Abstract: We consider new physics contributions to the top-quark forward-backward asymmetry from a neutral ${V}_{8}^{0}$ or charged ${V}_{8}^{+}$ color-octet vector exchanged in the $t$ channel. We study the phenomenological constraints on these particles arising from the Tevatron and LHC7 measurements and compare them with those on their color-singlet counterparts ${Z}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ and ${W}^{\ensuremath{'}}$. We find that the color octets fare better than the singlets in that they generate a lower ${A}_{C}$, a lower high-invariant mass cross section at LHC7 and a lower same sign top-pair cross section. However, they also generate a lower ${A}_{\mathrm{FB}}$ than their color-singlet counterparts.
Introduction
In the late 2000s and early 2010s, experiments at the Tevatron (D0 and CDF) observed a significant anomaly in top-quark production: the forward-backward asymmetry ($A_{FB}$) was measured at approximately 20%, far exceeding the Standard Model (SM) prediction of ~6%. While initial attempts to explain this discrepancy focused on new $Z'$ or $W'$ bosons, these models faced severe constraints from the LHC's measurements of charge asymmetry ($A_C$) and high-mass top-pair production cross-sections. This paper investigates whether color-octet vector particles ($V^0_8$ and $V^+_8$) exchanged in the $t$-channel can provide a more consistent explanation.
Methodology
The researchers employed an effective Lagrangian approach to model neutral ($V^0_8$) and charged ($V^+_8$) color-octet vectors. The study focused on the unique color algebra of $t$-channel exchange, where octets exhibit different interference patterns with the SM gluon compared to color-singlets. Simulations were performed using FeynRules and MadGraph5 to generate top-quark pair production events. The resulting observables were fitted to quartic polynomials of the coupling constants ($g_{ZR}$ and $g_{WR}$), allowing for a systematic comparison against experimental data from the Tevatron and the 7 TeV LHC.
Comparative Analysis of Color-Octet and Color-Singlet Models
A central finding is the trade-off between generating sufficient asymmetry and remaining within cross-section limits. Color-octet models naturally produce lower charge asymmetry ($A_C$) and smaller high-mass cross-section tails at the LHC, making them more compatible with experimental bounds than their color-singlet counterparts.
As shown in the figure above, the color-octet model (left) exhibits a more constrained relationship between asymmetry and cross-section deviation. While $Z'$ models (right, $V^0$) can actually decrease the total cross-section through destructive interference, they often fail other constraints like same-sign top production. Color-octets significantly reduce the same-sign top rate, easing tension with ATLAS and CMS limits.
High-Mass Asymmetry and Experimental Constraints
The study also examined how the asymmetry evolves at higher invariant masses ($m_{tt} > 450$ GeV). While color-octets are "stealthier" at the LHC, they struggle to produce the large $A_{FB}$ values initially reported by the Tevatron without violating total cross-section limits.
The analysis indicates that color-octets can contribute a "new physics" $A_{FB}$ of approximately 5-7%. While this helps bridge the gap between the SM and experimental data, it does not fully account for the highest reported anomalies. Neutral octets ($V^0_8$) are generally preferred over charged ones ($V^+_8$) as they better match the LHC's charge asymmetry measurements.
Conclusion
Color-octet $t$-channel resonances offer a promising, albeit constrained, path for explaining the top-quark asymmetry anomaly. They fare better than color-singlets regarding LHC compatibility, particularly in high-mass tails and same-sign top production. However, the modest asymmetry they generate suggests that a full explanation may require more complex models or higher-order corrections. Future studies at higher LHC energies will further restrict the viable parameter space for these particles.
Summary updated