Topology change in causal quantum gravity

J. Ambjørn, Stefan Zohren, R. Loll, W. Westra, Y. WatabikiarXiv 2008 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The role of topology change in a fundamental theory of quantum gravity is still a matter of debate. However, when regarding string theory as two-dimensional quantum gravity, topological fluctuations are essential. Here we present a third quantization of two-dimensional surfaces based on the method of causal dynamical triangulation (CDT). Formally, our construction is similar to the c = 0 non-critical string field theory developed by Ishibashi, Kawai and others, but physically it is quite distinct. Unlike in non-critical string theory the topology change of spatial slices is well controlled and regulated by Newton's constant.

Introduction

In the search for a consistent theory of quantum gravity, two-dimensional models serve as vital theoretical laboratories. Two primary frameworks have historically dominated this landscape: Euclidean Quantum Gravity (via Dynamical Triangulations or DT) and Causal Dynamical Triangulations (CDT). While DT allows for wild fluctuations in geometry and topology—including the branching of "baby universes"—it often results in a "branched polymer" phase that lacks a recognizable semi-classical limit. Conversely, standard CDT enforces a strict causal structure that forbids topology change, yielding more realistic four-dimensional results but creating a conceptual rift with string theory, where topological fluctuations are fundamental.

This research addresses a pivotal question: Is it possible to incorporate topology change within the causal framework of CDT without the theory collapsing into a chaotic, non-physical state?

The Problem of Unregulated Branching

The primary difficulty in allowing universes to split and join is the tendency for the process to become divergent. In Euclidean models, the proliferation of baby universes often dominates the path integral, leading to a fractal-like geometry. In the context of CDT, the challenge is to introduce a mechanism for branching that respects the time-ordering of the causal structure while preventing the "infinite baby universe" problem.

Methodology: The Double Scaling Limit

The authors utilize a discrete approach to spacetime, approximating surfaces through causal dynamical triangulations. To regulate the topology change, they introduce two critical innovations:

1. The Branching Coupling Constant

A specific mathematical weight, or coupling constant $g$, is assigned to every event where a spatial slice splits into two. This allows the frequency of topology change to be tracked and weighted within the partition function.

2. The Double Scaling Limit

To maintain a finite probability of splitting in the continuum limit (as the lattice spacing $a$ approaches zero), the authors propose a "double scaling limit." By scaling the coupling constant $g$ alongside the lattice spacing according to the relation $g = g_s a^3$, the rate of topology change remains controlled. This prevents the physics from being overwhelmed by microscopic fluctuations, effectively "taming" the multiverse.

Third Quantization and String Field Theory

The research shifts the perspective from a "first quantization" (the evolution of a single geometry) to a "third quantization" formalism. This approach is analogous to String Field Theory, where operators are defined to create or annihilate entire one-dimensional universes. By constructing a Hamiltonian that includes these creation and annihilation terms, the authors can explicitly model the dynamics of universes splitting and joining.

This formalism reveals a deep mathematical equivalence: the results obtained by summing over geometric diagrams (the path integral approach) match those derived from solving the Hamiltonian in the field theory approach. This cross-verification reinforces the validity of the regulated model.

Key Results

The study yields several significant analytical results:

  • The Propagator Equation: The authors derived a new partial differential equation for the "proper-time propagator." This equation describes the evolution of a universe over time while accounting for the possibility of branching at any point.
  • Exact Solutions: An exact analytical solution was found for the "disc function," which represents the probability of a universe originating from a point and evolving to a specific spatial boundary.
  • Physical Distinction from String Theory: While the mathematical structure resembles $c=0$ non-critical string theory, the physical interpretation is distinct. In this model, the rate of topology change is regulated by a renormalized version of Newton’s constant, ensuring that topological fluctuations do not destroy the large-scale structure of spacetime.

Discussion and Limitations

While this work successfully integrates topology change into 2D CDT, several challenges remain for a complete theory of quantum gravity. The current model is restricted to two dimensions; extending these "tamed" topological fluctuations to a four-dimensional CDT framework remains a significant hurdle. Furthermore, while the "splitting" of universes is well-handled, the "joining" (merging) process introduces significantly more complex Dyson-Schwinger equations that currently lack simple closed-form solutions. Finally, the current analysis focuses on disc-like topologies, and future research will need to address higher-genus surfaces through the study of higher-loop correlators.

Conclusion

By applying a double scaling limit to the CDT framework, this research demonstrates that topology change is not inherently incompatible with a stable, causal quantum gravity. By using Newton's constant as a regulator, the model allows for a branching multiverse that remains physically sensible, providing a potential bridge between discrete causal models and the topological requirements of string theory.

Summary updated

Abstract

The role of topology change in a fundamental theory of quantum gravity is still a matter of debate. However, when regarding string theory as two-dimensional quantum gravity, topological fluctuations are essential. Here we present a third quantization of two-dimensional surfaces based on the method of causal dynamical triangulation (CDT). Formally, our construction is similar to the c = 0 non-critical string field theory developed by Ishibashi, Kawai and others, but physically it is quite distinct. Unlike in non-critical string theory the topology change of spatial slices is well controlled and regulated by Newton's constant.
BibTeX
@misc{ambjrn2008topology,
  author = {J. Ambjørn and Stefan Zohren and R. Loll and W. Westra and Y. Watabiki},
  title = {{Topology change in causal quantum gravity}},
  year = {2008},
  eprint = {0802.0896},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0802.0896},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure