Tourism Knowledge Domains of Chinese and International Research

Yi-Jing Su, Cong Li, Geoffrey WallSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study maps the knowledge domains of Chinese and international tourism research by analyzing keywords from leading journals between 2012 and 2021. It reveals that while China is a major focus for international research, Chinese research is catching up, though international studies tend to be more in-depth and cutting-edge, particularly in methodology and theoretical application.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The tourism academic landscape is rapidly evolving, influenced by global events like the COVID-19 pandemic and China's growing prominence in the global tourism market. While numerous studies have analyzed tourism research trends, there's a need for a direct, comparative analysis of the knowledge domains of Chinese and international research. This paper aims to bridge this gap by systematically comparing the characteristics, themes, methods, and disciplines of tourism research originating from China versus the rest of the world, identifying similarities, differences, and potential areas for future development.

Methods

The authors employed a bibliometric approach, focusing on author-selected keywords from a curated set of academic journals. They collected keywords from 4788 articles published between 2012 and 2021 in four authoritative journals: Annals of Tourism Research, Tourism Management, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, and Tourism Tribune. These keywords were then coded into four categories: "research areas," "research objects," "research methods," and "research disciplines." Statistical analyses were performed on the frequency, quantity, average frequency, and frequency variance of keywords within each category to understand the breadth, depth, and focus of research. Visualization tools like CiteSpace were also used to analyze temporal trends and emergent keywords.

Datasets

The study utilized keywords extracted from the following four academic journals:

  • Annals of Tourism Research
  • Tourism Management
  • Journal of Sustainable Tourism
  • Tourism Tribune

Data was collected for articles published between 2012 and 2021. The analysis included 3459 unique Chinese keywords (from 1204 articles) and 9128 unique English keywords (from 3584 articles).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • China as a Global Focus: China is the most frequently studied geographical region in international tourism research, highlighting its significant role in the global tourism landscape.
  • Methodological Divide: Chinese tourism research shows a less frequent application of qualitative methods compared to international research. However, the combination of qualitative and quantitative methods is emerging as a significant trend in both.
  • Depth and Breadth: International tourism research tends to be more in-depth and cutting-edge, particularly in terms of theoretical application and methodological sophistication.
  • Evolving Landscape: While Chinese tourism research started later, it has significantly improved in quality and international influence, with young scholars increasingly contributing to global discourse.
  • Discipline Focus: There are notable differences in the research disciplines that receive more attention in China versus internationally. For instance, Chinese research shows more focus on tourism psychology and public administration, while international research leans more towards tourism ecology and sustainable development.

Key Results

  • Keyword Volume: The analysis encompassed 3459 unique Chinese keywords and 9128 unique English keywords.
  • Average Frequency: International research keywords appeared more frequently on average (2.04 times) compared to Chinese research keywords (1.48 times), suggesting a greater depth in international studies.
  • Geographical Focus: In Chinese research, domestic locations are overwhelmingly the focus, with a strong emphasis on smaller spatial scales (local and city-level). International research, while also focusing on China, covers a broader range of countries and regions, with a greater emphasis on national-scale geographic spaces.
  • Methodological Trends: International research utilizes a wider variety of methods, with a more mature application of qualitative approaches. The combination of qualitative and quantitative methods is a significant trend in international research.
  • Thematic Differences: While both Chinese and international research share common themes like "destination image," the timing and depth of research differ. International research shows a stronger focus on "sustainable tourism development," "ecotourism," and "climate change."

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the selection of only four journals might limit the representativeness of the findings, as different journals have distinct focuses and research fields. Future work could involve expanding the scope to include more journals to provide a more comprehensive understanding of tourism knowledge domains. They also suggest that Chinese tourism research should continue to highlight its unique characteristics while also closely following international trends and strengthening the application of qualitative methods and the integration of international theories. Furthermore, there's a call to increase attention to tourism ecology and sustainable development, especially within the context of China's ecological civilization strategy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Tourism knowledge domain has always been one of the appealing topics in tourism academic circle. This paper extracted author-selected keywords from 4788 articles published from 2012 to 2021 in four authoritative journals: Annals of Tourism Research, Tourism Management, Journal of Sustainable Tourism and Tourism Tribune. These keywords were coded according to “research areas”, “research objects”, “research methods”, and “research disciplines”, and a statistical analysis was carried out regarding the frequency, quantity, average frequency, and frequency variance of each category of the keywords. A total of 3459 Chinese keywords and 9128 English keywords formed the basis of this analysis. According to the findings, China is the most frequently studied geographical region in the international tourism research. The application of qualitative methods in the Chinese tourism research is less frequent than that in the international research, and the combination of qualitative and quantitative methods has become an important trend in tourism research. The international tourism research on certain topics is more in-depth and cutting-edge than the Chinese tourism research.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{su2023tourism,
  author = {Yi-Jing Su and Cong Li and Geoffrey Wall},
  title = {{Tourism Knowledge Domains of Chinese and International Research}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15129151},
}
Figure