Towards Optimal Platform-Based Robot Design for Ankle Rehabilitation: The State of the Art and Future Prospects

Qing Miao, Mingming Zhang, Congzhe Wang, Hongsheng LiJournal of Healthcare Engineering 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This review critically analyzes existing robot designs for ankle rehabilitation, categorizing them into wearable and platform-based systems. It identifies key design principles for an optimal ankle rehabilitation robot, emphasizing aligned rotation centers, appropriate workspace and torque, and adjustable posture, while also highlighting the potential of reconfigurable designs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Conventional rehabilitation for ankle injuries, whether musculoskeletal or neurological, is labor-intensive and requires significant patient effort. While robotics offers a promising solution to enhance therapy efficiency and data collection, the field of ankle rehabilitation robots is fragmented. Existing devices often have limitations in their design, such as misaligned rotation centers, insufficient workspace, or lack of adaptability to individual patient needs and varying stages of recovery. This paper aims to address this by providing a comprehensive comparative analysis of current ankle rehabilitation robot designs to guide the development of more effective and optimal systems.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic literature search using keywords like "ankle," "robot," and "rehabilitation" in Google Scholar and Scopus, focusing on English-language articles published between January 1980 and September 2016. They primarily drew from existing systematic reviews and then supplemented with additional relevant papers. The review's core methodology involves a comparative analysis of robot designs, classifying them into wearable and platform-based categories. They then evaluated these designs based on criteria such as degrees of freedom (DOF), alignment of the robot's rotation center with the ankle joint, workspace, actuation torque, posture adjustability, and sensing capabilities.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review article that analyzes existing research and robot designs, rather than presenting new experimental data or training models on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • No One-Size-Fits-All: The paper strongly emphasizes that a single "optimal" design for all ankle rehabilitation scenarios is unlikely. Therapy needs to be tailored to individual patient needs and the specific stage of their injury.
  • Anatomy is Key: The design of rehabilitation robots should closely mimic the complex biomechanics of the human ankle joint, which is not a simple hinge but involves multiple rotational axes.
  • Parallel vs. Serial Mechanisms: While serial mechanisms can be bulky, parallel mechanisms offer compactness and high torque capacity, making them attractive for multi-DOF ankle rehabilitation. However, they present challenges in workspace and singularity.
  • Reconfigurability is the Future: The concept of reconfigurable robots, capable of adapting their DOF and workspace for different training modes, is highlighted as a promising avenue for future development.
  • Beyond Just Motion: Factors like posture adjustability, secure yet comfortable foot/shank fixation, and the inclusion of mechanical stops for safety are crucial for clinical adoption.

Key Results

The review categorizes existing ankle rehabilitation robots into two main types: wearable (e.g., exoskeletons for gait training) and platform-based (stationary bases with moving footplates). Platform-based robots are further divided into single-DOF and multi-DOF systems, with multi-DOF devices being more suitable for comprehensive rehabilitation.

Key design considerations for an optimal ankle rehabilitation robot include:

  • Aligned Rotation Center: Crucial for natural motion and preventing user injury.
  • Appropriate Workspace: Must accommodate the full range of ankle motion required for therapy.
  • Sufficient Actuation Torque: Necessary for both passive and active/resistive exercises.
  • Adjustable Posture: Enhances usability across a wider patient population.

The paper notes that while single-DOF robots are good for specific tasks (like stretching), multi-DOF robots are better for comprehensive training. It also points out that the complexity of the ankle joint's motion necessitates systems with at least two, and ideally three, rotational DOFs.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The review primarily focused on English-language articles published up to September 2016, potentially missing newer developments or research in other languages. * It assumed that prototypes reported by the same group across different studies were fundamentally the same design, overlooking minor iterative improvements. * The search might have missed relevant studies where "ankle" was not explicitly used as a keyword, but rather broader terms like "lower extremity" were employed.

Future Work: * Developing reconfigurable and modular ankle rehabilitation robots that can adapt their functionality (DOF, workspace, torque) to specific patient needs and training modes. * Further optimization of parallel mechanisms for ankle rehabilitation to improve workspace and torque capacity, potentially by addressing singularities. * Investigating more advanced sensing and control strategies to enable personalized and interactive rehabilitation. * Designing more compliant and adaptable fixation methods for the foot and shank to improve patient comfort and reduce injury risk. * Exploring the integration of mechanical stops to ensure safety, especially in systems with workspaces larger than natural ankle motion.

Summary updated

Abstract

This review aims to compare existing robot-assisted ankle rehabilitation techniques in terms of robot design. Included studies mainly consist of selected papers in two published reviews involving a variety of robot-assisted ankle rehabilitation techniques. A free search was also made in Google Scholar and Scopus by using keywords "ankle<sup>∗</sup>," and "robot<sup>∗</sup>," and ("rehabilitat<sup>∗</sup>" or "treat<sup>∗</sup>"). The search is limited to English-language articles published between January 1980 and September 2016. Results show that existing robot-assisted ankle rehabilitation techniques can be classified into wearable exoskeleton and platform-based devices. Platform-based devices are mostly developed for the treatment of a variety of ankle musculoskeletal and neurological injuries, while wearable ones focus more on ankle-related gait training. In terms of robot design, comparative analysis indicates that an ideal ankle rehabilitation robot should have aligned rotation center as the ankle joint, appropriate workspace, and actuation torque, no matter how many degrees of freedom (DOFs) it has. Single-DOF ankle robots are mostly developed for specific applications, while multi-DOF devices are more suitable for comprehensive ankle rehabilitation exercises. Other factors including posture adjustability and sensing functions should also be considered to promote related clinical applications. An ankle rehabilitation robot with reconfigurability to maximize its functions will be a new research point towards optimal design, especially on parallel mechanisms.
BibTeX
@article{miao2018towards,
  author = {Qing Miao and Mingming Zhang and Congzhe Wang and Hongsheng Li},
  title = {{Towards Optimal Platform-Based Robot Design for Ankle Rehabilitation: The State of the Art and Future Prospects}},
  journal = {Journal of Healthcare Engineering},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1155/2018/1534247},
}
Figure