Toward Physically Unclonable Functions from Plasmonics-Enhanced Silicon Disc Resonators

Johann Knechtel, Jacek Gosciniak, Alabi Bojesomo, Satwik Patnaik, Ozgur Sinanoglu, Mahmoud RasrasarXiv 2019 · DOI · OpenReview

Abstract: The omnipresent digitalization trend has enabled a number of related malicious activities, ranging from data theft to disruption of businesses, counterfeiting of devices, and identity fraud, among others. Hence, it is essential to implement security schemes and to ensure the reliability and trustworthiness of electronic circuits. Toward this end, the concept of physically unclonable functions (PUFs) has been established at the beginning of the 21st century. However, most PUFs have eventually, at least partially, fallen short of their promises, which are unpredictability, unclonability, uniqueness, reproducibility, and tamper resilience. That is because most PUFs directly utilize the underlying microelectronics, but that intrinsic randomness can be limited and may thus be predicted, especially by machine learning. Optical PUFs, in contrast, are still considered as promising—they can derive strong, hard-to-predict randomness independently from microelectronics, by using some kind of "optical token." Here we propose a novel concept for plasmonics-enhanced optical PUFs, or peo-PUFs in short. For the first time, we leverage two highly nonlinear phenomena in conjunction by construction: (i) light propagation in a silicon disk resonator, and (ii) surface plasmons arising from nanoparticles arranged randomly on top of the resonator. We elaborate on the physical phenomena, provide simulation results, and conduct a security analysis of peo-PUFs for secure key generation and authentication. This study highlights the good potential of peo-PUFs, and our future work is to focus on fabrication and characterization of such PUFs.

Introduction

As hardware security becomes a cornerstone of modern digital infrastructure, Physically Unclonable Functions (PUFs) have emerged as a vital tool for creating unique, tamper-resistant identifiers for integrated circuits. However, traditional electronic PUFs (e.g., SRAM-based) are increasingly vulnerable to machine learning (ML) attacks that can model and predict their responses. This paper introduces peo-PUFs (plasmonics-enhanced optical PUFs), a novel architecture that combines silicon photonics and plasmonics to create a high-entropy "digital fingerprint" that is computationally infeasible to clone.

The peo-PUF Architecture

The peo-PUF leverages the complex interaction between two nonlinear physical phenomena to ensure security:

  1. Silicon Disc Resonators (SDRs): These micrometer-scale cavities enhance light intensity, triggering nonlinear effects such as the Kerr effect and two-photon absorption.
  2. Surface Plasmons: Metallic nanoparticles (NPs) are randomly deposited on the SDR via a stochastic sputtering process. These particles trigger Localized Surface Plasmon Resonance (LSPR), scattering light in highly complex, sub-wavelength patterns.
Schematic of the peo-PUF system showing the challenge-response mechanism and the 3D model of the silicon disc resonator with random nanoparticles.

Because the nanoparticle arrangement is naturally random and unique to every chip, the resulting optical signature serves as a one-way function that is resistant to modeling.

Simulation and Validation

The researchers validated the concept using high-fidelity physics simulations (Lumerical FDTD and COMSOL FEM) across 18 different configurations. These tests explored variations in resonator size, nanoparticle materials (such as Gold and Titanium Nitride), and environmental conditions like temperature.

Simulated electric field distributions illustrating the complex, nonlinear interactions between light and various nanoparticle configurations on the resonator.

The simulations revealed that Titanium Nitride (TiN) offers a broader extinction efficiency than standard gold, potentially providing more complex fingerprints. Furthermore, the system demonstrated extreme sensitivity to nanoparticle positioning, which is critical for uniqueness, while maintaining stability through correlation-based helper data algorithms.

Security Performance and Results

The peo-PUF was evaluated using the NIST Statistical Test Suite and Fractional Hamming Distance (FHD) metrics:

  • High Randomness: Simulated keys achieved a mean entropy of >0.987, passing standard NIST tests for frequency and runs.
  • Uniqueness: The inter-FHD (the difference between two different PUFs) centered around 0.5, the ideal value for distinguishing unique devices.
  • Robustness: The system remained reliable under environmental noise and temperature shifts (300K to 350K), ensuring that valid chips can be consistently authenticated.

Conclusion

By merging the nonlinearities of silicon disc resonators with the stochastic nature of plasmonic nanoparticles, peo-PUFs offer a promising path toward ML-resilient hardware security. While this study is simulation-based, it establishes a robust framework for future physical fabrication and monolithic integration of these optical tokens into standard CMOS manufacturing processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

The omnipresent digitalization trend has enabled a number of related malicious activities, ranging from data theft to disruption of businesses, counterfeiting of devices, and identity fraud, among others. Hence, it is essential to implement security schemes and to ensure the reliability and trustworthiness of electronic circuits. Toward this end, the concept of physically unclonable functions (PUFs) has been established at the beginning of the 21st century. However, most PUFs have eventually, at least partially, fallen short of their promises, which are unpredictability, unclonability, uniqueness, reproducibility, and tamper resilience. That is because most PUFs directly utilize the underlying microelectronics, but that intrinsic randomness can be limited and may thus be predicted, especially by machine learning. Optical PUFs, in contrast, are still considered as promising---they can derive strong, hard-to-predict randomness independently from microelectronics, by using some kind of "optical token." Here we propose a novel concept for plasmonics-enhanced optical PUFs, or peo-PUFs in short. For the first time, we leverage two highly nonlinear phenomena in conjunction by construction: (i) light propagation in a silicon disk resonator, and (ii) surface plasmons arising from nanoparticles arranged randomly on top of the resonator. We elaborate on the physical phenomena, provide simulation results, and conduct a security analysis of peo- PUFs for secure key generation and authentication. This study highlights the good potential of peo-PUFs, and our future work is to focus on fabrication and characterization of such PUFs.
BibTeX
@misc{knechtel2019toward,
  author = {Johann Knechtel and Jacek Gosciniak and Alabi Bojesomo and Satwik Patnaik and Ozgur Sinanoglu and Mahmoud Rasras},
  title = {{Toward Physically Unclonable Functions from Plasmonics-Enhanced Silicon Disc Resonators}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1907.13229},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.13229},
}
Figure