Tolerance analysis of multiple-element linear retrodirective cross-eye jamming

Tianpeng Liu, Wei Xizhang, Bo Peng, Zhen Liu, Bin Sun, Guan ZhiqiangJournal of Systems Engineering and Electronics 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Tolerance sensitivity limits the practical application of the cross-eye jammer. Previous literature has demonstrated that retrodirective cross-eye jamming with multiple antenna elements possesses the advantage of loose tolerance requirements compared to traditional cross-eye jamming. However, the previous analysis was limited, because there are still some factors affecting the parameter tolerance of the multiple-element retrodirective cross-eye jamming (MRCJ) system and they have not been investigated completely, such as the loop difference, the baseline ratio and the jammer-to-signal ratio. This paper performs a comprehensive tolerance analysis of the MRCJ system with a nonuniform-spacing linear array. Simulation results demonstrate the tolerance effects of the above influence factors and give reasonable advice for easing tolerance sensitivity.

Introduction

Monopulse radars are widely regarded as the gold standard for precision tracking due to their inherent resistance to traditional noise or repeater jamming. Cross-eye jamming is one of the few electronic countermeasure techniques capable of inducing significant angular error (glint) in these systems. By transmitting two signals with nearly identical amplitudes but opposite phases ($180^\circ$ apart), a jammer can deceive the radar into tracking an "apparent target" far from the actual platform.

However, traditional two-element jammers are highly sensitive to hardware imperfections. Minor deviations in amplitude or phase can cause the jamming effect to collapse. Multiple-element Retrodirective Cross-eye Jamming (MRCJ) has been proposed to mitigate these strict tolerances. This paper provides a rigorous analysis of Linear MRCJ (L-MRCJ), accounting for previously ignored real-world factors such as non-uniform antenna spacing, internal circuit differences between jammer loops, and the platform's natural radar cross-section (skin return).

System Modeling and Methodology

The research develops a mathematical framework for an L-MRCJ system utilizing $N$ antenna elements. The effectiveness of the jamming is quantified by the "angle factor" ($G_\theta$), which represents the ratio of the induced angular error to the radar's half-beamwidth.

Geometric model of the L-MRCJ system showing the monopulse radar and the multi-element jammer array.

The methodology involves:

  • Geometric Modeling: Defining the spatial relationship between the radar, the jammer array, and the resulting apparent target.
  • Gain Derivation: Formulating both "isolated" cross-eye gain and "statistical" gain, the latter of which incorporates the platform's skin return.
  • Tolerance Contours: Generating visual "safe zones" that map the range of allowable amplitude and phase errors for a given performance level.

Simulations were conducted using a 9 GHz radar model and a 4-element jammer array with a 10m total baseline at a range of 1 km. The study specifically examined the impact of varying the Jammer-to-Signal Ratio (JSR) and antenna baseline ratios.

Tolerance Analysis and Key Results

The analysis reveals that internal phase mismatches between jammer loops are the most critical factor affecting system stability. As the phase difference between loops ($\Delta\phi_n$) increases, the tolerance zones for hardware errors shrink and become skewed, significantly complicating system calibration.

Tolerance contours of the angle factor for different loop phase differences, illustrating how the 'safe zone' shrinks as phase error increases.

Key findings include:

  • The Phase Killer: Phase differences are far more destructive than amplitude differences. While the system can tolerate up to 10 dB of amplitude difference between loops if the phase is controlled, even small phase drifts drastically reduce the effective jamming area.
  • Baseline Optimization: A larger baseline ratio (approximately 0.8) is recommended. Placing inner antennas closer to the outer elements improves tolerance compared to uniform spacing, which can introduce antenna isolation issues.
  • JSR and Skin Return: The Jammer-to-Signal Ratio (JSR) is a decisive factor. At a low JSR (e.g., 10 dB), the platform's natural skin return interferes with the jamming signal, leading to unstable angular errors. High JSR values (30 dB) effectively mask the skin return, allowing for much looser hardware tolerances.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that while multi-element MRCJ systems offer improved robustness over traditional designs, they remain highly sensitive to internal phase synchronization and the signal environment. For practical deployment, maintaining a high JSR and optimizing antenna baseline ratios are essential strategies for easing hardware requirements. Future research should address dynamic scenarios involving relative motion and the non-linear behaviors of real-world hardware components.

Summary updated

Abstract

Tolerance sensitivity limits the practical application of the cross-eye jammer. Previous literature has demonstrated that retrodirective cross-eye jamming with multiple antenna elements possesses the advantage of loose tolerance requirements compared to traditional cross-eye jamming. However, the previous analysis was limited, because there are still some factors affecting the parameter tolerance of the multiple-element retrodirective cross-eye jamming (MRCJ) system and they have not been investigated completely, such as the loop difference, the baseline ratio and the jammer-to-signal ratio. This paper performs a comprehensive tolerance analysis of the MRCJ system with a nonuniform-spacing linear array. Simulation results demonstrate the tolerance effects of the above influence factors and give reasonable advice for easing tolerance sensitivity.
BibTeX
@article{liu2020tolerance,
  author = {Tianpeng Liu and Wei Xizhang and Bo Peng and Zhen Liu and Bin Sun and Guan Zhiqiang},
  title = {{Tolerance analysis of multiple-element linear retrodirective cross-eye jamming}},
  journal = {Journal of Systems Engineering and Electronics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.23919/jsee.2020.000028},
}
Figure