Towards Architecture-Agnostic Neural Transfer: a Knowledge-Enhanced Approach

Seán Quinn, Alessandra MileoIJCAI 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel approach to "architecture-agnostic neural transfer" by developing mechanisms for extracting and injecting prior knowledge into neural networks. The goal is to enable neural networks to learn new tasks more efficiently and robustly, mimicking human-like learning by leveraging and reusing knowledge across different domains and architectures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) excel at learning complex patterns from vast amounts of data, effectively acting as powerful feature extractors. However, they often lack the ability to easily access, represent, and reuse the underlying conceptual structure they learn. This makes it difficult for them to transfer knowledge to new tasks efficiently, unlike humans who build conceptual models and readily apply prior knowledge. Existing neural transfer methods often involve directly copying network layers, which is architecture-dependent. This paper addresses the challenge of creating a more flexible and generalizable form of neural transfer that is "architecture-agnostic," allowing knowledge to be shared between networks regardless of their specific design.

Methods

The core of the proposed approach lies in three key components:

  • Knowledge Extraction Algorithm: This mechanism aims to extract meaningful knowledge from a trained neural network. The paper mentions exploring different categories of extraction methods: decompositional (analyzing individual units), pedagogical (treating the network as a black box), and eclectic (combining both).
  • Knowledge Injection Algorithm: This component focuses on incorporating extracted or human-generated knowledge into a neural network. The authors propose an intermediate knowledge representation to facilitate this injection, moving away from direct layer transfer.
  • Intermediate Knowledge Representation: This serves as a common language or format for knowledge, allowing it to be transferred between different neural network architectures. The paper doesn't specify a single formalism but plans to explore and assess various existing knowledge representation formalisms for their suitability.

The authors' initial investigation involved using network dissection to identify semantically meaningful features in a trained network and then crafting propositional rules based on these features. These rules were then converted into a neural format and injected into another network.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Architecture-Agnostic Transfer is Key: The paper argues that true neural transfer should not be tied to specific network architectures. By using an intermediate knowledge representation, knowledge can be shared more broadly.
  • Bridging Symbolic and Connectionist Learning: The research aims to integrate structured, symbolic knowledge with the connectionist learning paradigm of neural networks, moving towards more human-like intelligence.
  • Knowledge as a Reusable Asset: The vision is to create neural networks that can not only learn but also characterize and reuse knowledge, leading to more robust and explainable AI.
  • Human-like Learning: The ultimate goal is to imbue ANNs with properties similar to human learning, such as building conceptual models and leveraging background knowledge across tasks.

Key Results

The paper describes an initial investigation where knowledge injection was performed using network dissection and propositional rules. This mechanism was found to be functional but impractical due to the need for significant training to identify meaningful features and the manual effort required for rule crafting. The authors state that this initial work demonstrated the feasibility of the concept but highlighted the need for more automated and generalizable approaches.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The initial investigation into knowledge injection was found to be impractical due to manual feature identification and rule crafting. * The current approach is focused on classification tasks.

Future Work: * The research will focus on graph-based knowledge representation formalisms. * Exploration of probabilistic graphical models, graph convolutional networks, and statistical relational learning techniques. * Comparing and assessing the suitability of various knowledge formalisms for their properties (correctness, expressivity, complexity). * Evaluating the methods by contrasting the performance and accuracy of knowledge-enhanced networks with baseline networks trained on data alone, considering both maximum data scenarios and varying data amounts.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{quinn2019towards,
  author = {Seán Quinn and Alessandra Mileo},
  title = {{Towards Architecture-Agnostic Neural Transfer: a Knowledge-Enhanced Approach}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2019/915},
}
Figure