Topological gaps without masses in driven graphene-like systems

Thomas Iadecola, Titus Neupert, Claudio ChamonPhysical 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We illustrate the possibility of realizing band gaps in graphene-like systems that fall outside the existing classification of gapped Dirac Hamiltonians in terms of masses. As our primary example we consider a band gap arising due to time-dependent distortions of the honeycomb lattice. By means of an exact, invertible, and transport-preserving mapping to a time-independent Hamiltonian, we show that the system exhibits Chern-insulating phases with quantized Hall conductivities $\pm e^2/h$. The chirality of the corresponding gapless edge modes is controllable by both the frequency of the driving and the manner in which sublattice symmetry is broken by the dynamical lattice modulations. Finally, we discuss a promising possible realization of this physics in photonic lattices.

Introduction

In condensed matter physics, graphene serves as the prototypical system for studying massless Dirac fermions. Traditionally, inducing a topological phase—such as the one described by the Haldane model—requires introducing a "mass term" into the Hamiltonian. This mass term opens a spectral gap, effectively giving particles an inertial weight and transforming the system into a topological insulator.

However, standard classifications of these gaps typically assume an $s$-wave symmetry, where the gap is uniform across all momentum directions. This research explores a fundamental alternative: can topological gaps be generated without traditional mass terms? By employing periodic driving, such as high-frequency lattice vibrations, the authors demonstrate the emergence of gaps with higher angular momentum (e.g., $d$-wave) that transcend standard textbook definitions.

Theoretical Framework and Methods

The study models a honeycomb lattice subjected to time-dependent in-plane deformations, specifically Longitudinal Optical (LO) and Longitudinal Acoustic (LA) phonon modes. To analyze this time-dependent system, the researchers utilized a sophisticated mathematical approach:

  1. Unitary Transformation: A time-dependent gauge transformation shifts the system into a "rotating frame."
  2. Exact Mapping: Unlike common Floquet high-frequency approximations, this mapping is exact and preserves the system's transport properties, including conductivity.
  3. Effective Hamiltonian: The process yields a time-independent Bloch Hamiltonian, allowing for standard topological analysis and the calculation of Chern numbers ($C$).

The model specifically accounts for onsite potential modulation (energy changes as atoms move) and hopping modulation (changes in electron tunneling probability due to bond stretching).

Key Insights: Gaps on a Circle

A defining feature of this driven system is that the gap does not open at a single Dirac point. Instead, the resonance condition in the rotating frame causes the gap to open along a circle (or ellipse) in momentum space.

The energy spectrum $E(p_x, p_y)$ of the driven system. Unlike standard mass gaps at a point, this topological gap $E_g$ opens along a circle of radius $p_0$ in momentum space.

This structure is a hallmark of $d$-wave character. While $d$-wave gaps are well-known in superconductivity, they are rare in non-interacting electronic bands. The research shows that breaking sublattice symmetry (A vs. B) is essential; if both sublattices are driven identically, the gap remains closed.

Topological Phases and Results

The driven system functions as a Chern insulator, exhibiting a quantized Hall conductivity of $\sigma_{xy} = \pm e^2/h$. A significant finding is the controllability of the system's chirality. By adjusting the driving frequency or the relative vibration amplitudes of the sublattices, the direction of edge currents can be reversed.

Phase diagrams illustrating topological control. (a) The Chern number $C$ depends on the relative driving amplitudes of the A and B sublattices. (b) The system can transition between a $d$-wave gap and a Haldane-like phase.

The authors also identify a unique experimental signature: the density of states diverges as $1/\sqrt{E}$ at the conduction band edge when the gap is at finite momentum. Furthermore, they propose that photonic lattices using helical waveguides offer an ideal platform for realization, as the sublattice symmetry can be precisely tuned by varying helix radii.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This work introduces a new class of topological insulators where gaps are induced dynamically rather than through static mass terms. While implementation in bulk graphene faces challenges—specifically the need for differential sublattice excitation—it may occur naturally at flake edges or through dynamical symmetry breaking.

Future research will explore the impact of electron-electron interactions on these "non-mass" gaps. Ultimately, this study paves the way for a broader classification of gapped Dirac Hamiltonians, potentially uncovering even more exotic topological states in both electronic and bosonic systems.

Reference: Iadecola, T., Neupert, T., & Chamon, C. (2014). Topological gaps without masses in driven graphene-like systems. arXiv:1311.5231v3.

Summary updated

Abstract

We illustrate the possibility of realizing band gaps in graphene-like systems that fall outside the existing classification of gapped Dirac Hamiltonians in terms of masses. As our primary example we consider a band gap arising due to time-dependent distortions of the honeycomb lattice. By means of an exact, invertible, and transport-preserving mapping to a time-independent Hamiltonian, we show that the system exhibits Chern-insulating phases with quantized Hall conductivities $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}{e}^{2}/h$. The chirality of the corresponding gapless edge modes is controllable by both the frequency of the driving and the manner in which sublattice symmetry is broken by the dynamical lattice modulations. Finally, we discuss a promising possible realization of this physics in photonic lattices.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{iadecola2014topological,
  author = {Thomas Iadecola and Titus Neupert and Claudio Chamon},
  title = {{Topological gaps without masses in driven graphene-like systems}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.89.115425},
}
Figure