Topological Origins of Flexibility and Internal Stress in Sodium Aluminosilicate Glasses

Ernest Ching, Mathieu BauchyarXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In the framework of topological constraint theory, network glasses are classified as flexible, stressed–rigid, or isostatic if the number of atomic constraints is smaller, larger, or equal to the number of atomic degrees of freedom. Here, based on molecular dynamics simulations, we show that sodium aluminosilicate glasses exhibit a flexible-to-stressed–rigid transition driven by their composition. This transition manifests itself by a loss of atomic mobility and an onset of internal atomic stress. Importantly, we find that the flexible-to-rigid (i.e., loss of internal flexibility) and unstressed-to-stressed transitions (i.e., onset of internal stress) do not occur at the same composition. This suggests that the isostatic state (i.e., rigid but unstressed) is achieved within a window rather than at a threshold composition.

The Challenge of Glass Design

Sodium aluminosilicate glasses are industrial workhorses, famously used in high-performance products like Corning® Gorilla® Glass due to their exceptional strength and ion-exchange capabilities. However, designing these materials often involves a difficult trade-off between flexibility and internal stress.

This research addresses a fundamental gap in Topological Constraint Theory (TCT). TCT treats a glass network like a mechanical truss: atoms are nodes, and chemical bonds are the beams. If there are too few bonds, the network is "flexible"; too many, and it becomes "stressed-rigid" (over-constrained). The "isostatic" state—where constraints perfectly balance atomic degrees of freedom—is the ideal "Goldilocks" zone for glass stability. While models exist for simpler glasses, a comprehensive topological model for complex sodium aluminosilicates was missing, especially for alumina-rich versions that are difficult to synthesize experimentally.

Computational Methodology

The researchers utilized Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations via the LAMMPS package to study glasses with the formula $(Na_2O)_{30}(SiO_2)_{70-x}(Al_2O_3)_x$, varying $x$ from 0% to 70%. The dataset consists of 15 unique glass compositions simulated across six independent trials each to ensure statistical reliability.

Key technical aspects included:

  • Empirical Potentials: The "Teter potential" was used to model atomic interactions, providing a well-validated basis for these specific glass types.
  • The "Energy Bump" Method: To measure flexibility, the simulated glass was subjected to a 200 meV kinetic energy "bump" to measure the Mean Square Displacement (MSD). Significant atomic displacement indicates a flexible network.
  • Stress per Atom: Local internal stress was calculated for individual atoms based on their Voronoi volume and neighbor forces.
  • Structural Characterization: Oxygen atoms were classified into three types: non-bridging (NBO), bridging (BO), and tricluster (TO), which are critical for counting topological constraints.

Structural Drivers of Rigidity

A key insight from the study is the role of oxygen coordination in driving network rigidity. As alumina content increases, the population of non-bridging oxygens (NBO) decreases, while tricluster oxygens (TO)—oxygen atoms connected to three network formers instead of two—begin to emerge.

Figure 1: Evolution of oxygen species (NBO, BO, TO) as a function of Al2O3 content. Note the disappearance of NBOs and the onset of TOs near 30% Al2O3.

In alumina-rich glasses ($x > 30\%$), these triclusters significantly increase the number of constraints, rapidly driving the glass into a stressed-rigid state. The study confirms that simply counting these "pegs and holes" (atomic constraints) accurately predicts macroscopic physical properties like MSD and internal stress.

Mapping the Isostatic Window

Traditionally, researchers looked for a single "threshold" composition where glass turns from flexible to rigid. This paper argues for an isostatic window. The loss of internal mobility (rigidity) happens at a different composition than the onset of internal stress.

Figure 6: Number of constraints per atom (nc) versus Al2O3 content. The transition through the isostatic threshold (nc = 3) occurs as the network becomes globally connected.

Key results include:

  • Rigidity Transition: At 30% $Al_2O_3$, the MSD drops sharply, marking the percolation threshold where the network becomes globally connected.
  • Stress Transition: Internal stress per silicon atom increases linearly, but a distinct increase in the slope of this stress occurs at 40% $Al_2O_3$.
  • The "Goldilocks" Zone: The region between 30% and 40% $Al_2O_3$ represents the isostatic window. In this range, the glass is rigid (stable) but lacks the high internal stresses that characterize over-constrained, brittle networks.

Limitations and Future Directions

While simulations provide a clear path forward, physical validation of the 40%+ $Al_2O_3$ range remains a challenge due to the poor glass-forming ability of per-aluminous compositions. Additionally, while the theoretical model assumes all Aluminum is four-fold coordinated ($Al^{IV}$), simulations showed up to 10% five-fold coordination ($Al^V$) at high concentrations, suggesting room for further model refinement. Future work could apply this topological model to predict stress profiles during the ion-exchange processes used to toughen commercial glass.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the framework of topological constraint theory, network glasses are classified as flexible, stressed--rigid, or isostatic if the number of atomic constraints is smaller, larger, or equal to the number of atomic degrees of freedom. Here, based on molecular dynamics simulations, we show that sodium aluminosilicate glasses exhibit a flexible-to-stressed--rigid transition driven by their composition. This transition manifests itself by a loss of atomic mobility and an onset of internal atomic stress. Importantly, we find that the flexible-to-rigid (i.e., loss of internal flexibility) and unstressed-to-stressed transitions (i.e., onset of internal stress) do not occur at the same composition. This suggests that the isostatic state (i.e., rigid but unstressed) is achieved within a window rather than at a threshold composition.
BibTeX
@misc{ching2018topological,
  author = {Ernest Ching and Mathieu Bauchy},
  title = {{Topological Origins of Flexibility and Internal Stress in Sodium Aluminosilicate Glasses}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1812.04791},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1812.04791},
}
Figure