Towards Cost-effective Multi-style Conversations: A Pilot Study in Task-oriented Dialogue Generation

Tiziano Labruna, Bernardo MagniniCOLING 2024

TL;DR

This paper introduces a cost-effective method for generating task-oriented dialogues in multiple conversational styles, addressing the performance drop when models trained on a single style encounter new ones. By leveraging large language models and existing knowledge bases, they create new multi-style datasets that improve dialogue system robustness to stylistic variations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Task-oriented dialogue systems are designed to help users accomplish specific goals, like booking a restaurant. Traditionally, these systems are trained on dialogues exhibiting a single, often formal, conversational style. However, real-world interactions are far more varied, with users employing diverse linguistic styles. When a dialogue model trained on one style is used by someone with a different style, its performance can significantly degrade. This paper tackles the challenge of creating dialogue systems that are resilient to these stylistic variations without incurring the high cost of manually collecting diverse, multi-style datasets.

Methods

The core of the methodology is a cost-effective approach to generating multi-style task-oriented dialogues. It begins with a domain knowledge base (KB) that defines entities, slots, and their values. The process involves:

  1. KB Partitioning: The KB instances are clustered into independent groups, each intended for generating a single dialogue. This clustering aims to maximize similarity between instances within a cluster based on shared slot values, ensuring the dialogues remain focused on relevant content.
  2. LLM-based Generation: A large language model (LLM) is prompted to generate conversations. The prompt includes specifications for the desired dialogue format, conversational style (e.g., "friendly tone with an informal lexicon"), and the KB instances to guide the dialogue's content.
  3. Dialogue Annotation: The generated dialogues are then semantically annotated with dialogue acts and slot-value pairs. This process involves an initial LLM-based annotation followed by a crucial manual correction step to ensure accuracy and precision.

Datasets

The paper introduces new multi-style dialogue datasets and uses a well-established one for comparison:

  • MULTIWOZ 2.4: A human-collected, predominantly formal task-oriented dialogue dataset (Restaurant domain) used as a baseline.
  • NEUTRALGPT: An automatically generated dataset using GPT-3.5-TURBO, designed to mimic the neutral style of MULTIWOZ.
  • FRIENDLYGPT: Another automatically generated dataset using GPT-3.5-TURBO, simulating a friendly, informal conversational style between friends.
  • MULTISTYLEGPT: A novel dataset created by merging half of the MULTIWOZ and half of the FRIENDLYGPT datasets to provide a mixed-style training resource.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Single-style models are brittle: The experiments strongly suggest that dialogue models trained on a single style (like formal MULTIWOZ) perform poorly when tested on dialogues with a different style (like informal FRIENDLYGPT).
  • Multi-style data enhances robustness: Training models on datasets that incorporate multiple styles (like MULTISTYLEGPT) leads to improved performance and resilience when encountering diverse conversational styles.
  • LLMs are powerful but imperfect: While LLMs are effective for generating dialogues and initial annotations, they struggle with consistently adhering to complex instructions regarding format, dialogue acts, and slot-value detection, necessitating manual correction.
  • Cost-effectiveness is achievable: The proposed methodology offers a way to create diverse dialogue resources at a lower cost compared to manual collection, by leveraging existing KBs and LLMs.

Key Results

The paper presents results from training an RNNLG (Recurrent Neural Network Language Generation) model.

  • When trained on MULTIWOZ and tested on MULTIWOZ, the model achieved a BLEU score of 0.437 and a BARTScore of -4.388.
  • Testing the same MULTIWOZ-trained model on NEUTRALGPT resulted in a significant drop: BLEU of 0.184 and BARTScore of -4.841.
  • Training on NEUTRALGPT and testing on MULTIWOZ also showed poor performance (BLEU 0.088, BARTScore -5.465).
  • Using the MULTISTYLEGPT dataset for training and testing on MULTIWOZ or NEUTRALGPT showed improved performance compared to the single-style cross-dataset tests. For instance, MULTISTYLEGPT trained on MULTIWOZ yielded a BLEU of 0.340 and BARTScore of -4.443 when tested on MULTIWOZ, which is better than the 0.088 BLEU when trained on NEUTRALGPT and tested on MULTIWOZ.
  • The Pearson correlation coefficient between BLEU and BARTScore was 0.8195, indicating a strong positive correlation between these evaluation metrics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • LLM limitations: The authors acknowledge that LLMs, while powerful, have limitations in precisely following instructions for dialogue generation and annotation. Fine-tuning LLMs could potentially mitigate these issues.
  • Style fidelity: The generated styles, while distinct, might not fully capture the nuanced complexity of human conversational variations.
  • Evaluation metric limitations: Standard metrics like BLEU and BARTScore may not perfectly assess the quality and appropriateness of generated dialogues, especially concerning stylistic variations.
  • Future work: The authors suggest further research to address these limitations, aiming for a more comprehensive understanding of stylistic variations in task-oriented dialogues. This could involve exploring more advanced LLM fine-tuning techniques and developing more nuanced evaluation methods.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{labruna2024towards,
  author = {Tiziano Labruna and Bernardo Magnini},
  title = {{Towards Cost-effective Multi-style Conversations: A Pilot Study in Task-oriented Dialogue Generation}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure