Towards Fair Conversational Recommender Systems

Allen Lin, Ziwei Zhu, Jianling Wang, James CaverleearXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Conversational Recommender Systems (CRSs) are often perceived as inherently fairer than traditional systems because they explicitly solicit user preferences through dialogue. However, this research demonstrates that CRSs remain deeply susceptible to systemic biases. By auditing state-of-the-art models, the authors identify critical dimensions of unfairness—specifically popularity bias, user preference assumption bias, and evaluation bias. The findings reveal that popular items are prioritized in recommendations and discovered faster than niche content, suggesting a need for a fundamental shift in how interactive recommendation systems are designed and audited.

Introduction

Traditional recommender systems are notorious for "popularity bias," where "hit" items are over-recommended at the expense of the "long tail" of niche content. CRSs were initially viewed as a potential solution; by engaging in multi-turn dialogues (e.g., "Do you like Jazz?"), these systems should theoretically provide perfectly tailored results. This paper challenges that assumption, arguing that underlying algorithms can remain skewed even with explicit user input. The authors propose a formal fairness framework to address how bias manifests in recommendation selection, conversational strategy, and success metrics.

Methodology

The study audits three state-of-the-art CRS models—SCPR, EAR, and CRM—using the Lastfm dataset, a benchmark for music artist recommendation. The analysis focuses on three primary lenses:

  1. Popularity Bias: Evaluating if popular items receive preferential exposure.
  2. Elicitation Bias: Proposing "User Preference Assumption Bias," where the system's questioning strategy favors certain attributes.
  3. Metric Critique: Analyzing how standard metrics like Success Rate (SR@t) can mask inequities between user groups.

Analyzing Bias in CRSs

The data-driven analysis reveals significant disparities in how models treat items based on their popularity.

The Exposure Gap and Success Rate

Even when a candidate pool of items matches a user's stated preferences, models show a strong preference for popular items. For instance, in the CRM model, the average popularity of recommended items was nearly eight times higher than that of the total candidate set. Furthermore, success rates are heavily correlated with popularity; in the EAR model, items in the top popularity quartile achieved over a 75% success rate, while niche items lagged significantly.

Figure 1: Analysis of CRS bias across three perspectives: (a) exposure rate, (b) success rate, and (c) conversational utility.

Conversational Utility Inequity

A key finding is the "fast-track" for popular items. In an unbiased system, the number of turns required to find an item should depend on its attributes, not its popularity. However, the authors found a sharp inverse correlation: as item popularity increases, the number of turns required to reach a recommendation drops significantly across all models. This suggests the system is more "impatient" or less efficient when helping users find niche content, creating a disparity in conversational utility.

Figure 2: Conversational utility: Number of user interactions needed vs. item popularity.

Discussion and Future Directions

This research highlights that transparency and interaction do not automatically guarantee fairness. While the paper focuses on identifying these systemic issues, it sets the stage for future work in several areas:

  • Mitigation Strategies: Determining if traditional de-biasing techniques (like re-ranking) are effective in conversational contexts or if the "policy agent" requires a fairness-centric overhaul.
  • Broader Bias Categories: Extending the analysis beyond popularity to include demographic biases such as gender, race, and age.
  • Refined Metrics: Developing new evaluation metrics that account for "per-user" fairness and utility rather than relying on global averages that can mask individual failures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Conversational recommender systems have demonstrated great success. They can accurately capture a user's current detailed preference -- through a multi-round interaction cycle -- to effectively guide users to a more personalized recommendation. Alas, conversational recommender systems can be plagued by the adverse effects of bias, much like traditional recommenders. In this work, we argue for increased attention on the presence of and methods for counteracting bias in these emerging systems. As a starting point, we propose three fundamental questions that should be deeply examined to enable fairness in conversational recommender systems.
BibTeX
@misc{lin2022towards,
  author = {Allen Lin and Ziwei Zhu and Jianling Wang and James Caverlee},
  title = {{Towards Fair Conversational Recommender Systems}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2208.03854},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.03854},
}
Figure