Tork: Conformational analysis method for molecules and complexes

Chia‐en A. Chang, Michael K. GilsonJournal of Computational Chemistry 2003 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Tork, a novel conformational search algorithm that efficiently explores the vast landscape of possible molecular shapes. By leveraging normal-mode analysis in internal coordinates and focusing on key torsional degrees of freedom, Tork significantly outperforms existing methods, particularly for complex molecules and host-guest systems, paving the way for more accurate molecular design and drug discovery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the three-dimensional shape (conformation) of molecules is crucial for predicting their behavior and designing new ones, especially in fields like drug discovery and materials science. Molecules aren't rigid; they can twist and bend into many different shapes, each with a unique energy. Finding all the stable, low-energy shapes (conformations) is a computationally challenging task known as conformational searching. Existing methods, like LMOD, often struggle with molecules that combine rigid rings with flexible chains, or with the even more complex problem of finding stable arrangements in molecular complexes (like a drug binding to a protein or a host molecule encapsulating a guest). These methods can be inefficient, miss important conformations, or require excessive computational resources.

Methods

Tork is a conformational search method that builds upon the concept of normal-mode analysis, a technique that identifies the natural vibrational modes of a molecule. However, Tork introduces several key innovations:

  • Internal Coordinates (BAT): Instead of using Cartesian coordinates (x, y, z for each atom), Tork uses Bond-Angle-Torsion (BAT) coordinates. This is a crucial difference because it allows for the direct representation of bond rotations (torsions) as smooth circular motions, avoiding the artificial bond stretching that can occur with Cartesian-based distortions.
  • Focus on Key Torsions: Tork doesn't analyze all possible internal degrees of freedom. Instead, it identifies a "key subset" of torsional coordinates that are most critical for determining the molecule's overall shape. This significantly reduces the computational complexity.
  • "Drivers" for Distortion: Normal modes are calculated based on the Hessian matrix (second derivatives of energy) with respect to these key torsions. These modes are then adjusted to create "drivers" that represent natural molecular motions.
  • Pairwise Combinations: New conformations are generated by distorting the molecule along these drivers, both individually and in pairwise combinations. The weighting of these combinations is based on the "force constants" of the drivers, meaning softer modes (those that require less energy to distort) are given more influence.
  • Special Treatment for Complexes: For bimolecular complexes, Tork specifically accounts for the six degrees of freedom that define the relative position and orientation of the two molecules.

Datasets

The paper evaluates Tork on a series of test cases, including:

  • n-Octane: An acyclic molecule.
  • Cyclononane: A moderately flexible cyclic molecule.
  • (-)-Menthol: A molecule with both cyclic and acyclic parts.
  • Cyclophane: A synthetic macrocyclic host molecule.
  • Cyclophane-Menthol Complex: A host-guest complex.

These systems were chosen to represent a range of structural complexities and are compared against existing methods and quenched molecular dynamics (QMD) for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BAT Coordinates are Key: The shift from Cartesian to BAT coordinates is a major improvement, enabling smoother and more realistic molecular distortions that directly lead to new low-energy conformations without artificial energy penalties.
  • Focusing on the "Important" Motions: By identifying and prioritizing key torsional degrees of freedom, Tork avoids getting bogged down in analyzing many trivial or unproductive molecular motions, leading to greater efficiency.
  • Host-Guest Systems are Tractable: Tork demonstrates significant success in exploring the conformational space of host-guest complexes, a problem that has been largely overlooked by previous conformational search methods. This opens doors for better understanding and designing molecular recognition events.
  • Factorizing Complexity: For molecules with both cyclic and acyclic parts, or for complexes, Tork's approach can be further optimized by "factorizing" the search, i.e., analyzing the ring and acyclic parts (or host and guest) separately, which can accelerate the process and reduce the generation of redundant conformations.

Key Results

Tork consistently outperformed LMOD (a previously state-of-the-art method) across various molecular systems:

  • n-Octane: Tork found significantly more conformations (129) than LMOD (95) with comparable computational effort.
  • Cyclononane: Tork identified all nine known local energy minima, while LMOD found only seven. Tork also demonstrated that a full set of conformations could be generated from a single initial conformation by using multiple energy thresholds.
  • Menthol: Tork was more efficient, finding nearly all 60 known minima, and showed particular advantage when the ring and acyclic parts were analyzed separately.
  • Cyclophane: Tork found more low-energy conformations than LMOD, especially when considering the number of conformations within 1, 2, and 3 kcal/mol of the global minimum.
  • Cyclophane-Menthol Complex: Tork significantly outperformed LMOD in finding low-energy conformations of the complex, highlighting its strength in handling bimolecular systems. For instance, Tork found 10 conformations within 1 kcal/mol of the global minimum, while LMOD found only 1.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Multiple Initial Conformations for Complexes: While Tork is efficient, for complex systems like host-guest complexes, using multiple initial conformations is found to be more effective than relying solely on multiple energy thresholds. This is likely due to the ligand potentially "bumping" or leaving the receptor during large distortions.
  • Computational Cost: While Tork is more efficient, extensive searches can still be computationally demanding, especially for very large or complex systems.
  • Future Work: The authors anticipate Tork will be valuable for designing molecular hosts and for calculating binding affinities using predominant states methods. Further applications in areas like protein-ligand docking and materials design are likely. The ability to factorize searches for complex molecules is also a promising avenue for further optimization.

Summary updated

Abstract

A conformational search method for organic molecules and bimolecular complexes is presented. The method, termed Tork, uses normal-mode analysis in bond-angle-torsion coordinates and focuses on a key subset of torsional coordinates to identify natural molecular motions that lead the initial conformation to new energy minima. New conformations are generated via distortion along these modes and their pairwise combinations, followed by energy minimization. For complexes, special treatment is accorded to the six coordinates that specify the position and orientation of one molecule relative to the other. Tests described here show that Tork is highly efficient for cyclic, acyclic, and mixed single molecules, as well as for host-guest complexes.
BibTeX
@article{chang2003tork,
  author = {Chia‐en A. Chang and Michael K. Gilson},
  title = {{Tork: Conformational analysis method for molecules and complexes}},
  journal = {Journal of Computational Chemistry},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.1002/jcc.10325},
}
Figure