Towards Circular Fashion: Design for Community-Based Clothing Reuse and Upcycling Services under a Social Innovation Perspective

Duan Wu, Mingyu Zhuang, Xinni Zhang, Yuheng ZhaoSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of scaling up clothing reuse and upcycling in the fashion industry by proposing a community-based service network design. It leverages social innovation principles to overcome technical and cultural barriers, aiming to foster a more collaborative and sustainable fashion ecosystem.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The fashion industry has historically operated on a linear "take-make-dispose" model, leading to significant environmental pollution and resource depletion. While circular economy principles like reuse and upcycling offer a sustainable alternative, their widespread adoption is hindered by technical challenges (e.g., lack of infrastructure) and cultural barriers (e.g., low consumer acceptance of second-hand items). This paper addresses the critical need to move these practices from niche activities to mainstream solutions, particularly within the context of China, by exploring how community-based interventions can effectively bridge these gaps.

Methods

The research employs a multi-phase approach rooted in Design for Social Innovation (DfSI).

  • Phase 1: Participant Research: This involved extensive field research, expert interviews with local tailors, and user interviews with community residents in Shanghai. The goal was to understand existing practices, perceptions, needs, and barriers related to clothing reuse and upcycling.
  • Phase 2: Design Prototyping: Based on Phase 1 findings, the researchers developed tangible prototypes for community-based services. This included the "Upcycling Case" (a portable toolkit for tailoring and repair) and the "Upcycling Bike" (a mobile station for upcycling activities). Participatory workshops were then conducted with community members, tailors, and designers to test these prototypes and gather feedback.
  • Phase 3: Developing Community-Based Services: This phase focused on designing a comprehensive service network and an online platform. The service network aims to connect various stakeholders (residents, tailors, hobbyists, schools, brands, NGOs) for collaborative reuse and upcycling. The online platform is envisioned to facilitate service reservations, provide educational content, and foster community exchange.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention the use of pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it relies on primary data collected through:

  • Field research: Observations of local tailors and community environments.
  • Expert interviews: Discussions with local tailors.
  • User interviews: Conversations with community residents.
  • Participatory workshops: Hands-on activities and discussions with a mix of participants.
  • Desk research: Review of existing literature and reports on clothing reuse and upcycling in Shanghai.

A key piece of secondary data referenced is a study by Liu et al. [46] on the current situation of recycling unwanted clothes in Shanghai, which provided insights into resident behaviors and awareness.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "community tailor" as a vital, yet endangered, resource: Traditional tailors possess essential skills and community trust but are hampered by limited financial resources and a lack of modern business adaptation. Revitalizing their role is crucial for scaling up reuse and upcycling.
  • The "awareness-action gap" is significant: While many Shanghai residents acknowledge the importance of clothing recycling, their actual behaviors often fall short, indicating a need for more accessible and integrated solutions.
  • Social innovation is key to overcoming barriers: DfSI, with its focus on problem-solving and sense-making, is uniquely positioned to address the intertwined technical and cultural challenges of scaling up circular fashion.
  • Tangible tools foster engagement: The "Upcycling Case" and "Upcycling Bike" prototypes demonstrated the potential for practical, mobile infrastructure to facilitate community participation in reuse and upcycling activities.
  • Community-based networks are powerful enablers: Connecting residents, tailors, and other stakeholders through a collaborative network can create a self-sustaining ecosystem for circular fashion, reducing individual burdens and fostering a sense of shared responsibility.

Key Results

The research successfully identified key barriers and opportunities for scaling up clothing reuse and upcycling in Shanghai.

  • Tailor insights: Traditional tailors are skilled and trusted but face financial limitations and a decline in new apprentices. They are open to new service models that can enhance their business.
  • Resident insights: A significant portion of residents dispose of clothes rather than reuse or upcycle them, despite awareness of sustainability benefits. They express a desire for convenient and accessible services.
  • Workshop outcomes: Participatory workshops showed high levels of collaboration and a positive sense of community belonging. Participants demonstrated increased engagement with reuse and upcycling, with some developing into "DIY hobbyists" and even assisting in future workshops.
  • Service network proposal: The paper proposes a "community-based service network" that integrates physical tools (Upcycling Case, Upcycling Bike), an online platform, and a collaborative structure involving various community actors. This model aims to enhance collaboration and cocreation, demonstrating a significant advancement over traditional community service models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pandemic impact: The research was conducted during the COVID-19 pandemic, which limited the depth of user and expert interviews and potentially affected the scope of field research.
  • Prototype stage: The proposed design concepts (service network, online platform) are still in the conceptual and preparation stages and have not yet been fully implemented or tested in a real-world, scaled-up scenario.
  • Future research directions: The authors suggest future work should focus on evaluating the effectiveness of the proposed service network. Additionally, conducting experiments in different regional and cultural contexts is recommended to test the broader applicability of the DfSI approach for promoting clothing reuse and upcycling globally.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rise of the circular economy, recycling, and upcycling is an emerging sustainable system in the fashion industry, emphasising a closed loop of “design, produce, use, and recycle”. In this context, this paper will explore community-based approaches to scale up clothing reuse and upcycling under a social innovation perspective. This study aims to establish community-based practice models, which contribute toward promoting a greater understanding of sustainable fashion and achieving collaborative cocreation frameworks for community stakeholders. This paper, therefore, takes a social innovation perspective to conduct design studies helping with the technical (problem-solving) and cultural (sense-making) barriers that clothing reuse and upcycling face. The research was conducted in the context of the Shanghai community, and a large amount of first-hand research data were obtained through field research, expert and user interviews, and participatory workshops. Finally, this research establishes a platform proposal which combines strategic service design and practical toolkit design. It is a new community-based service model highlighting a significant advancement in the degree of collaboration and cocreation in traditional community service models. Additionally, it dramatically demonstrates the potential of socially innovative design thinking in promoting circular fashion and the closed-loop fashion system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2022towards,
  author = {Duan Wu and Mingyu Zhuang and Xinni Zhang and Yuheng Zhao},
  title = {{Towards Circular Fashion: Design for Community-Based Clothing Reuse and Upcycling Services under a Social Innovation Perspective}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su15010262},
}

Loading related content...

Figure