Toward a wave turbulence formulation of statistical nonlinear optics

Josselin Garnier, M. Lisak, Antonio PicozziJournal of the Optical Society of America B 2012 · DOI

Abstract: During this last decade, several remarkable phenomena inherent to the nonlinear propagation of incoherent optical waves have been reported in the literature. This article is aimed at providing a generalized wave turbulence kinetic formulation of random nonlinear waves governed by the nonlinear Schrödinger equation in the presence of a nonlocal or a noninstantaneous nonlinear response function. Depending on the amount of nonlocal (noninstantaneous) nonlinear interaction and the amount of inhomogeneous (nonstationary) statistics of the incoherent wave, different types of kinetic equations are obtained. In the spatial domain, when the incoherent wave exhibits fluctuations that are statistically homogeneous in space, the relevant kinetic equation is the wave turbulence (Hasselmann) kinetic equation. It describes, in particular, the process of optical wave thermalization to thermodynamic equilibrium, which slows down significantly as the interaction becomes highly nonlocal. When the incoherent wave is characterized by inhomogeneous statistical fluctuations, different forms of the Vlasov equation are derived, which depend on the amount of nonlocality in the system. This Vlasov approach describes, in particular, the processes of incoherent modulational instability and the formation of localized incoherent soliton structures. In the temporal domain, the noninstantaneous nonlinear response function is constrained by the causality condition. It turns out that the relevant kinetic equation has a form analogous to the weak Langmuir turbulence equation, which describes, in particular, the formation of nonlocalized spectral incoherent solitons. In the regime of a highly noninstantaneous nonlinear response and a stationary statistics of the incoherent wave, the weak Langmuir turbulence equation reduces to the Korteweg–de Vries equation. Conversely, in the regime of a highly noninstantaneous response in the presence of a nonstationary statistics, we derive a long-range Vlasov-like kinetic equation in the temporal domain, whose self-consistent potential is constrained by the causality condition. From a broader perspective, this work indicates that the wave turbulence theory may constitute the appropriate theoretical framework to formulate statistical nonlinear optics.

Introduction

In traditional nonlinear optics, research typically focuses on coherent light. However, many real-world systems involve "incoherent" or partially coherent fields—light that fluctuates randomly in space or time. While the linear propagation of such fields is well-understood through statistical optics, a complete "statistical nonlinear optics" has been missing.

The challenge lies in describing how these random waves evolve when the medium's response is either nonlocal (the refractive index at one point depends on the light intensity in the surrounding neighborhood) or noninstantaneous (the medium takes time to respond to the light). These conditions are common in photorefractive crystals, liquid crystals, and optical fibers. This work provides a rigorous mathematical framework that maps these complex physical scenarios to specific kinetic equations borrowed from plasma physics and gas kinetics.

Theoretical Methodology

The study utilizes the generalized Nonlinear Schrödinger (NLS) equation as its foundational model. To transition from a field-based description to a statistical one, several key techniques are employed:

  • Multiscale Expansion: Introducing small parameters representing the ratio between the coherence length of the light and the scale of its overall intensity variations.
  • Wigner-Moyal Transform: This allows for the definition of a "local spectrum" (a phase-space density of light) that evolves like a gas of quasi-particles.
  • Moment Closure: Assuming the field follows Gaussian statistics in the weakly nonlinear regime allows the infinite hierarchy of equations to be closed at the second or fourth order.
  • Causality Constraints: A critical component is enforcing the causality condition in the temporal domain, dictating that a medium cannot respond to a pulse before it arrives.

Key Insights

The Causality "Fork"

A striking finding is that the temporal and spatial domains are not perfectly analogous. Because time has a direction (causality), the kinetic equations for temporal fluctuations take the form of "weak Langmuir turbulence" equations, which behave differently than their spatial counterparts.

Thermalization and the Vlasov Gas

The research shows that as a medium becomes more nonlocal, the process of "thermalization"—where light relaxes into a disordered Rayleigh-Jeans equilibrium—slows down significantly. Furthermore, in regimes where light is statistically inhomogeneous (like a beam of finite size), it behaves like a plasma governed by the Vlasov equation. The light creates its own "potential well" and can trap itself, forming incoherent solitons.

Results and Validity Maps

The primary result is a categorization of kinetic equations based on the degree of nonlocality/noninstantaneity and the degree of statistical inhomogeneity.

Validity map for the spatial domain, categorizing kinetic regimes based on nonlocality and statistical inhomogeneity.

In the spatial domain, homogeneous and local interactions are described by the Hasselmann (Wave Turbulence) equation, leading to irreversible thermalization. In contrast, inhomogeneous and nonlocal interactions are governed by various forms of the Vlasov equation, leading to modulational instability and localized structures.

Validity map for the temporal domain, showing the emergence of Langmuir and KdV regimes due to causality.

In the temporal domain, noninstantaneous responses lead to the Weak Langmuir Turbulence equation, accounting for spectral red-shifts. In the limit of a highly noninstantaneous response with stationary statistics, the formulation simplifies to the famous Korteweg–de Vries (KdV) equation.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the current derivations rely on the assumption of Gaussian statistics (valid in the weakly nonlinear regime), future work aims to extend this framework to $\chi^{(2)}$ nonlinearities and explore the "short-range" Vlasov equation in the temporal domain. This unified framework indicates that wave turbulence theory constitutes the appropriate theoretical foundation for formulating statistical nonlinear optics.

Summary updated

Abstract

During this last decade, several remarkable phenomena inherent to the nonlinear propagation of incoherent optical waves have been reported in the literature. This article is aimed at providing a generalized wave turbulence kinetic formulation of random nonlinear waves governed by the nonlinear Schrödinger equation in the presence of a nonlocal or a noninstantaneous nonlinear response function. Depending on the amount of nonlocal (noninstantaneous) nonlinear interaction and the amount of inhomogeneous (nonstationary) statistics of the incoherent wave, different types of kinetic equations are obtained. In the spatial domain, when the incoherent wave exhibits fluctuations that are statistically homogeneous in space, the relevant kinetic equation is the wave turbulence (Hasselmann) kinetic equation. It describes, in particular, the process of optical wave thermalization to thermodynamic equilibrium, which slows down significantly as the interaction becomes highly nonlocal. When the incoherent wave is characterized by inhomogeneous statistical fluctuations, different forms of the Vlasov equation are derived, which depend on the amount of nonlocality in the system. This Vlasov approach describes, in particular, the processes of incoherent modulational instability and the formation of localized incoherent soliton structures. In the temporal domain, the noninstantaneous nonlinear response function is constrained by the causality condition. It turns out that the relevant kinetic equation has a form analogous to the weak Langmuir turbulence equation, which describes, in particular, the formation of nonlocalized spectral incoherent solitons. In the regime of a highly noninstantaneous nonlinear response and a stationary statistics of the incoherent wave, the weak Langmuir turbulence equation reduces to the Korteweg–de Vries equation. Conversely, in the regime of a highly noninstantaneous response in the presence of a nonstationary statistics, we derive a long-range Vlasov-like kinetic equation in the temporal domain, whose self-consistent potential is constrained by the causality condition. From a broader perspective, this work indicates that the wave turbulence theory may constitute the appropriate theoretical framework to formulate statistical nonlinear optics.
BibTeX
@article{garnier2012toward,
  author = {Josselin Garnier and M. Lisak and Antonio Picozzi},
  title = {{Toward a wave turbulence formulation of statistical nonlinear optics}},
  journal = {Journal of the Optical Society of America B},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1364/josab.29.002229},
}
Figure