Towards a Unified Framework for Adaptable Problematic Content Detection via Continual Learning

Ali Omrani, Alireza Salkhordeh Ziabari, Preni Golazizian, Jeffrey Sorensen, Morteza DehghaniNAACL 2024

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel continual learning framework and benchmark for detecting problematic content online. By integrating diverse, evolving datasets and prioritizing adaptability over task-specific performance, their approach significantly outperforms static methods in handling new and changing forms of harmful language.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Detecting problematic content like hate speech, toxicity, and bias is a constant challenge because the nature of such content is inherently dynamic. It evolves with social dynamics, user populations, and cultural contexts, leading to new forms of expression and subtle shifts in meaning. Existing research often relies on static datasets, creating fragmented knowledge and making it difficult to build models that can adapt to these changes. This heterogeneity also hinders progress reporting, as different resources capture different facets of the problem. The authors aim to bridge this gap by creating a unified framework that can continuously learn and adapt to the ever-changing landscape of problematic content.

Methods

The core of this paper is a continual learning (CL) framework designed to address the dynamic nature of problematic content. Instead of training on a fixed dataset, their approach treats incoming data as a stream of related tasks.

Key methodological components include:

  • Upstream Training: The model is sequentially trained on a series of "upstream" tasks, mimicking the continuous influx of new data and evolving definitions of problematic content. This stage focuses on accumulating knowledge from diverse sources and time periods.
  • Downstream Few-Shot Evaluation: After upstream training, the model's ability to quickly adapt to new, unseen tasks with very limited data (few-shot learning) is evaluated. This is crucial for assessing adaptability to novel forms of problematic content.
  • Benchmark Design: They introduce a benchmark comprising 84 related tasks derived from 15 annotation schemas across 8 diverse data sources. This benchmark prioritizes a model's ability to adapt to evolving tasks over excelling in any single task.
  • Models: They experiment with different CL techniques, including regularization-based methods like BiHNet-Reg and BiHNet-EWC, and compare them against baselines like single-task learning and multitask learning.

Datasets

The benchmark integrates data from 8 different sources, including:

  • Twitter
  • Reddit
  • Wikipedia
  • Gab
  • Stromfront
  • Chat dialogues
  • Synthetically generated text
  • Civil Comments

These datasets span a wide range of problematic content definitions, from specific types like sexism and misogyny to broader categories like toxicity and offensive language. The authors emphasize that all datasets are publicly available and provide instructions for recreating the benchmark.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Adaptability is Key: The paper strongly advocates for prioritizing a model's ability to adapt to new and evolving forms of problematic content over simply achieving high performance on existing, static tasks.
  • Continual Learning is Crucial: Static models struggle with the dynamic nature of online discourse. Continual learning offers a promising path to build more robust and adaptable detection systems.
  • Task Order Matters (but not too much for robust models): While the sequence of tasks can influence performance, the authors found that their proposed BiHNet-Reg model demonstrates remarkable robustness to different task orderings, suggesting its suitability for real-world, unpredictable scenarios.
  • Few-Shot Learning is a Strong Indicator of Adaptability: The ability to learn new tasks with minimal examples is a critical measure of a model's capacity to handle emerging problematic content.

Key Results

  • Significant Performance Gains: Continual learning methods, particularly BiHNet-Reg, outperformed static approaches by up to 17% and 4% AUC in capturing evolving content and adapting to novel forms.
  • Mitigating Catastrophic Forgetting: BiHNet-Reg showed strong knowledge retention, falling only slightly short of the multitask learning upper bound.
  • Positive Transfer: While the immediate performance boost from upstream training on new tasks was found to be negligible, the overall upstream training significantly improved generalization ability.
  • Robustness to Task Order: BiHNet-Reg demonstrated stable performance across different upstream task orderings (chronological, random), highlighting its practical utility.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Language Limitation: The current benchmark is limited to English language content. The authors note that their formulation allows for easy expansion to other languages.
  • Dataset Diversity: While diverse, the benchmark relies on majority label datasets, which could introduce bias and overgeneralization due to the inherent subjectivity of problematic content. Future work could explore this subjectivity within their CL framework.
  • Experimental Scope: The experiments focused on specific CL algorithms. Future research could explore other CL approaches.
  • Potential for Misuse: The authors acknowledge the possibility of misuse, such as training models to generate problematic content or designing adversarial attacks. They emphasize that their open-access approach fosters transparency and accountability, contrasting with proprietary methods.
  • Bias Mitigation: Future work could investigate the influence of biases in datasets on model performance and explore bias mitigation techniques within the CL framework.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{omrani2024towards,
  author = {Ali Omrani and Alireza Salkhordeh Ziabari and Preni Golazizian and Jeffrey Sorensen and Morteza Dehghani},
  title = {{Towards a Unified Framework for Adaptable Problematic Content Detection via Continual Learning}},
  booktitle = {Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure