TL;DR
This study applies the Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA) model to evaluate tourist satisfaction at Shiqian Fodingshan Hot Spring Town in China. It reveals a significant "expectation-performance gap," where tourists prioritize therapeutic benefits and infrastructure but find the most satisfaction in cultural elements and the natural environment, highlighting critical areas for service optimization.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
As hot spring tourism evolves from a niche health activity into a mainstream leisure industry, destination competitiveness is increasingly tied to tourist satisfaction rather than just the presence of natural thermal springs. However, managers often struggle to identify which specific service attributes—ranging from water quality to parking convenience—actually drive visitor loyalty.
The author addresses this by investigating Shiqian Fodingshan Hot Spring Town, a major resort in Guizhou Province. The core challenge is the mismatch between what tourists expect (importance) and what they experience (performance). Without a structured way to visualize these gaps, resort operators risk misallocating resources—for example, over-investing in areas tourists don't care about while neglecting "make-or-break" facilities like parking or therapeutic efficacy.
Methods
The researcher employed the Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA) model, a standard but effective diagnostic tool in marketing and tourism research.
- Indicator System: The study established a two-tier evaluation system. Four primary dimensions (Hot Spring Resources, Service Quality, Supporting Facilities, and Cultural Value) were broken down into 15 secondary indicators (e.g., water temperature, staff expertise, environmental hygiene).
- Data Collection: A Likert-scale questionnaire was distributed via the "Questionnaire Star" platform, yielding 223 valid responses.
- The IPA Matrix: The results were plotted onto a four-quadrant matrix:
- Advantage Zone (High I/High P): Strengths to maintain.
- Improvement Zone (High I/Low P): Critical weaknesses requiring immediate attention.
- Opportunity Zone (Low I/Low P): Low priority for investment.
- Maintenance Zone (Low I/High P): Areas where the resort is "over-delivering" relative to importance.
- IPAI Index: The study also calculated an Importance-Performance Analysis Index (IPAI) to quantify the degree of dissatisfaction, where higher scores indicate greater gaps between expectation and reality.
Datasets
The study relies on a primary dataset of 223 valid survey responses from tourists who visited Shiqian Fodingshan Hot Spring Town.
- Demographics: The sample was predominantly female (57.39%), young (61.43% aged 18–30), and highly educated (68.5% with college degrees or higher).
- Behavioral Data: Most visitors were first-timers (69.51%) from within Guizhou Province, influenced heavily by social media platforms like Weibo and Xiaohongshu.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Expectation Paradox: Tourists ranked infrastructure and facilities as the most important factors (Mean = 4.155), yet these areas underperformed. Conversely, cultural value was ranked as the least important pre-visit but delivered the highest actual satisfaction (Mean = 3.813).
- The "One-and-Done" Risk: High first-time visitation driven by social media, coupled with low repeat visit rates, suggests that while the marketing is effective, the on-site experience isn't yet compelling enough to build long-term loyalty.
- Hidden Strengths: The "rest and relaxation environment" was the only indicator where performance actually exceeded expectations (I-P = -0.01), suggesting the natural setting is a powerful, perhaps under-marketed, asset.
- Service Professionalism Gap: While tourists were satisfied with staff attitude, they were dissatisfied with staff expertise and efficiency. This distinguishes between "being nice" and "being competent."
Key Results
- Critical Weaknesses (Improvement Zone): Five indicators fell into the high-importance/low-performance quadrant: water quality (a1), therapeutic effects (a2), staff expertise (b1), service efficiency (b3), and parking convenience (c2).
- The Biggest Gap: "Therapeutic effects" showed the largest discrepancy (I-P = 0.68) and the highest dissatisfaction index (IPAI = 16.59), categorized as "Very Dissatisfied."
- Core Competencies (Advantage Zone): The resort excels in pool variety (a4), staff attitude (b2), catering (c1), hygiene (c3), and transportation accessibility (c4).
- Cultural Dominance: Folk customs (d1) and the relaxation environment (d2) were rated "Very Satisfied," despite being lower on the initial importance scale.
Limitations and Future Work
The author acknowledges three primary limitations:
- Sample Bias: The data skewed toward younger students due to the online collection method, potentially overlooking the perspectives of older "silver hair" tourists who are a traditional demographic for hot springs.
- Subjectivity: The study relies entirely on tourist perception. Future research could integrate objective data, such as chemical water quality testing or physiological health markers, to validate "therapeutic efficacy."
- Scope: As a single-case study, the results may not be generalizable to all hot spring resorts. The author suggests future work should compare multiple destinations to identify broader industry trends.
Summary updated