainty of Renewable Energy Sources (RESs) remain a challenging issue in managing energy resources in the system. To address these issues, we formalize the optimal EV penetration problem as a two-stage Stochastic Optimal Penetration (SOP) model, which aims to minimize the emission and operation cost in the system. Uncertainties coming from RESs (e.g., wind, solar, and load demand) are considered in the stochastic model and random parameters to represent those uncertainties are captured by the Monte Carlo-based method. To enable the reasonable deployment of EVs in each MGs, we develop two scheduling schemes, namely Unlimited Coordinated Scheme (UCS) and Limited Coordinated Scheme (LCS), respectively. An extensive simulation study based on a modified 9 bus system with three MGs has been carried out to show the effectiveness of our proposed schemes. The evaluation data indicates that our proposed strategy can reduce both the environmental pollution created by CO 2 emissions and operation costs in UCS and LCS.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2016towards,
  author = {Qingyu Yang and Dou An and Wei Yu and Zhengan Tan and Xinyu Yang},
  title = {{Towards Stochastic Optimization-Based Electric Vehicle Penetration in a Novel Archipelago Microgrid}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/s16060907},
}
Figure