Towards higher sensitivity and stability of axon diameter estimation with diffusion‐weighted MRI

Farshid Sepehrband, Daniel C. Alexander, Nyoman D. Kurniawan, David C. Reutens, Zhengyi YangNMR 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper pushes the boundaries of diffusion-weighted MRI (dMRI) for estimating axon diameter, achieving higher sensitivity to smaller axons by using ultra-high gradient strengths. While still overestimating diameters compared to electron microscopy, the study identifies key factors like gradient strength and fitting routines that influence accuracy, paving the way for more precise in vivo microstructural analysis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the structure of white matter in the brain, particularly the diameter of axons, is crucial for comprehending neural connectivity, development, and the pathophysiology of neurological disorders. Diffusion-weighted MRI (dMRI) offers a non-invasive way to estimate axon morphometry. However, current methods struggle with sensitivity to small axons and stability in parameter estimation. Specifically, achieving accurate measurements of smaller axon diameters (below ~2 µm) has been a significant challenge, often leading to overestimations when compared to gold-standard histological methods like electron microscopy (EM). This paper aims to improve both the sensitivity and stability of axon diameter estimation by investigating the impact of acquisition parameters (specifically gradient strength) and advanced model-fitting techniques.

Methods

The researchers employed the ActiveAx technique, a model-based approach that fits a minimal white matter diffusion (MMWMD) model to dMRI data. They explored two main areas:

  • Acquisition Protocol Optimization: They utilized an ultra-high field (16.4-T) MRI scanner with a pulsed gradient spin echo (PGSE) sequence. Crucially, they tested two gradient strengths: a high strength (Gmax = 300 mT/m, previously used) and an ultra-high strength (Gmax = 1350 mT/m), pushing the scanner's limits. These protocols were optimized for sensitivity to mouse callosal axons.
  • Parameter Estimation Routine: They implemented a dictionary-based fitting routine, termed ActiveAx-D, which is similar to the AMICO framework but with key modifications. These include using a Rician noise model (more appropriate for MRI data than Gaussian) and a four-compartment tissue model (MMWMD). This approach aims to improve stability by avoiding local minima in the fitting process.

They also investigated potential sources of overestimation, including time-dependent diffusion in the extra-axonal space, limitations of the PGSE sequence itself, and axonal dispersion.

Datasets

The study used ex vivo mouse brain diffusion-weighted MRI data. The primary dataset was acquired from a single sacrificed mouse brain.

For validation, electron microscopy (EM) data of the mouse corpus callosum was used as the ground truth. This involved preparing tissue samples, sectioning them, and performing EM imaging to measure axon diameters directly.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gradient Strength is King (for small axons): The most significant finding is that increasing gradient strength dramatically improves sensitivity to smaller axon diameters. The ultra-high gradient (1350 mT/m) yielded estimates closer to EM, suggesting it can resolve finer structures.
  • Dictionary-Based Fitting Boosts Stability: The ActiveAx-D approach, using a dictionary and a Rician noise model, demonstrated improved stability (lower variance in estimates) and sensitivity compared to conventional ActiveAx. This highlights the importance of sophisticated fitting routines.
  • Overestimation Persists, but is Reduced: Despite improvements, axon diameter estimates still exceeded EM measurements. This suggests that even with advanced techniques, inherent limitations in dMRI models and acquisition sequences remain.
  • Axonal Dispersion is a Real Problem: The study strongly suggests that the complex arrangement of axons (dispersion) within white matter significantly impacts diameter estimation, as current models often assume perfect alignment.
  • Low b-values Can Be Tricky: While discarding low b-value data showed a trend towards improvement, it wasn't statistically significant, indicating that the interplay of b-values, SNR, and model complexity is nuanced.

Key Results

  • Gradient Strength Impact: Axon diameter indices were significantly lower with the ultra-high gradient (1350 mT/m) compared to the high gradient (300 mT/m). The lower bound for detectable axon diameters shifted from ~3 µm to ~2 µm with the higher gradient.
  • ActiveAx-D Performance: ActiveAx-D provided significantly more sensitive and stable estimates of axon diameter indices compared to conventional ActiveAx, especially with higher b-value datasets.
  • EM Validation: EM-derived mean axon diameters for the entire corpus callosum were around 0.56 µm. The dMRI estimates, even with the best protocols, had a lower bound of approximately 1.8 µm, indicating an overestimation of at least 0.6 µm.
  • Axonal Dispersion Correlation: Fractional anisotropy (FA) and orientation dispersion index (ODI) showed significant correlations with axon diameter estimates, suggesting that these measures of white matter complexity influence the results.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Overestimation: The persistent overestimation of axon diameter indices, even with the best protocols, remains a key limitation. The study suggests this is likely due to limitations in the PGSE sequence, the MMWMD model's simplicity (e.g., not accounting for permeability or complex extra-axonal structures), and axonal dispersion.
  • SNR Trade-off: While high gradient strengths are beneficial, they often come with lower Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNR), especially at very high b-values. This trade-off limits achievable sensitivity.
  • Time-Dependent Diffusion: The investigation into time-dependent extra-axonal diffusion was inconclusive due to insufficient b-value sampling. More dense sampling is needed for a definitive answer.
  • Model Complexity: The MMWMD model, while useful, doesn't capture all white matter complexities like unmyelinated axons, glial cells, or permeability.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose several avenues for future research:
  • Exploring oscillating gradient spin echo (OGSE) sequences, which might offer higher sensitivity to small pores.
  • Developing more advanced machine learning approaches for parameter extraction.
  • Incorporating more comprehensive tissue models that account for fibre dispersion and permeability, potentially using Monte Carlo simulations.
  • Improving SNR through acquisition setup modifications or post-processing techniques.

Summary updated

Abstract

Diffusion-weighted MRI is an important tool for in vivo and non-invasive axon morphometry. The ActiveAx technique utilises an optimised acquisition protocol to infer orientationally invariant indices of axon diameter and density by fitting a model of white matter to the acquired data. In this study, we investigated the factors that influence the sensitivity to small-diameter axons, namely the gradient strength of the acquisition protocol and the model fitting routine. Diffusion-weighted ex. vivo images of the mouse brain were acquired using 16.4-T MRI with high (Gmax of 300 mT/m) and ultra-high (Gmax of 1350 mT/m) gradient strength acquisitions. The estimated axon diameter indices of the mid-sagittal corpus callosum were validated using electron microscopy. In addition, a dictionary-based fitting routine was employed and evaluated. Axon diameter indices were closer to electron microscopy measures when higher gradient strengths were employed. Despite the improvement, estimated axon diameter indices (a lower bound of ~ 1.8 μm) remained higher than the measurements obtained using electron microscopy (~1.2 μm). We further observed that limitations of pulsed gradient spin echo (PGSE) acquisition sequences and axonal dispersion could also influence the sensitivity with which axon diameter indices could be estimated. Our results highlight the influence of acquisition protocol, tissue model and model fitting, in addition to gradient strength, on advanced microstructural diffusion-weighted imaging techniques. © 2016 The Authors. NMR in Biomedicine published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sepehrband2016towards,
  author = {Farshid Sepehrband and Daniel C. Alexander and Nyoman D. Kurniawan and David C. Reutens and Zhengyi Yang},
  title = {{Towards higher sensitivity and stability of axon diameter estimation with diffusion‐weighted MRI}},
  booktitle = {NMR},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1002/nbm.3462},
}
Figure