Toward the Evolution of National Spatial Data Infrastructure Development in Indonesia

Tandang Yuliadi Dwi Putra, Yoshihide Sekimoto, Ryosuke ShibasakiIsprs Int. J. geo inf 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the evolution and challenges of Indonesia's National Spatial Data Infrastructure (NSDI), highlighting issues with stakeholder participation, data availability, and technical resources. It proposes strategic directions for effective NSDI development by examining stakeholder relationships and cost structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing a robust National Spatial Data Infrastructure (NSDI) is crucial for national development, facilitating data sharing and reuse across various sectors. However, many countries, including Indonesia, have faced significant implementation challenges despite early adoption of NSDI concepts. These challenges include insufficient stakeholder engagement, limited availability of detailed geospatial data (especially large-scale maps), and inadequate technological and human resources. This paper aims to understand the historical development of Indonesia's NSDI, identify the root causes of its implementation difficulties, and propose strategic directions for its future evolution.

Methods

The study employed a mixed-methods approach:

  • Documentary Analysis: To trace the historical evolution of Indonesia's NSDI through different periods, characterized by technological changes in data management.
  • Semi-structured Interviews: Conducted with 18 stakeholder representatives from government, private, and academic sectors to gather insights into their perspectives on NSDI development and its problems.
  • Stakeholder Analysis: Utilized a power-interest grid and an actor-linkage matrix to categorize stakeholders, understand their influence and interests, and map their interrelationships. This analysis also incorporated elements like geospatial data provision, technological infrastructure, financial resources, and human capacity.
  • Questionnaire Surveys: Distributed to 46 respondents to collect quantitative data on stakeholder capabilities across the four identified features.
  • Cost Analysis: Examined existing NSDI cost components and estimated the cost of producing large-scale topographic maps to understand financial aspects and identify potential efficiencies.
  • SWOT Analysis: Synthesized findings from the previous analyses to identify Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats of NSDI implementation in Indonesia, informing strategic recommendations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on existing government documents, interview data, and survey responses rather than specific geospatial datasets for analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Evolutionary Stages: Indonesia's NSDI development can be categorized into three distinct periods: Centralized Data (1991-2000), Distributed System (2001-2010), and Open Initiative (2011-present), each marked by technological shifts.
  • Root Causes of Problems: Low stakeholder participation is primarily driven by insufficient technological, financial, and human resources, rather than a lack of interest.
  • Stakeholder Dynamics: The power-interest grid reveals that while government agencies are "key players" with high interest and influence, private sectors and citizens are largely "subjects" or "crowd" with limited influence.
  • Resource Gaps: BIG and central government agencies possess strong resources, but local governments and other stakeholders face significant limitations in data, technology, human capacity, and funding.
  • Costly Mapping: The production of large-scale topographic maps (1:5,000) is extremely expensive, with an estimated nationwide budget of $2.99 billion USD, suggesting a need for more efficient production methods.
  • Top-Down Approach: Indonesia's NSDI initiative is largely top-down, driven by national policy, which, while providing a legal framework, can sometimes lead to coordination challenges and limited private sector involvement.

Key Results

  • Stakeholder Identification: 15 key stakeholders were identified, including government bodies (BIG, central agencies, provincial, municipal/district governments), state institutions, national police, armed forces, and private sector entities (surveying, application developers, software providers), as well as academia and citizens.
  • Resource Assessment: BIG and central government agencies scored highest across all four assessed features (data provision, technological infrastructure, human capacity, financial resource), while state institutions, national police, and citizens scored lowest.
  • Connection Patterns: BIG exhibits strong relationships with central and local government agencies. Private sector connections are primarily limited to mapping projects, with limited collaboration with geospatial application developers.
  • Cost Allocation: Approximately 80% of the annual NSDI budget is allocated to geospatial data provision, with capacity building receiving a disproportionately low share (2%).
  • Mapping Cost: The estimated cost for producing 58 mapsheets of 1:5,000 scale topographic maps in Cibinong District was $463,300 USD, or $7,988 USD per mapsheet.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The study acknowledges that the top-down approach, while legally mandated, can hinder active stakeholder participation. The analysis of private sector involvement is limited, with a lack of commercial producers directly contributing to NSDI. The cost analysis for large-scale maps is based on specific assumptions and a single district.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest increasing the budget for research and development to adopt emerging technologies (e.g., high-resolution satellite imagery, drones) for more efficient data production. They recommend establishing an NSDI committee to improve coordination and minimize conflicts. Developing a detailed NSDI grand design is crucial for clear objectives and measurement. Broadening the scope to accommodate active interactions among all stakeholders, including the private sector and geospatial communities, is also recommended. Further research could explore NSDI evolution in other countries to understand diverse stakeholder interactions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{putra2019toward,
  author = {Tandang Yuliadi Dwi Putra and Yoshihide Sekimoto and Ryosuke Shibasaki},
  title = {{Toward the Evolution of National Spatial Data Infrastructure Development in Indonesia}},
  journal = {Isprs Int. J. geo inf},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi8060263},
}
Figure