Towards closed strings as single-valued open strings at genus one

Jan E. Gerken, Axel Kleinschmidt, Carlos R. Mafra, Oliver Schlotterer, Bram VerbeekJournal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an "elliptic single-valued map" that connects mathematical objects appearing in open-string scattering amplitudes (elliptic multiple zeta values) to those in closed-string amplitudes (modular graph forms) at genus one. This map provides a unified framework for understanding these seemingly disparate mathematical structures in string theory.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In string theory, calculating scattering amplitudes involves integrating over complex mathematical spaces. At genus one (a specific type of surface in string theory calculations), these integrals lead to two distinct families of mathematical objects: elliptic multiple zeta values (eMZVs) for open strings and modular graph forms (MGFs) for closed strings. While a similar connection, a "single-valued map," exists at genus zero (tree-level amplitudes), a clear and consistent connection at genus one has been elusive. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing and providing evidence for an "elliptic single-valued map" that relates these genus-one objects.

Methods

The authors leverage the a'-expansion (an expansion in terms of the inverse string tension) of both open- and closed-string integrals. They analyze the differential equations that govern these integrals and their behavior in degeneration limits (specifically, as the torus approaches a cusp). By comparing these properties, they identify formal substitution rules that map eMZVs to MGFs. A key technique involves constructing new generating series for open- and closed-string integrals, denoted as $B$ and $J$ respectively, which are designed to be more amenable to this comparison. They also utilize iterated Eisenstein integrals as a common language to express both eMZVs and MGFs.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Elliptic Single-Valued Map": The core contribution is the proposal of a map that connects eMZVs (from open strings) to MGFs (from closed strings) at genus one. This generalizes the known genus-zero single-valued map for multiple zeta values.
  • Differential Equations as a Bridge: The authors found that the differential equations governing the open- and closed-string integrals, while similar, have subtle differences related to the $\tau$ and $\bar{\tau}$ dependence. These differences are crucial for defining the single-valued map.
  • Degeneration Limits Reveal Connections: By studying how these integrals behave as the torus degenerates (approaches a cusp), the authors found connections to simpler, genus-zero objects (Parke-Taylor factors), providing further evidence for their proposed map.
  • New Generating Series ($B$ and $J$): The introduction of specific generating series $B$ and $J$ for open and closed strings, respectively, proved essential for making the comparison and defining the map.
  • Modular Graph Forms as Single-Valued eMZVs: The paper suggests that MGFs can be viewed as single-valued versions of eMZVs, solidifying the proposed map.

Key Results

  • The paper proposes a formal substitution rule, the "elliptic single-valued map," that relates eMZVs to MGFs at genus one.
  • This map is shown to be consistent with the differential equations governing the generating series of open- and closed-string integrals.
  • The map is also consistent with the degeneration limits of these integrals, connecting them to genus-zero structures.
  • Explicit examples of the map are provided for two-point and three-point amplitudes, demonstrating its application.
  • The paper establishes a framework for expressing eMZVs in terms of modular graph forms, and vice versa, at genus one.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conjectural Nature: While strong evidence is presented, the proposed map relies on certain conjectures, particularly regarding the relationship between initial values at the cusp and the single-valued map of multiple zeta values. Rigorous mathematical proofs for all aspects are still needed.
  • Antiholomorphic Contributions: The precise determination of certain antiholomorphic admixtures in the SV map on iterated Eisenstein integrals at higher depths requires further investigation.
  • Higher Genus: The paper suggests that extending these ideas to higher-genus string amplitudes is a promising direction for future research.
  • Loop-Level KLT Relations: The authors propose exploring a connection to loop-level Koba-Nielsen-Tye (KLT) relations, which could provide a new perspective on the problem.
  • Mathematical Rigor: The authors explicitly state the need for mathematically rigorous proofs for several of their findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We relate the low-energy expansions of world-sheet integrals in genus-one amplitudes of open- and closed-string states. The respective expansion coefficients are elliptic multiple zeta values (eMZVs) in the open-string case and non-holomorphic modular forms dubbed ‘modular graph forms (MGFs)’ for closed strings. By inspecting the differential equations and degeneration limits of suitable generating series of genus-one integrals, we identify formal substitution rules mapping the eMZVs of open strings to the MGFs of closed strings. Based on the properties of these rules, we refer to them as an elliptic single-valued map which generalizes the genus-zero notion of a single-valued map acting on MZVs seen in tree-level relations between the open and closed string.
BibTeX
@article{gerken2021towards,
  author = {Jan E. Gerken and Axel Kleinschmidt and Carlos R. Mafra and Oliver Schlotterer and Bram Verbeek},
  title = {{Towards closed strings as single-valued open strings at genus one}},
  journal = {Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1088/1751-8121/abe58b},
}

Loading related content...

Figure