Topological insulators with unexpectedly HgTe-like band inversion in hexagonal wurtzite-type binary compounds

X. M. Zhang, R. S., Xingcheng Liu, Guangzhao Xu, Enke Liu, Guodong Liu, Z. Y. Liu, W. H. Wang, Guangheng WuEurophysics Letters (EPL) 2013 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper identifies two new classes of 3D topological insulators (TIs) in hexagonal wurtzite-type binary compounds, AgI and AuI. These materials exhibit an HgTe-like band inversion mechanism, where scalar relativistic effects are crucial for the inversion, while spin-orbit coupling opens the band gap. Uniaxial strain is shown to be a powerful tool for inducing topological phase transitions in these materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Topological insulators (TIs) are a fascinating class of materials that possess an insulating bulk but conduct electricity on their surfaces, with these surface states being protected by topology. While many TIs have been discovered, the search for new materials with unique properties and potential applications continues. The authors focus on hexagonal wurtzite-type binary compounds, a structural class that has been less explored for TI properties compared to cubic structures. They aim to identify new TIs within this structural family and understand the underlying mechanisms driving their topological behavior, particularly how band inversion occurs and the role of spin-orbit coupling (SOC) and strain.

Methods

The researchers employed first-principles calculations, specifically the full-potential linearized augmented plane-wave (LAPW) method implemented in the WIEN2K package. This is a standard and robust computational technique for electronic structure calculations. They calculated the band structures of various compounds, including AgI and AuI, both with and without spin-orbit coupling (SOC). To investigate the role of strain, they simulated both hydrostatic and uniaxial strain by varying lattice constants. The analysis of band inversion was guided by the concept of band ordering and energy level crossings, particularly focusing on the interplay between S and P orbitals.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • HgTe-like behavior in hexagonal structures: The paper demonstrates that the HgTe-like band inversion mechanism (s-orbital inversion with p-orbitals) can occur in hexagonal wurtzite structures, which was previously more commonly associated with cubic materials.
  • Scalar relativistic effects as the driver of band inversion: A key finding is that scalar relativistic (SR) effects, not SOC, are primarily responsible for the band inversion that leads to the topological phase. This challenges the common intuition that SOC is the main driver for topological properties.
  • SOC's role in gap opening: While SR effects drive the inversion, SOC is crucial for opening a global band gap, thus stabilizing the topological insulating phase.
  • Strain as a topological tuning knob: The study highlights the significant impact of strain, particularly uniaxial strain, on tuning the topological order. This suggests a practical pathway for inducing topological phase transitions.
  • AgI and AuI as promising candidates: The identified compounds, AgI and AuI, are predicted to be 3D TIs with naturally opened band gaps, making them interesting for further experimental investigation.

Key Results

  • AgI and AuI identified as 3D TIs: First-principles calculations predict that hexagonal wurtzite AgI and AuI are 3D topological insulators.
  • Band inversion mechanism: Both compounds exhibit an s-Γ₆ - p-Γ₈ band inversion, similar to HgTe.
  • Role of SR and SOC: Scalar relativistic effects are found to be essential for the band inversion, while spin-orbit coupling is responsible for opening the global band gap.
  • Strain-induced topological transitions:
    • Hydrostatic strain shows AgI to be a robust trivial phase, while AuI can transition to a trivial phase at a specific strain.
  • Uniaxial strain is more effective, inducing a topological phase transition in AgI at a/a₀=0.86 and in AuI at a/a₀=1.02.
  • Gap size: AuI exhibits a global energy gap of 63 meV, comparable to well-known TIs like Bi₂Se₃.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental verification: The study is theoretical, and experimental synthesis and characterization of these predicted TIs are needed to confirm the findings. AuI, in particular, has not yet been synthesized in the wurtzite structure.
  • Strain effects on surface states: While the paper discusses bulk band inversion and topological order, a more detailed investigation into how strain affects the topological surface states would be valuable.
  • Exploration of other hexagonal compounds: The authors suggest that their work can be meaningful in widening the circle of topological insulator candidates, implying that further exploration of other hexagonal wurtzite compounds is warranted.
  • Understanding abnormal SOC strength in AuI: The paper notes an "abnormal behavior" where AuI, despite being a heavier atom, exhibits a weaker SOC strength than AgI, which is attributed to the lack of inversion symmetry in the wurtzite structure. Further theoretical and experimental work could delve deeper into this phenomenon.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose new topological insulators in hexagonal wurtzite-type binary compounds based on the first principles calculations. It is found that two compounds AgI and AuI are three-dimensional topological insulators with a naturally opened band-gap at Fermi level. From band inversion mechanism point view, this new family of topological insulators is similar with HgTe, which has s (Gamma 6) - p (Gamma 8) band inversion. Our results strongly support that the spin-orbit coupling is not an essential factor to the band inversion mechanism; on the contrary, it is mainly responsible to the formation of a global band gap for the studied topological insulators. We further theoretically explore the feasibility of tuning the topological order of the studied compounds with two types of strains. The results show that the uniaxial strain can contribute extremely drastic impacts to the band inversion behavior, which provide an effective approach to induce topological phase transition.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2013topological,
  author = {X. M. Zhang and R. S. and Xingcheng Liu and Guangzhao Xu and Enke Liu and Guodong Liu and Z. Y. Liu and W. H. Wang and Guangheng Wu},
  title = {{Topological insulators with unexpectedly HgTe-like band inversion in hexagonal wurtzite-type binary compounds}},
  journal = {Europhysics Letters (EPL)},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1209/0295-5075/103/57012},
}
Figure