Towards near-real-time air pollutant and greenhouse gas emissions: lessons learned from multiple estimates during the COVID-19 pandemic

Marc Guevara, Hervé Petetin, Oriol Jorba, Hugo Denier van der Gon, Jeroen Kuenen, Ingrid Super, Claire Granier, Thierno Doumbia, Philippe Ciais, Zhu Liu, Robin Lamboll, Sabine Schindlbacher, Bradley Matthews, Carlos Pérez García‐PandoAtmospheric 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

The COVID-19 pandemic caused a significant, unprecedented drop in air pollutant and greenhouse gas emissions. This study compares near-real-time emission estimates derived from novel data sources (like mobility data) with official, lagged inventories for Europe. While overall annual trends align, significant discrepancies emerge at the sector and country level, highlighting the need for caution and further validation of these emerging near-real-time methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Official national emission inventories, crucial for tracking progress towards climate and air quality goals, have a significant time lag (typically 2 years). This delay makes them unsuitable for timely monitoring and modeling, especially during major, unexpected events like the COVID-19 pandemic. The pandemic's drastic reduction in human activity created an urgent need for "near-real-time" emission estimates. This paper addresses the challenge of evaluating the reliability and comparability of these emerging near-real-time emission datasets against established official inventories, particularly for the European region. It aims to understand the discrepancies and provide insights for their future use in modeling and policy.

Methods

The study employs an intercomparison approach, comparing emission changes from four different near-real-time datasets with official emission inventories. The near-real-time datasets utilize various proxies, including:

  • Mobility data: Derived from smartphones (e.g., Google COVID-19 Community Mobility Reports) and navigation apps (e.g., TomTom).
  • Energy data: Electricity demand and generation statistics from sources like ENTSO-E.
  • Industrial production indices: Data from Eurostat.
  • Traffic counts: Traditional traffic data.
  • Flight and shipping data: Information from aviation authorities and maritime trade databases.

These proxies are used to derive "adjustment factors" that quantify the reduction in emissions compared to a business-as-usual scenario. The study analyzes these changes at annual, quarterly, and monthly resolutions, focusing on various air pollutants (NOx, NMVOC, CO, SO2, NH3, PM2.5) and greenhouse gases (CO2, CH4) across different sectors and countries in the EU27 + UK.

Datasets

The study utilizes the following datasets:

  • Official Emission Inventories:
    • Air Pollutants (APs): Reported under the Convention on Long-Range Transboundary Air Pollution (CLRTAP) and managed by the EMEP Centre on Emission Inventories and Projections (emep_ceip).
  • Greenhouse Gases (GHGs): Reported under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) (unfccc).
  • Near-Real-Time Emission Estimates:
    • guevaraetal: Copernicus Atmosphere Monitoring Service (CAMS) COVID-19 emission adjustment factors (European coverage).
  • doumbiaetal: COvid-19 adjustment Factors fOR eMissions (CONFORM) dataset (global coverage).
  • forsteretal: COVID-19 emission estimates developed by Forster et al. (global coverage).
  • liuetal: Carbon Monitor initiative (European version available for CO2 emissions).

The study also references data from sources like Google COVID-19 Community Mobility Reports, TomTom, Flightradar24, UN COMTRADE, ENTSO-E, Eurostat, and national inventory submissions (e.g., CITEPA for France, BEIS for the UK, CBS for the Netherlands) for specific comparisons.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Great Equalizer" of COVID-19: The pandemic provided a unique, albeit tragic, opportunity to observe the impact of drastic human activity reduction on emissions. This event underscored the limitations of traditional, lagged emission reporting.
  • Near-Real-Time Data is Promising, But Not Perfect: Novel data sources like mobility data can offer valuable near-real-time insights, but they are not a silver bullet. Their effectiveness varies significantly by sector and country.
  • Sectoral and Country-Level Discrepancies are Key: While overall European emission drops for pollutants like NOx and CO2 showed general agreement between near-real-time and official estimates, the devil is in the details. Significant differences emerge when drilling down into specific sectors (e.g., manufacturing industry, road transport) and individual countries.
  • Non-COVID Factors Still Matter: For sectors like residential combustion, shipping, and public energy, changes in emissions between 2019 and 2020 were often driven by pre-existing trends like meteorology (warmer winters), decarbonization policies (coal phase-outs), and regulatory changes (Global Sulphur Cap), rather than solely by pandemic restrictions.
  • Data Heterogeneity is a Challenge: The study highlights how different countries report emissions for certain activities (like solvent use from pandemic products) using varying levels of detail, leading to inconsistencies even within official reporting.

Key Results

  • Overall Trends Align: For most species, annual total emission changes in 2020 reported by official and near-real-time estimates were "fairly in line." NOx and fossil fuel CO2 showed the largest reductions across Europe.
  • Significant Sectoral/Country Discrepancies:
    • Manufacturing industry NOx: Relative changes ranged from -21.4% to -5.4% between official and non-official estimates.
  • Road transport CO2: Relative changes ranged from -29.3% to -5.6%.
  • Monthly/Quarterly Variations: Discrepancies were substantial in the temporal distribution of emission drops. For total NOx in April 2020 (peak restrictions), differences between near-real-time inventories reached up to a factor of 1.5.
  • Specific Sector Findings:
    • Public Power: Near-real-time estimates generally showed lower SO2 reductions than official ones, often due to pre-existing decarbonization trends.
  • Residential Combustion: Changes were largely driven by meteorology, not COVID-19.
  • Manufacturing Industry: Differences were notable, with some near-real-time estimates showing much larger NMVOC reductions than official data.
  • Road Transport: guevaraetal and liuetal showed better agreement with official estimates than doumbiaetal and forsteretal.
  • Aviation: Showed the largest drops across all estimates, with relatively consistent results.
  • NMVOC from Pandemic Products: Heterogeneous reporting in official inventories makes it difficult to capture the impact of increased use of hand sanitizers, for example.

Limitations and Future Work

  • No Absolute Ground Truth: The study acknowledges that official emission inventories themselves have uncertainties and are subject to revisions. Therefore, direct cross-verification of near-real-time data against official data doesn't establish absolute accuracy but rather provides a measure of consistency and highlights discrepancies.
  • Data Availability and Consistency: Obtaining accurate and consistent local information for near-real-time emission proxies remains a challenge, especially at a global level. While European data (like guevaraetal) showed better alignment, global datasets exhibited larger discrepancies.
  • Limited Scope of Proxies: While mobility and energy data are emerging, near-real-time monitoring for sectors like solvent use, residential combustion, and agricultural activities remains scarce.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that combining new data sources (mobility, satellite data) with traditional statistics is crucial. They also emphasize the need for improved emission science that integrates near-real-time data into modeling and forecasting applications, moving beyond traditional inventory-based approaches. The increasing frequency of disruptive events (like the war in Ukraine) further underscores the importance of this shift.

Summary updated

Abstract

The 2020 COVID-19 crisis caused an unprecedented drop in anthropogenic emissions of air pollutants and greenhouse gases. Given that emissions estimates from official national inventories for the year 2020 were not reported until 2 years later, new and non-traditional datasets to estimate near-real-time emissions became particularly relevant and widely used in international monitoring and modelling activities during the pandemic. This study investigates the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on 2020 European (the 27 EU member states and the UK) emissions by comparing a selection of such near-real-time emission estimates, with the official inventories that were subsequently reported in 2022 under the Convention on Long-Range Transboundary Air Pollution (CLRTAP) and the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). Results indicate that annual changes in total 2020 emissions reported by official and near-real-time estimates are fairly in line for most of the chemical species, with NOx and fossil fuel CO2 being reported as the ones that experienced the largest reduction in Europe in all cases. However, large discrepancies arise between the official and non-official datasets when comparing annual results at the sector and country level, indicating that caution should be exercised when estimating changes in emissions using specific near-real-time activity datasets, such as time mobility data derived from smartphones. The main examples of these differences are observed for the manufacturing industry NOx (relative changes ranging between −21.4 % and −5.4 %) and road transport CO2 (relative changes ranging between −29.3 % and −5.6 %) total European emissions. Additionally, significant discrepancies are observed between the quarterly and monthly distribution of emissions drops reported by the various near-real-time inventories, with differences of up to a factor of 1.5 for total NOx during April 2020, when restrictions were at their maximum. For residential combustion, shipping and the public energy industry, results indicate that changes in emissions that occurred between 2019 and 2020 were mainly dominated by non-COVID-19 factors, including meteorology, the implementation of the Global Sulphur Cap and the shutdown of coal-fired power plants as part of national decarbonization efforts, respectively. The potential increase in NMVOC emissions from the intensive use of personal protective equipment such as hand sanitizer gels is considered in a heterogeneous way across countries in officially reported inventories, indicating the need for some countries to base their calculations on more advanced methods. The findings of this study can be used to better understand the uncertainties in near-real-time emissions and how such emissions could be used in the future to provide timely updates to emission datasets that are critical for modelling and monitoring applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guevara2023towards,
  author = {Marc Guevara and Hervé Petetin and Oriol Jorba and Hugo Denier van der Gon and Jeroen Kuenen and Ingrid Super and Claire Granier and Thierno Doumbia and Philippe Ciais and Zhu Liu and Robin Lamboll and Sabine Schindlbacher and Bradley Matthews and Carlos Pérez García‐Pando},
  title = {{Towards near-real-time air pollutant and greenhouse gas emissions: lessons learned from multiple estimates during the COVID-19 pandemic}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-23-8081-2023},
}
Figure