Towards Modeling and Resolving Singular Parameter Spaces using Stratifolds

Pascal Mattia Esser, Frank NielsenarXiv 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework using "stratifolds" from algebraic topology to formally model and resolve singular parameter spaces in statistical models. By constructing a smooth manifold approximation of these singular spaces, the authors demonstrate improved learning convergence and avoidance of attractor behaviors, particularly for gradient-based optimization methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many statistical models, including common ones like neural networks and mixtures, have parameter spaces that aren't smooth manifolds. Instead, they contain "singular points" where the space's geometry becomes non-smooth. These singularities pose significant problems for machine learning:

  1. Undefined Tangent Spaces: Gradient-based optimization methods, which rely on well-defined tangent spaces for updates, fail at these singular points.
  2. Attractor Behavior: Singularities can act as "attractors," causing learning algorithms to slow down dramatically or get stuck as they approach these points, hindering convergence.

The paper aims to address these issues by providing a principled way to model and "smooth out" these singular parameter spaces, enabling more robust and efficient learning.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in the application of stratifolds and their resolution to model singular parameter spaces.

  • Stratifolds: Borrowed from algebraic topology, stratifolds are a generalization of smooth manifolds that can formally describe spaces with singularities. They allow for a decomposition of the space into smooth "strata" of different dimensions.
  • Inductive Construction: The paper outlines a method to construct a stratifold representation of a parameter space, starting from lower-dimensional strata and iteratively attaching higher-dimensional ones.
  • Resolution: A key technique is the "resolution" of a stratifold. This process transforms the singular stratifold into a smooth manifold approximation. Crucially, this resolution preserves the dimension of the original space, unlike some prior functional approaches (e.g., blow-up).
  • Smooth Manifold Approximation: The resolved stratifold provides a smooth manifold that approximates the original singular space. The authors then apply gradient descent (and natural gradient descent) on this approximated smooth manifold instead of the original singular space.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses toy models and a specific "cone model" for illustration and experimentation, rather than standard datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stratifolds as a Formal Language: The paper highlights stratifolds as a powerful mathematical tool to precisely define and work with parameter spaces that deviate from the standard smooth manifold assumption.
  • Resolution as a Practical Solution: The concept of "resolution" is not just theoretical; it's presented as a practical method to create a smooth, well-behaved approximation of a singular space. This approximation allows existing optimization algorithms to function effectively.
  • Singularities as Attractors: The paper empirically confirms that singularities act as attractors, slowing down learning. The proposed resolution method effectively mitigates this by providing a smooth path.
  • Natural Gradient Descent Benefits: While natural gradient descent (NGD) is often robust to singularities due to its use of the Fisher Information Matrix (FIM), the paper suggests that resolving the singularity can still be beneficial. It prevents the FIM from degenerating, which can occur even for NGD in certain singular regimes.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of their approach through experiments on a "double cone model," a common example used to study singular parameter spaces.

  • Improved Convergence: By applying gradient descent (SGD) on the smooth manifold approximation (derived from the stratifold resolution), the learning process avoids getting trapped at the singularity. This leads to faster convergence compared to SGD on the original singular cone model.
  • Avoidance of Plateaus: The plots show that SGD on the original cone model exhibits plateau behavior near the singularity, indicating stalled learning. The resolved stratifold approach avoids this.
  • NGD Behavior: For NGD, the convergence speed on the original cone model and its smooth approximation is similar, aligning with previous findings that FIM-based methods are less affected by singularities. However, the resolution still offers benefits by preventing FIM degeneration.
  • Reaching True Parameterization: In cases where the initialization and target parameterization lie on different "cones" of the double cone model (requiring passage through the singularity), SGD on the original model gets stuck. In contrast, SGD on the resolved stratifold successfully reaches the target parameterization.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Isolated Singularities: The current work primarily addresses "isolated singularities." The authors acknowledge that more complex singularities exist and that extending their framework to handle them will be a significant future direction.
  • Theoretical vs. Practical Resolution: While [Gri03] offers theoretical frameworks for more complex singularities, their practical applicability remains an open question.
  • Computational Cost: The paper mentions that NGD, while powerful, can be computationally intensive due to the need to compute and invert the FIM, especially for complex models. This suggests that efficient implementation of their stratifold resolution for large-scale models will be crucial.
  • Broader Model Applicability: The authors express a strong expectation that more complex stratifold structures will be necessary to describe and resolve the parameter spaces of truly complex models beyond the toy examples presented.
  • Future Research: Future work includes a deeper understanding of the topology of parameter spaces in complex models, formally characterizing singular points and their resolutions, and exploring the practical application of stratifold resolutions to real-world machine learning problems.

Summary updated

Abstract

When analyzing parametric statistical models, a useful approach consists in modeling geometrically the parameter space. However, even for very simple and commonly used hierarchical models like statistical mixtures or stochastic deep neural networks, the smoothness assumption of manifolds is violated at singular points which exhibit non-smooth neighborhoods in the parameter space. These singular models have been analyzed in the context of learning dynamics, where singularities can act as attractors on the learning trajectory and, therefore, negatively influence the convergence speed of models. We propose a general approach to circumvent the problem arising from singularities by using stratifolds, a concept from algebraic topology, to formally model singular parameter spaces. We use the property that specific stratifolds are equipped with a resolution method to construct a smooth manifold approximation of the singular space. We empirically show that using (natural) gradient descent on the smooth manifold approximation instead of the singular space allows us to avoid the attractor behavior and therefore improve the convergence speed in learning.
BibTeX
@misc{esser2021towards,
  author = {Pascal Mattia Esser and Frank Nielsen},
  title = {{Towards Modeling and Resolving Singular Parameter Spaces using Stratifolds}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2112.03734},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.03734},
}
Figure